Quad Cities Map [Quenched]

[Evil DIMwit]

No comments? Good. Looks like a promotion here.

[Victor Sullivan]

Very nice.

[ironsij0287]

Onto Graphics. I would imagine there'll be some comments/suggestions here.

[Victor Sullivan]

My only quibble is the boxes that have the names of the bonus areas are just not quick-reference friendly, nor does it look aesthetically splendid. Honestly, I'm not really sure what a good alternative would be, though.

[ironsij0287]

My only quibble is the boxes that have the names of the bonus areas are just not quick-reference friendly, nor does it look aesthetically splendid. Honestly, I'm not really sure what a good alternative would be, though.

Yeah. But I do at least have the bonus numbers on the small map to accompany them.

[ironsij0287]

Would troop number circles or whatever you call them be a good idea? I'm thinking in some of the regions it might help a little.

[MrBenn]

This is a very good-looking map - it's good to see somebody with a good attitude too

I'll have a more in-depth look later, and have some thoughts about how to take it from good to great

[AndyDufresne]

For the graphics, where do you want to see this map go, ironsij? Is your intent to develop it more into what looks like a tabletop foldable map? A brochure map for the area? Or something with that sort of theme? (Indian Empire, High Seas, Route 66, etc) Or more a simply crafted map with minimal aesthetics (Australia, Charelston, Greenland, etc).


--Andy

[ironsij0287]

Probably the latter with minimal aesthetics. I used up so much space with the territories and labels that trying to add any additional effects to the map in my opinion would really muddy it up.

[thenobodies80]

You could try to add a sort of image to your background, maybe something related with the zone the map shows or just a texture instead of using that green background because your map looks like it's floating on a strange green substance.
You could also work a bit on river, the water can be improved a bit to look a bit less flat (charleston map is a good example) and the river edges should have softer changes of directions, less "angular".
Did you try to draw thinner creek where they start?
A question, probably a stupid one since the first time i read your map title i thought about one of this , but because there's that empty space between the Mississippi, Big Island and Turkey Hollow?
Isn't rivers and creeks redundant? I think that something like rivers are only passable by bridge is enough. or not?
Your signature is hard to read imo.
Swap the position of armies and name in Campbell.
I tested the map on vischeck, the colors look fine and your good minimap is a nice addition.

Could you please post a version with yellow and orange 888 on the zones with the same colors? I don't think there will be problems since numbers have a black outline, but just to be sure...

On the whole it's a nice map, you're on the right way!

Nobodies

[ironsij0287]

You could try to add a sort of image to your background, maybe something related with the zone the map shows or just a texture instead of using that green background because your map looks like it's floating on a strange green substance.
You could also work a bit on river, the water can be improved a bit to look a bit less flat (charleston map is a good example) and the river edges should have softer changes of directions, less "angular".
Did you try to draw thinner creek where they start?
A question, probably a stupid one since the first time i read your map title i thought about one of this , but because there's that empty space between the Mississippi, Big Island and Turkey Hollow?
Isn't rivers and creeks redundant? I think that something like rivers are only passable by bridge is enough. or not?
Your signature is hard to read imo.
Swap the position of armies and name in Campbell.
I tested the map on vischeck, the colors look fine and your good minimap is a nice addition.

Could you please post a version with yellow and orange 888 on the zones with the same colors? I don't think there will be problems since numbers have a black outline, but just to be sure...

On the whole it's a nice map, you're on the right way!

Nobodies

I really appreciate the input. I'll work on some of this over the weekend. Thanks!

[jefjef]

Wow. Can't believe I hadn't seen this until now. Nice. Looking forward to conquering the QCA!

The region you are referring to as Nahant Swamp is generally known to the natives/locals as "West End" or "West River Drive" or "Garden Addition". Although a part of the Garden you have in the Rockingham tert. No one I know refers to that area as Nahant Swamp. Guess that is a realtor name for it, like Probstie. (Which is a small 2 pool table - 12 chair bar at the entrance of a Trailer park just before I-280)

Just to the west of the "Nahant" tert (Across the river from Andalusia) is Buffalo, Which in all realty is as much a part of the QCA as Andalusia or Eldridge.

