Cleared Kyaljs [DCR]

[ChrisPond]

Accused:Kyaljs




The accused are suspected of: point dumping...making a mockery of the monthly leader board, namely most improved player.


Game number(s):

Game 13765200
Game 13765201
Game 13765202
Game 13765204
Game 13765205
Game 13763124

there are more games not listed that finished before January 1st but I figured this list was a good start.

Comments: the player begin deadbeating games around December 26th driving his score down before January 1st. the player appears to have come back and started playing games around January 4th. He is now first on the list of most improved player for the month of January but his accomplishment is blemished by the fact that he lost a lot of points at the end of December due to the deadbeating. He may very well have been the leader without artificially lowering score but this sets a precedent that you can deadbeat games and be rewarded.

[ChrisPond]

i spent 5 more minutes and found some addition games

Game 13779276
Game 13779277
Game 13779278
Game 13779279
Game 13779280
Game 13779281
Game 13779282
Game 13779387
Game 13779388
Game 13779389
Game 13779390
Game 13779391


it looks like he has won most improved player for January. i know there are more games as well that were deadbeated right at the end of the month.

[JOHNNYROCKET24]

Game 13841477

dead beated

[iAmCaffeine]

This needs sorting out.. Dumb scoreboard.

[king achilles]

Are there any games there where he was missing turns and yet he made a turn on another?

[MrPinky]

He just missed 2 turns in a row in several games in an autotournament. But he was not logged in during this time at all. And he returned to play 3rd time. He could just be a casual player that goes offline for days at a time. And although annoying, it is not cheating.

[jltile1]

i spent 5 more minutes and found some addition games

Game 13779276
Game 13779277
Game 13779278
Game 13779279
Game 13779280
Game 13779281
Game 13779282
Game 13779387
Game 13779388
Game 13779389
Game 13779390
Game 13779391


it looks like he has won most improved player for January. i know there are more games as well that were deadbeated right at the end of the month.

Looks like you should add a player to this report.

[iAmCaffeine]

i spent 5 more minutes and found some addition games

Game 13779276
Game 13779277
Game 13779278
Game 13779279
Game 13779280
Game 13779281
Game 13779282
Game 13779387
Game 13779388
Game 13779389
Game 13779390
Game 13779391


it looks like he has won most improved player for January. i know there are more games as well that were deadbeated right at the end of the month.

Looks like you should add a player to this report.

Are you suggesting adding Gamefreakguy? They're tournament games..

[ChrisPond]

He may be a casual player and go off line and deadbeat out of games but he did it at the end of the month and lost points. Then he won "most improved player" the next month. If this is ok, then there is a precedent to go off line and deadbeat lots of games to point dump and then come back the next month and win the most improved contest.

[CatchersMitt14]

Are there any games there where he was missing turns and yet he made a turn on another?

Yes, he does seem to be picking and choosing which games he plays. He joined 4/5 of the terminator games I set up at the same time for the January challenge. They have the same settings and have been progressing at about the same rate. I was starting to wonder about him point dumping as well since he started missing a lot (but not all) of his turns at the end of January/beginning of February and he's keeping several of these games from ending in time for the challenge medal.

He has missed at least one turn in most of the games. He was just kicked out of Game 13815817 for missing too many turns.
2014-02-03 09:40:07 - Kyaljs missed a turn
2014-02-04 19:21:24 - Kyaljs missed a turn
2014-02-06 18:59:53 - Kyaljs missed a turn
2014-02-06 18:59:53 - Kyaljs was kicked out for missing too many turns

He missed two turns in Game 13815815 then just played this past round to keep him in the game. He played this turn at the same time he could've played the turn in the above game.
2014-02-05 19:56:01 - Kyaljs received 3 troops for 5 regions
2014-02-05 19:56:03 - Kyaljs received 6 deferred troops for missing 2 rounds
2014-02-05 19:56:11 - Kyaljs deployed 3 troops on G2
2014-02-05 19:56:27 - Kyaljs assaulted G1 from G2 and conquered it from Marshmelows
2014-02-05 19:56:33 - Kyaljs assaulted G5 from G6 and conquered it from Marshmelows
2014-02-05 19:56:45 - Kyaljs deployed 6 troops on G5
2014-02-05 19:56:51 - Kyaljs ended the turn and got spoils

Missed one turn in Game 13815818 before he was eliminated.

Game 13815816 he played all his turns and the game ended in January.

We are also playing against each other in a doubles game where he has missed the past two turns. Game 13813132
2014-02-03 08:29:28 - Kyaljs missed a turn
2014-02-05 17:49:44 - Kyaljs missed a turn

[Vinyl-Taliban]

I'm involved in a similar game involving Kyaljs: Game 13951008

Even more frustrating is he missed 2 turns, then dropped 14 and is likely to win the game...but alas.

I noticed he dropped ~ 4 ranks since that game above started.

[ChrisPond]

After hitting somewhere around 2300 at the end of January, his score is now 1392. I have not checked to see if he also slow played his losses and fast played his wins or if he is just on a horrible losing streak. He was on top of the score board for most improved player in January though

[deathcomesrippin]

Kyaljs is cleared of point dumping.

