TML/CDP10294 SD [Noted/Warned] KRK

[KraphtOne]

Accused:

tml
cdp10294




The accused are suspected of:

Conducting Secret Diplomacy




Game number(s):

Game 9049540
Both players seemed to have the same dumb strategy... and neither seemed to ever be logged on at the same time during the game, so possibly was one person using both accounts... and then i made a comment about it, and after the game i got the EXACT same neg rating and descriptive words from both players 40 seconds apart...
Game 9047050
Did nothing to each other even though clearly they were sitting right next to each other with bonuses... tml didnt touch cdp until he thought all other players were completely done...
Game 9034445
tml did not attack cdp but one time and that was to get a card... cdp did not attack him until he was mopping up he board...
Game 9033459
this one speaks for itself...
Game 9001552
guess who attacked randomly damaging clearly inferior armies whilst his buddy mopped up the map... if you guess tml... you would be correct
Game 8827243
didnt touch each other until cdp killed him for cards en route to winning the game...
Game 8949627
tml is hitting neutrals and players that are clearly deadbeating
Game 8780806
you starting to get the picture?
Game 8491107
this game is just bizarre...
Game 8502327
and so is this...
Game 8495961
and this...
Game 8908135
and this one just made me laugh...



Comments:

play your team games boys... play 1 vs 1... clearly you don't need to be playing large player singles games...

[SirJohn13]

One of my first games ever was vs these 2 guys (and 2 more). I didn't have much experience at the time to be able to tell if something fishy was going on. Anyway I checked the log now and noticed that although for a few rounds they did not attack each other, then at some point cdpl attacked tml hard and 2 rounds later eliminated him. Also they were playing simultaneously at some point when this happened. Still maybe he did that because he was completely winning at that point (he lost because he deadbeated).

Game 8514197

[Dibbun]

Here's something from tml's wall:



The game mentioned, Game 9032574, is not a team game. While there was indeed a truce proposed in open chat, there is an extra editorial on the wall, and in my opinion saying anything to an opponent in a multiplayer game on their wall other than "read chat" constitutes SD, but that's just me.

[Karl_R_Kroenen]

CDP10294 = WARNED - clearly extending the hand of SD in the wall post.
TML = Noted - unable to confirm if SD was accepted in Game 9032574 as Blue seems to be fending off any and all.

I analyzed several other games and they do attack each other (perhaps to clear the road or a freebie single).