Arsenal should be titled R.I. Arsenal. (Rock Island Arsenal)

I have never heard of Longview tert of Rock Island referred to anything but Downtown R. I.

Ridgeview Park is always just "RidgeView" to the locals.

Just wanted ya to hear from a local.

Keep up the good work!

[ironsij0287]

Wow. Can't believe I hadn't seen this until now. Nice. Looking forward to conquering the QCA!

The region you are referring to as Nahant Swamp is generally known to the natives/locals as "West End" or "West River Drive" or "Garden Addition". Although a part of the Garden you have in the Rockingham tert. No one I know refers to that area as Nahant Swamp. Guess that is a realtor name for it, like Probstie. (Which is a small 2 pool table - 12 chair bar at the entrance of a Trailer park just before I-280)

Just to the west of the "Nahant" tert (Across the river from Andalusia) is Buffalo, Which in all realty is as much a part of the QCA as Andalusia or Eldridge.

Arsenal should be titled R.I. Arsenal. (Rock Island Arsenal)

I have never heard of Longview tert of Rock Island referred to anything but Downtown R. I.

Ridgeview Park is always just "RidgeView" to the locals.

Just wanted ya to hear from a local.

Keep up the good work!

Yeah the naming of the regions had to be a little more generalized given the entire area it covered.

Originally I had Buffalo on the map as part of another group of territories including Blue Grass and Walcott as well, but due to space constraints I opted to cut them from the map. Andalusia was added later to offer a small bonus region on the Illinois side to counter Eldridge.

I lived in Rock Island for four years. I tried my best to keep the geographical integrity of the regions but some liberties had to be taken for the sake of the game board.

[Joodoo]

"Arsenal" looks pretty lonely out on its on bonus zone. Would it be possible if you could make it a starter neutral and autodeploy if a player captures it?

[AndyDufresne]

"Arsenal" looks pretty lonely out on its on bonus zone. Would it be possible if you could make it a starter neutral and autodeploy if a player captures it?

I've always preferred to see gameplay 'fixes' that aren't hard coded-always neutral regions.


--Andy

[Industrial Helix]

Hmm... I see nobodies already mentioned Charleston. I think its a good map that you should be able to draw some inspiration from. A little bit of texture on the map wouldn't muddy things in my opinion.

[ironsij0287]

I planned on having Arsenal always start as a Neutral 3 and the zone would be an autodeploy +1 bonus when held. Kind of like New Westminster on the Vancouver game.

[ironsij0287]

Latest update.

[RedBaron0]

I agree with Helix, a bit of land texture would do well here.

Have you tried different colors for the text? Black is ok, but a few spots where you've tried to add extra glow for readability actually makes it worse. Try white with a black glow or shadow, see if it comes out any better.
The red in Blackhawk is pretty much the same color as the army numbers for red, tweak that bonus region's color a bit, and take a look at vischeck and make sure you're good with the those with colorblindness. http://www.vischeck.com/vischeck/vischeckImage.php

[ironsij0287]

Another update:

[Industrial Helix]

Yeah, that texture does a lot for the map. Big improvement.

The thing that really bugs me is the deep jungle green background. It reminds me of the Brazil map or the rainforest in its tone. I imagine the area is quite green, so I see why you chose it, but I think a warmer green might do better. Either straight up green or perhaps an autumn green. Test things out, see which fits.

[ironsij0287]

Yeah, that texture does a lot for the map. Big improvement.

The thing that really bugs me is the deep jungle green background. It reminds me of the Brazil map or the rainforest in its tone. I imagine the area is quite green, so I see why you chose it, but I think a warmer green might do better. Either straight up green or perhaps an autumn green. Test things out, see which fits.

Yeah I can fiddle with the green a bit. I'm happy with how the texture turned out. That's from a digital elevation model of that area so it's true to the region's topography too.

[pamoa]

yeah great move with this bg
maybe can you remove the shadow under territories and river

[AndyDufresne]

Is it worthwhile to add some sort of more well defined line/barrier around the regions that touch the non-playable area? I.E. the whole perimeter of the gameboard.


--Andy

[ironsij0287]

I went a little different route and made the background a muted brown. I think it makes the colors of the regions come out more.