Elimination: Sci-fi edition

[Thorthoth]

Sounds good, I'll go next.
One other change, we really should/must split the Original Star Trek and Original Star Wars from all of the later disasters.
I think we'll find a lot of the inconstant flux in the data stream will diminish with this necessary modification.

Star Wars Original (eps. 4-6)-------34
Star Wars All Others-------32
Doctor Who----60
Mass Effect-----51
Star Trek Original-------45
Star Trek All Others-------44
HALO-----------39
Matrix----------47
Stargate---62
Transformers---21
Gears of War---36
Starcraft--------44

[mrswdk]

To be fair... I have ignored mrswdk's changes, but mine have also been ignored.

No they weren't. All my posts took into account the franchises that you shaded red and green.

[Dukasaur]

To be fair... I have ignored mrswdk's changes, but mine have also been ignored.

No they weren't. All my posts took into account the franchises that you shaded red and green.

For the record, this is the truth.

I checked the math yesterday, mrswdk has been fairly counting jb's votes.

[Thorthoth]

No need to argue, I think we can all agree that it was a particularly stupid game anyway.

[Dukasaur]

No need to argue, I think we can all agree that it was a particularly stupid game anyway.

It IS a remarkably stupid game. Pointless even by the low standards of this forum. Nonetheless, let's get it over with. (For a Catholic, I have an amazingly Protestant work ethic.)


Star Wars--------------49
Doctor Who------------54
Mass Effect-------------51
Star Trek---------------9
HALO------------------37
Matrix-----------------48
Stargate----------------35
Transformers-----------15
Gears of War------------36
Starcraft----------------44

[Thorthoth]

This is just outrageous...

Star Wars--------------47
Doctor Who------------54
Mass Effect-------------51
Star Trek---------------10
HALO------------------37
Matrix-----------------48
Stargate----------------35
Transformers-----------15
Gears of War------------36
Starcraft----------------44

[mrswdk]

Yayyyyy

Let's sterilize this puppy once and for all!

Star Wars---------------47
Doctor Who------------54
Mass Effect-------------51
Star Trek----------------8
HALO--------------------37
Matrix------------------49
Stargate-----------------35
Transformers-----------15
Gears of War------------36
Starcraft----------------44

[Thorthoth]

mr. swdk = Jarjar Binks


Star Wars---------------45
Doctor Who------------54
Mass Effect-------------51
Star Trek----------------9
HALO--------------------37
Matrix------------------49
Stargate-----------------35
Transformers-----------15
Gears of War------------36
Starcraft----------------44

[jimboston]

Star Wars---------------43
Doctor Who------------54
Mass Effect-------------51
Star Trek----------------10
HALO--------------------37
Matrix------------------49[/color]
Stargate-----------------35
Transformers-----------15
Gears of War------------36
Starcraft----------------44

[jimboston]

So we're not going to go back to where we agree?

[jimboston]

To be fair... I have ignored mrswdk's changes, but mine have also been ignored.

No they weren't. All my posts took into account the franchises that you shaded red and green.

For the record, this is the truth.

I checked the math yesterday, mrswdk has been fairly counting jb's votes.

There are definitely some math errors in there.
There are also some serious procedural errors.

[Dukasaur]

To be fair... I have ignored mrswdk's changes, but mine have also been ignored.

No they weren't. All my posts took into account the franchises that you shaded red and green.

For the record, this is the truth.

I checked the math yesterday, mrswdk has been fairly counting jb's votes.

There are definitely some math errors in there.
There are also some serious procedural errors.

I went through the bulk of the thread and I didn't find any math errors. I'll admit I did it quickly and something might have slipped past me, but I'm not going through it all again. If you can link directly to a math error, I'll have a look.

As far as procedural errors, there's way too much double-posting, but everyone has done it, so we'll let it go.

The biggest procedural error is you wasting 10 months on the delusion that you somehow had the right to disqualify someone. Luckily that someone continued counting your votes even while you posted delusional totals, so the totals are still more or less correct.

It is a really, really stupid game. Basically, whoever posts most often and most consistently can eliminate whatever they want to eliminate, so the entire nub of the game is about who wants to waste the largest share of their life checking this thread. Thus far, it's been mrswdk. And since it's add 1 subtract 2, you need at least two people equally dedicated to saving something to overcome one person dedicated to killing it. You'd need three dedicated people to make any headway back up river.

[mrswdk]

TT please using the correct color codes thanks ^_^

Star Wars---------------43
Doctor Who------------54
Mass Effect-------------51
Star Trek-----------------8
HALO--------------------37
Matrix-------------------50
Stargate-----------------35
Transformers-----------15
Gears of War------------36
Starcraft----------------44

[Thorthoth]

I'm delegating that job to you, swdk.
I'm too busy and important for that.

Star Wars---------------41
Doctor Who------------54
Mass Effect-------------51
Star Trek-----------------9
HALO--------------------37
Matrix-------------------50
Stargate-----------------35
Transformers-----------15
Gears of War------------36
Starcraft----------------44

P.S. Even if Star Trek is eliminated, that will in no way tarnish the glorious legacy of Kirk. It will only confirm that mr. swdk is a rimjobbing tool of bad sci-fi.

[jimboston]

Star Wars---------------39
Doctor Who------------54
Mass Effect-------------51
Star Trek-----------------10
HALO--------------------37
Matrix-------------------50
Stargate-----------------35
Transformers-----------15
Gears of War------------36
Starcraft----------------44

[jimboston]

TT if we work together we can SAVE STAR TREK.

I don't hate Star Wars... but Star Trek certainly deserves to last longer than some of those other "franchises".

[Dukasaur]

Star Wars---------------39
Doctor Who------------54
Mass Effect-------------51
Star Trek-----------------11
HALO--------------------37
Matrix-------------------50
Stargate-----------------35
Transformers-----------15
Gears of War------------34
Starcraft----------------44

[mrswdk]

Star Wars---------------40
Doctor Who------------54
Mass Effect-------------51
Star Trek-----------------9
HALO--------------------37
Matrix-------------------50
Stargate-----------------35
Transformers-----------15
Gears of War------------34
Starcraft----------------44

Star Trek sucks almost as hard as TT.

[Dukasaur]

Star Wars---------------41
Doctor Who------------54
Mass Effect-------------51
Star Trek-----------------9
HALO--------------------37
Matrix-------------------50
Stargate-----------------35
Transformers-----------15
Gears of War------------32
Starcraft----------------44

[mrswdk]

Star Wars---------------42
Doctor Who------------54
Mass Effect-------------51
Star Trek-----------------7
HALO--------------------37
Matrix-------------------50
Stargate-----------------35
Transformers-----------15
Gears of War------------32
Starcraft----------------44

Down dowwwwwn, deeper and down.

[Thorthoth]

There is o need for me to play this lame game.
Everytime, that despicable swdk takes points away from the Trek it only rises in honor and esteem.
Take it to 0, swdk. Take it into negative numbers, even. I don't care. Your pathetic actions will in no way harm the greatness of Kirk's Enterprise.

[mrswdk]

It is more than one year since the now-deceased ThotPatrol made the most recent post in this thread. I nominate you, the reader, to revive this esteemed game.

[bigtoughralf]

Star Wars---------------43
Doctor Who------------54
Mass Effect-------------51
Star Trek-----------------5
HALO--------------------37
Matrix-------------------50
Stargate-----------------35
Transformers-----------15
Gears of War------------32
Starcraft----------------44

[Votanic]

??
So then, ...mrswdk nominated itself?