He has explained the situation to us, and it seemed legitimate. I will not explain it, but we have contacted him, looked into what he said, and we agree with his story.

[iAmCaffeine]

[ChrisPond]

+1

the most improved scoreboard is a joke!

and his score is now down to 1203

[iAmCaffeine]

Sounds like the mods bought a lame excuse and he's doing it again.

[Masli]

Not everybody has a sitter iAmCaffeine
The 1st couple of years that I played, I had no sitter either and was not able to play in weekends or holidays. I missed a lot of turns because of that.

[iAmCaffeine]

Not everybody has a sitter iAmCaffeine
The 1st couple of years that I played, I had no sitter either and was not able to play in weekends or holidays. I missed a lot of turns because of that.

That's all well and good. This is abuse though.

[rishaed]

Are there any games there where he was missing turns and yet he made a turn on another?

Yes, he does seem to be picking and choosing which games he plays. He joined 4/5 of the terminator games I set up at the same time for the January challenge. They have the same settings and have been progressing at about the same rate. I was starting to wonder about him point dumping as well since he started missing a lot (but not all) of his turns at the end of January/beginning of February and he's keeping several of these games from ending in time for the challenge medal.

He has missed at least one turn in most of the games. He was just kicked out of Game 13815817 for missing too many turns.
2014-02-03 09:40:07 - Kyaljs missed a turn
2014-02-04 19:21:24 - Kyaljs missed a turn
2014-02-06 18:59:53 - Kyaljs missed a turn
2014-02-06 18:59:53 - Kyaljs was kicked out for missing too many turns

He missed two turns in Game 13815815 then just played this past round to keep him in the game. He played this turn at the same time he could've played the turn in the above game.
2014-02-05 19:56:01 - Kyaljs received 3 troops for 5 regions
2014-02-05 19:56:03 - Kyaljs received 6 deferred troops for missing 2 rounds
2014-02-05 19:56:11 - Kyaljs deployed 3 troops on G2
2014-02-05 19:56:27 - Kyaljs assaulted G1 from G2 and conquered it from Marshmelows
2014-02-05 19:56:33 - Kyaljs assaulted G5 from G6 and conquered it from Marshmelows
2014-02-05 19:56:45 - Kyaljs deployed 6 troops on G5
2014-02-05 19:56:51 - Kyaljs ended the turn and got spoils

Missed one turn in Game 13815818 before he was eliminated.

Game 13815816 he played all his turns and the game ended in January.

We are also playing against each other in a doubles game where he has missed the past two turns. Game 13813132
2014-02-03 08:29:28 - Kyaljs missed a turn
2014-02-05 17:49:44 - Kyaljs missed a turn

I don't know what excuse he gave, but this is weird here for me. I understand that you can pick and choose, but when you have internet access its usually more than enough to take turns in multiple games, and if hes missing in one, but playing in another the take me to next playable game link always works to avoid issues. And if he has too many games, he is still responsible for joining and finishing them to the best of his ability. Also he should roughly know how long games usually last and plan around things like weekends and holidays (because they are static and cannot be considered unavoidable factors.) Also this example above also would disprove holidays and weekends IMO. Like i said if Im taking turns on CC i usually have a 10-20 minute block minimum. Usually 30 min to avoid problems. Taking turns in 4 games is roughly between 5-10 depending on internet speed. And if your internet is bad enough that it takes 5-10 for one game then that should limit the amount of games you join anyways.
Just My Opinion here ya know.

[ChrisPond]

I honestly never would have made this report if not for him winning the most improved player. No one would care about the abuse. But since u get a reward for being most improved, the abuse should not be accepted.

[deathcomesrippin]

The stretch of games where he deadbeated out of them were accounted for. As for any other individual turns missed after that time period, people miss turns. It happens. I miss turns all the time as other things get in the way. The batch of games that were posted are excused, and that is that whether you like the response or not, grow up and deal with it. This case is closed. Let it be.

[iAmCaffeine]

The stretch of games where he deadbeated out of them were accounted for. As for any other individual turns missed after that time period, people miss turns. It happens. I miss turns all the time as other things get in the way. The batch of games that were posted are excused, and that is that whether you like the response or not, grow up and deal with it. This case is closed. Let it be.

I'm not looking to start an argument here but stooping to insults is low DCR. We disagree with the decision. The abuse is obvious, unless he magically gets busy in time to win the leaderboard every other month, which seems to be the intention.

[rishaed]

The stretch of games where he deadbeated out of them were accounted for. As for any other individual turns missed after that time period, people miss turns. It happens. I miss turns all the time as other things get in the way. The batch of games that were posted are excused, and that is that whether you like the response or not, grow up and deal with it. This case is closed. Let it be.

I was only looking for an explanation. For above reasons, along the lines of missing games because you were on holiday, and didn't plan for it is unacceptable. Also seeing the recent amount of abuse with the Scoreboards, and the hassle its brought the C&A Team, it might be better to just get rid of it for the most part to prevent further abuse, resulting directly from it. I hoped when you said you had an "verification" that it was true and not just from the player. Also I would like to point out that when you miss those turns you miss all of them, not taking one and leaving the other. And if you have to leave them for later, then you take the most pressing turns. However nothing here is going to change in this case so Caffiene lets stop beating our head against the brick wall here.