Two Sides Mafia: Side A, Endgame, The Old Ways

[Some7hingCLEVER]

Wow, I never even got a word in lol.

sorry i didnt even notice there was only 7 people now

[jonty125]

I only just logged in, and WOW!

New guy, can you share with us your results from night one as well.

[new guy1]

... I did. Rodion's Side A was town result.

[jonty125]

... I did. Rodion's Side A was town result.

My bad, it was the same post as you investigative on saf, so it took a lower priority in my memory.

[Some7hingCLEVER]

... I did. Rodion's Side A was town result.

My bad, it was the same post as you investigative on saf, so it took a lower priority in my memory.

lol your memory can take priority

[shieldgenerator7]

... I did. Rodion's Side A was town result.

My bad, it was the same post as you investigative on saf, so it took a lower priority in my memory.

lol your memory can take priority

lshicastr

Go town! I'll tell my night actions in Side B.

-SG7 ( )

[Rodion]

Ok, on Night 1 in Side A I protected Rodion, and then last night I also protected Rodion, so either Rodion was targetted or I was because as Bodyguard I die instead of my target if my target is targetted for a night kill (that was coherent, right?)

Yes, that was coherent. I do think I was targeted, though, as flavour clearly indicates you drank poison that was meant for someone else.

"Here try this, it's my godfather's special recipe" said one person to another as they handed over a small paper cup of wine, just as the second was about to take a lick, a third intervened, "NO! No one eat anything until I try it first!"

Anyway, mafia A tried to kill me N2. And assuming Safari flips mafia, I have the sad feeling New Guy B won't be of much use in finding the remaining mafia (godfathers are usually immune to investigations and if the 2nd killer is a SK he might also be immune to that). N3 will start with 6 players, probably 5-1 or 4-1-1. I'm cleared (not so much by New Guy's investigation because of the presumed existence of a godfather, but more due to the flavour scene indicating mafia targeted me N2). From what I understand, VS A clears New Guy B and New Guy B clears VS A (due to being masoned - if I understand things correctly, they can't clear NG A or VS B, though). In other words, the non-cleared A players are New Guy A, Jonty A, Edocsil A and Clever A and 1 or 2 of those are anti-town.

[new guy1]

Well if it will help I will confirm my Side A role as it is not powerful at all and so it is not a huge loss.

[Rodion]

Well if it will help I will confirm my Side A role as it is not powerful at all and so it is not a huge loss.

Not sure what you mean by confirming, but if it's making you innefective (like a tree stump), do not confirm. Did you meant claiming instead? Don't claim, just answer.

[new guy1]

Yes, I meant claiming.

[shieldgenerator7]

WHat a dick move replying to me in the thread I can't post in

-SG7 ( )

[Rodion]

Looks like the only way to get Side A Mafia to go all-in into helping Town B is by beating them here.

Edoc, New Guy, Clever - if you killed Drunkmonkey, claim now.

[Some7hingCLEVER]

Looks like the only way to get Side A Mafia to go all-in into helping Town B is by beating them here.

Edoc, New Guy, Clever - if you killed Drunkmonkey, claim now.

i did not kill drunkmonkey last night. and if new guy is mafia in side b and he investigates into side a then would he be mafia on the other side. it would just make his side b role pretty much useless since he knows who the town is. so that leaves edoc.

[edocsil]

Looks like the only way to get Side A Mafia to go all-in into helping Town B is by beating them here.

Edoc, New Guy, Clever - if you killed Drunkmonkey, claim now.

I did not kill him.

Perhaps I am missing something, but it seems like you are looking for the scum to suicide here? I don't understand why you think they will cooperate. Or do you think one of the kills could be a vig?

[Rodion]

I'm thinking that the Shield kill was the scum kill and the Monkey kill was:
a) town vig
b) SK
c) Jonty as per his paranoid role

Getting someone to claim the kill would help with counterclaiming Jonty, but nobody did that (New Guy's posting in Side B indicated he will not claim Monkey's kill).

This means:
a) Monkey was killed by Jonty as per his paranoid role
b) Monkey was killed by a SK (that can or cannot be Jonty) and he is afraid to claim and expose himself.

[new guy1]

I will claim now if it is nessesary to clear my name here and lower the pool of suspects. I do not have a killing role, and it might offer insight on why there was only one kill night 1.

[edocsil]

I'm thinking that the Shield kill was the scum kill and the Monkey kill was:
a) town vig
b) SK
c) Jonty as per his paranoid role

Getting someone to claim the kill would help with counterclaiming Jonty, but nobody did that (New Guy's posting in Side B indicated he will not claim Monkey's kill).

This means:
a) Monkey was killed by Jonty as per his paranoid role
b) Monkey was killed by a SK (that can or cannot be Jonty) and he is afraid to claim and expose himself.

c) Kill came from the other game.

[Rodion]

I'd expect / to make it obvious it was from the other game just like he did when PCM A died.

[Rodion]

I'd like to have Edocsil and New Guy complete the massclaiming party (in that order) before friday so we can try to POE the remaining scum with our night actions.

[new guy1]

Alright, I am Town Hider. Im a bit busy so I will get the color later as well as my name. I hid behind everyone I investigated and found (obviously) that hiding behind mafia does not kill me in this case.

[jonty125]

Alright, I am Town Hider. Im a bit busy so I will get the color later as well as my name. I hid behind everyone I investigated and found (obviously) that hiding behind mafia does not kill me in this case.

Very unusual for a hider

[new guy1]

Not really, this is the second game I have played where thats the case. Ive been telling you guys my role isnt that powerful.

[edocsil]

Alright, I am Town Hider. Im a bit busy so I will get the color later as well as my name. I hid behind everyone I investigated and found (obviously) that hiding behind mafia does not kill me in this case.

Very unusual for a hider

Never seen it done this way before, only heard of it. Role is pretty OP, but this is a odd game so far, so it is plausible for me.

[new guy1]

Sorry, I forgot to get the name after I posted that, had a fun spring break to attend to.

I am the [quote="/"]Snake Oil Salesman, Town Hider for this side. I revised this a little so its not a direct quote .

[Rodion]

Clever, I don't want you to track the same person I block, but I also do not want mafia to know what we are doing, so we need to play this semi-randomly.

I will block either Edocsil or VS.
You will track either New Guy or Jonty.
New Guy - do not hide at all.
VS - investigate Side B if you are not roleblocked (but do not target Shield as he said he would commute).

Edocsil, claim if you have time so we can adapt the plan for more accuracy.