Moderator: Community Team
Commander9 wrote:Trust Edoc, as I know he's VERY good.
zimmah wrote:Mind like a brick.
safariguy5 wrote:TheGeneral2112 wrote:To all who are asking, I was not roleblocked. I learned that someone is not sided with the mafia. I'm not outting the invest yet, as it is pretty confirmed that we have a doc. If a watcher was watching me last night, please don't out what you saw. Even if you got both the doc and a mafia, that would mean outting the doc and I really don't want that shit.
Yeah, Ionno, I would think that mafia wouldn't wanna WIFOM their nightkills, so it's possible the doc protected someone else.
jonty125 wrote:safariguy5 wrote:TheGeneral2112 wrote:To all who are asking, I was not roleblocked. I learned that someone is not sided with the mafia. I'm not outting the invest yet, as it is pretty confirmed that we have a doc. If a watcher was watching me last night, please don't out what you saw. Even if you got both the doc and a mafia, that would mean outting the doc and I really don't want that shit.
Yeah, Ionno, I would think that mafia wouldn't wanna WIFOM their nightkills, so it's possible the doc protected someone else.
If I was mafia, I'd probably have a punt at killing cop N1 just in case doc bluffs but all WIFOM.
Iliad wrote:The upside of calling everyone scum and making 1000 predictions is that statistically you should get a few right.
strike wolf wrote:jonty125 wrote:safariguy5 wrote:TheGeneral2112 wrote:To all who are asking, I was not roleblocked. I learned that someone is not sided with the mafia. I'm not outting the invest yet, as it is pretty confirmed that we have a doc. If a watcher was watching me last night, please don't out what you saw. Even if you got both the doc and a mafia, that would mean outting the doc and I really don't want that shit.
Yeah, Ionno, I would think that mafia wouldn't wanna WIFOM their nightkills, so it's possible the doc protected someone else.
If I was mafia, I'd probably have a punt at killing cop N1 just in case doc bluffs but all WIFOM.
It really depends on the player and the scenario. For the doc if he is the one who stopped the kill assuming it was aimed at General, he may have felt uncomfortable attempting to WIFOM who they thought mafia would kill. For the mafia if they targeted general they probably figured that the doc WOULD attempt to wifom their kill. IF not it was either a good stab by the role blocker hitting the killer or a good WIFOM by the doctor in guessing who the mafia would target. Of course even all of this doesn't account for it having been possibly a jailkeeper. There's a lot of options.
jonty125 wrote:strike wolf wrote:jonty125 wrote:safariguy5 wrote:TheGeneral2112 wrote:To all who are asking, I was not roleblocked. I learned that someone is not sided with the mafia. I'm not outting the invest yet, as it is pretty confirmed that we have a doc. If a watcher was watching me last night, please don't out what you saw. Even if you got both the doc and a mafia, that would mean outting the doc and I really don't want that shit.
Yeah, Ionno, I would think that mafia wouldn't wanna WIFOM their nightkills, so it's possible the doc protected someone else.
If I was mafia, I'd probably have a punt at killing cop N1 just in case doc bluffs but all WIFOM.
It really depends on the player and the scenario. For the doc if he is the one who stopped the kill assuming it was aimed at General, he may have felt uncomfortable attempting to WIFOM who they thought mafia would kill. For the mafia if they targeted general they probably figured that the doc WOULD attempt to wifom their kill. IF not it was either a good stab by the role blocker hitting the killer or a good WIFOM by the doctor in guessing who the mafia would target. Of course even all of this doesn't account for it having been possibly a jailkeeper. There's a lot of options.
Didn't the general say he wasn't roleblocked or was that my imagination.
Iliad wrote:The upside of calling everyone scum and making 1000 predictions is that statistically you should get a few right.
strike wolf wrote:jonty125 wrote:strike wolf wrote:jonty125 wrote:safariguy5 wrote:Yeah, Ionno, I would think that mafia wouldn't wanna WIFOM their nightkills, so it's possible the doc protected someone else.
If I was mafia, I'd probably have a punt at killing cop N1 just in case doc bluffs but all WIFOM.
It really depends on the player and the scenario. For the doc if he is the one who stopped the kill assuming it was aimed at General, he may have felt uncomfortable attempting to WIFOM who they thought mafia would kill. For the mafia if they targeted general they probably figured that the doc WOULD attempt to wifom their kill. IF not it was either a good stab by the role blocker hitting the killer or a good WIFOM by the doctor in guessing who the mafia would target. Of course even all of this doesn't account for it having been possibly a jailkeeper. There's a lot of options.
Didn't the general say he wasn't roleblocked or was that my imagination.
He did the jailkeeper option is almost entirely dependent on the target being someone other than thegeneral.
safariguy5 wrote:I always have the mafia assign someone to execute the kill because there are so many roles that depend on that information. Busdriver, roleblocker, jailkeeper, etc. Because I was mafia last game, I know edoc does require a single mobster execute the kill.
jonty125 wrote:strike wolf wrote:jonty125 wrote:safariguy5 wrote:TheGeneral2112 wrote:To all who are asking, I was not roleblocked. I learned that someone is not sided with the mafia. I'm not outting the invest yet, as it is pretty confirmed that we have a doc. If a watcher was watching me last night, please don't out what you saw. Even if you got both the doc and a mafia, that would mean outting the doc and I really don't want that shit.
Yeah, Ionno, I would think that mafia wouldn't wanna WIFOM their nightkills, so it's possible the doc protected someone else.
