violcla and gerry2010[Noted]e84

[Blatta]

Accused:

454474
309690


The accused are suspected of:

Conducting Secret Diplomacy or possibly being a Multi
Game number(s):

Game 7612124
Game 7604146
Game 7578623
Game 7568376

Comments: Okay, here we go-
I first noticed something was odd in Game 7612124 when I was building up a stack on Washington to try to take West. Violcla holds California and Nevada. Out of nowhere, gerry2010 454474 (who has New England) decides to hit my stack. It seemed very odd and had no strategical advantage for 454474. I decided to look further - both from Italy and both logged in within 2 mins of each other - http://i235.photobucket.com/albums/ee137/blatta999/Violclaonline.jpg and http://i235.photobucket.com/albums/ee137/blatta999/gerry2010online.jpg

In Game 7604146 they are the last two surving and only attacked each other right at the end. They take their goes within a few minutes of each other.
In Game 7578623 they are hardly hitting each other and are nearly the only two left. When you look at the time they take their goes when they are one after another it is all within a few minutes.
In Game 7568376 they have started badly but are both trying to take Europe at the moment. Both are dropping troops on Europe and trying to clear out opposition. Again they are taking their goes within a few seconds of each other.

[TheForgivenOne]

Accused:

violcla
gerry2010


The accused are suspected of:

Conducting Secret Diplomacy or possibly being a Multi
Game number(s):

Game 7612124
Game 7604146
Game 7578623
Game 7568376

Comments: Okay, here we go-
I first noticed something was odd in Game 7612124 when I was building up a stack on Washington to try to take West. Violcla holds California and Nevada. Out of nowhere, gerry2010 454474 (who has New England) decides to hit my stack. It seemed very odd and had no strategical advantage for 454474. I decided to look further - both from Italy and both logged in within 2 mins of each other - http://i235.photobucket.com/albums/ee137/blatta999/Violclaonline.jpg and http://i235.photobucket.com/albums/ee137/blatta999/gerry2010online.jpg

In Game 7604146 they are the last two surving and only attacked each other right at the end. They take their goes within a few minutes of each other.
In Game 7578623 they are hardly hitting each other and are nearly the only two left. When you look at the time they take their goes when they are one after another it is all within a few minutes.
In Game 7568376 they have started badly but are both trying to take Europe at the moment. Both are dropping troops on Europe and trying to clear out opposition. Again they are taking their goes within a few seconds of each other.

Fixed player links

[Blatta]

Thanks for sorting the player links The ForgivenOne.
Just as an update, These two are regulalry coming online within about 15 mins of each other. Now this does not make them multis, so unless there is an issue with their IP addresses I feel that this is more likely to be secret diplomacy. They are playing as a team though, as with other games too (in my opinion).

[Blatta]

Accused:

violcla
gerry2010

The accused are suspected of:
Conducting Secret Diplomacy

Game number(s):

Game 7612124
Comments:
e84 has already cleared these two but please can you look at this one more time. I believe they are clearly working as a team. I will foe them and put this down to a bad experience on my part but it is pretty clear as far as i am concerned. The most blatent teamwork has happened after e84 cleared them, so there is more evidence to look at.

[Evil Semp]

If you feel that the decision was wrong you should fill out an e-ticket not open another report. e-tickets can be found be clicking on the help page.

[jefjef]

If you feel that the decision was wrong you should fill out an e-ticket not open another report. e-tickets can be found be clicking on the help page.

They have been in 7 games together. violcla has joined everyone of them right after gerry2010. These are coordinated game joins.

Perhaps you would be kind enough to look at this closer. Perhaps a mistake was made by eye8.

[eddie2]

like es said he did not wipe it off just asked for a eticket 2 be opened plus were is the op's link 2 the first case.

Forum rules
[These cases have been closed. If you would like to appeal the decision of the hunter please open a ticket on the help page and the case will be looked into by a second hunter.]

[eye84free]

Cleared of multis. Sorry I was looking at it worng. Still looking into Secret Diplomacy.

[eye84free]

This is still opend. will merge this one with the other. Was my mistake was looking into the multi side and forgot about the Secret Diplomacy side of this. Still looking into the Secret Diplomacy.

[Blatta]

Thank you. I did not know about the e ticket system but i should read through the appropriate procedure, sorry

[eye84free]

Ok after looking into this for far to long. It has come to this. There hasnt been enough games as of yet for me to say that they are conducting Secret Diplomacy but there is enough for me to note this. Again I am sorry for the delay on this.

Eye84free