Moderator: Community Team
virus90 wrote:ok i skip the jokevote stage
vote:mtambrini
virus90 wrote:ok i skip the jokevote stage
vote:mtambrini
jak111 wrote:Charm has been probed.
HotShot53 wrote:Hmm... I guess this is a problem with smaller games... harder to get things started.
charm wrote:I would have know had I been probed! No such probing here!
I'm checking in and vote MTAM because he is my favorite!!!
Just rented 1st season of Game of Thrones - I'm ready to do battle!! Ooops, tha tis the other game!
Whatsausage wrote:jak111 wrote:Charm has been probed.
Gross.charm wrote:Found it! Mod did probe me!!
iAmCaffeine wrote:There are only going to be two/three mafia right? We don't have to lynch.
jonty125 wrote:iAmCaffeine wrote:There are only going to be two/three mafia right? We don't have to lynch.
Two mafia in a 8 player game. 3 mafia puts us at MYLO on D1. And come on Caffeine you know no lynch on D1, is only for extenuating circumstances. Giving in to a no lynch [at this stage of the day] gives us no information to D2. And how many PR's do you think we have in a 6 town v 2 mafia? I reckon 2 at best, cop and doc. If town have cop, mafia will probably have GF, if town don't have cop mafia won't have GF.
iAmCaffeine wrote:jonty125 wrote:iAmCaffeine wrote:There are only going to be two/three mafia right? We don't have to lynch.
Two mafia in a 8 player game. 3 mafia puts us at MYLO on D1. And come on Caffeine you know no lynch on D1, is only for extenuating circumstances. Giving in to a no lynch [at this stage of the day] gives us no information to D2. And how many PR's do you think we have in a 6 town v 2 mafia? I reckon 2 at best, cop and doc. If town have cop, mafia will probably have GF, if town don't have cop mafia won't have GF.
Okay, now that I've recovered from my hangover I can think clearly. I'd be surprised if town had more than two PRs, so we agree there.
Your standard game of mafia has seven players, two of whom are mafia. In an eight player game I'd expect there to be one neutral party, maybe a fool that wins if they get lynched, or something along those lines. I don't really see an 8 player game being very balanced with 5v3 or 6v2, although it also depends on the PRs.
The logic of no cop therefore no GF is flawed. What are you even basing that on? The standard mafia game has a doc, cop and two vanilla mafia.
Whatsausage wrote:jak111 wrote:Charm has been probed.
Gross.HotShot53 wrote:Hmm... I guess this is a problem with smaller games... harder to get things started.
Every game kinda starts like this in my experience, nothing to go on before anyone has said anything haha
virus90 wrote:i rather pressure someone for a claim before we decide to not lynch, else you dont have much more intel day 2, unless everyone strikes gold with their nightactions n1
iAmCaffeine wrote:There are only going to be two/three mafia right? We don't have to lynch.
jonty125 wrote:iAmCaffeine wrote:There are only going to be two/three mafia right? We don't have to lynch.
Two mafia in a 8 player game. 3 mafia puts us at MYLO on D1. And come on Caffeine you know no lynch on D1, is only for extenuating circumstances. Giving in to a no lynch [at this stage of the day] gives us no information to D2. And how many PR's do you think we have in a 6 town v 2 mafia? I reckon 2 at best, cop and doc. If town have cop, mafia will probably have GF, if town don't have cop mafia won't have GF.
Nebuchadnezer wrote:Well,I don't think everyone checked in, did they?
Where is charm?
This was by far the best post of the day...virus90 wrote:ok i skip the jokevote stage
vote:mtambrini
Nebuchadnezer wrote:Gf in a eight person game would render the cop all but useless.
But this is good talk. I'm going to get serious and unvote. Vote whatsausage.
It's day one. This post didn't sit right with me.Whatsausage wrote:jak111 wrote:Charm has been probed.
Gross.HotShot53 wrote:Hmm... I guess this is a problem with smaller games... harder to get things started.
Every game kinda starts like this in my experience, nothing to go on before anyone has said anything haha
mtamburini wrote:My top 2 suspects right now are Jonty and neb
Neb is leaning more towny atm I like his recent posts.
Unvote. vote jonty
I think this is some good pressure for today.
Neb can you explain this post.Nebuchadnezer wrote:Well,I don't think everyone checked in, did they?
Where is charm?
This was by far the best post of the day...virus90 wrote:ok i skip the jokevote stage
vote:mtambrini
mtamburini wrote:My top 2 suspects right now are Jonty and neb
Neb is leaning more towny atm I like his recent posts.
Unvote. vote jonty
I think this is some good pressure for today.
Neb can you explain this post.Nebuchadnezer wrote:Well,I don't think everyone checked in, did they?
Where is charm?
This was by far the best post of the day...virus90 wrote:ok i skip the jokevote stage
vote:mtambrini
Whatsausage wrote:Nebuchadnezer wrote:Gf in a eight person game would render the cop all but useless.
But this is good talk. I'm going to get serious and unvote. Vote whatsausage.
It's day one. This post didn't sit right with me.Whatsausage wrote:jak111 wrote:Charm has been probed.
Gross.HotShot53 wrote:Hmm... I guess this is a problem with smaller games... harder to get things started.
Every game kinda starts like this in my experience, nothing to go on before anyone has said anything haha
Looks like someone didn't like my joke
But more seriously, what I meant was that we don't have any information past our role and the number of players at the beginning of the game and it is hard to push on anyone until someone says something stupid, which it seems like you think I did.
Really my post was just a general captain obvious statement
@mtam, I do agree that I thought it was interesting that he kept bringing up the GF role, so I can understand jonty, but why did you have neb as a suspect?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users