If I was mafia, I'd probably have a punt at killing cop N1 just in case doc bluffs but all WIFOM.
It really depends on the player and the scenario. For the doc if he is the one who stopped the kill assuming it was aimed at General, he may have felt uncomfortable attempting to WIFOM who they thought mafia would kill. For the mafia if they targeted general they probably figured that the doc WOULD attempt to wifom their kill. IF not it was either a good stab by the role blocker hitting the killer or a good WIFOM by the doctor in guessing who the mafia would target. Of course even all of this doesn't account for it having been possibly a jailkeeper. There's a lot of options.
Didn't the general say he wasn't roleblocked or was that my imagination.
TheGeneral2112 wrote:To all who are asking, I was not roleblocked. I learned that someone is not sided with the mafia. I'm not outting the invest yet, as it is pretty confirmed that we have a doc. If a watcher was watching me last night, please don't out what you saw. Even if you got both the doc and a mafia, that would mean outting the doc and I really don't want that shit.
jonty125 wrote:safariguy5 wrote:I always have the mafia assign someone to execute the kill because there are so many roles that depend on that information. Busdriver, roleblocker, jailkeeper, etc. Because I was mafia last game, I know edoc does require a single mobster execute the kill.
I thought you were town-aligned but were told you were mafia last game saf? But back to the point, edoc does specifically ask for who is performing the kill and who is being performed upon.
soundman wrote:So General, why won't you tell us who you investigated? I don't see how it could hurt the town, only help.
Iliad wrote:The upside of calling everyone scum and making 1000 predictions is that statistically you should get a few right.
strike wolf wrote:soundman wrote:So General, why won't you tell us who you investigated? I don't see how it could hurt the town, only help.
*shrugs* I don't see the harm in keeping it behind the bars for now. As long as the person isn't considered to be at risk of any lynch, I don't really feel there's strong to make them claim.
strike wolf wrote:soundman wrote:So General, why won't you tell us who you investigated? I don't see how it could hurt the town, only help.
*shrugs* I don't see the harm in keeping it behind the bars for now. As long as the person isn't considered to be at risk of any lynch, I don't really feel there's strong to make them claim.
everywhere116 wrote:What we know:
Either the doc got lucky, or a roleblocker did.
General got an innocent. Won't reveal him so that the Daedra don't have an obvious target.
I'm not quite sure we have more than this. I'll look in day one's post see if there's anything else that caught my eye.
Another thing that I found while researching the Greek thread is that edoc said that he had trouble finding malicious roles for this pantheon, with one exception. This could mean that there is only one scum in this game, or he could have found someone else for the baddie to be with.
safariguy5 wrote:everywhere116 wrote:What we know:
Either the doc got lucky, or a roleblocker did.
General got an innocent. Won't reveal him so that the Daedra don't have an obvious target.
I'm not quite sure we have more than this. I'll look in day one's post see if there's anything else that caught my eye.
Another thing that I found while researching the Greek thread is that edoc said that he had trouble finding malicious roles for this pantheon, with one exception. This could mean that there is only one scum in this game, or he could have found someone else for the baddie to be with.
Interesting. Could be a third party SKer role of some sort? Maybe also investigation immune to buff the role a bit?
everywhere116 wrote:safariguy5 wrote:everywhere116 wrote:What we know:
Either the doc got lucky, or a roleblocker did.
General got an innocent. Won't reveal him so that the Daedra don't have an obvious target.
I'm not quite sure we have more than this. I'll look in day one's post see if there's anything else that caught my eye.
Another thing that I found while researching the Greek thread is that edoc said that he had trouble finding malicious roles for this pantheon, with one exception. This could mean that there is only one scum in this game, or he could have found someone else for the baddie to be with.
Interesting. Could be a third party SKer role of some sort? Maybe also investigation immune to buff the role a bit?
Perhaps something like that, although what you describe would make a Cop useless.
Although this entire thought is still conjecture with incredibly loose evidence behind it. I'm not going to put too much stock in it.
everywhere116 wrote:
General got an innocent. Won't reveal him so that the Daedra don't have an obvious target.
jonty125 wrote:everywhere116 wrote:
General got an innocent. Won't reveal him so that the Daedra don't have an obvious target.
Where did everywhere get Daedra from?
Iliad wrote:The upside of calling everyone scum and making 1000 predictions is that statistically you should get a few right.
It is from the Elder Scrolls. Good catch. You probably also know that the Daedra are the quote unquote "bad" gods. That's what I meant. I frequently pull terms out of my ass like this. It's what I do.strike wolf wrote:jonty125 wrote:everywhere116 wrote:
General got an innocent. Won't reveal him so that the Daedra don't have an obvious target.
Where did everywhere get Daedra from?
I was wondering the same thing...of course I'm not even sure what Daedra would have to do with Japanese mythology. Seems to be more of an Elder Scrolls thing.
Anyways same as I've said in my other threads. Very busy over weekend likely won't be able to post
everywhere116 wrote:It is from the Elder Scrolls. Good catch. You probably also know that the Daedra are the quote unquote "bad" gods. That's what I meant. I frequently pull terms out of my ass like this. It's what I do.strike wolf wrote:jonty125 wrote:everywhere116 wrote:
General got an innocent. Won't reveal him so that the Daedra don't have an obvious target.
Where did everywhere get Daedra from?
I was wondering the same thing...of course I'm not even sure what Daedra would have to do with Japanese mythology. Seems to be more of an Elder Scrolls thing.
Anyways same as I've said in my other threads. Very busy over weekend likely won't be able to post
Users browsing this forum: No registered users