Moderator: Tournament Directors
HighlanderAttack wrote:too bad I am not in this tourney
jrh_cardinal wrote:erikiscool is replacing moldy780 as the Tigers, and jsholty4690 is probably replacing edwinissweet as the Yankees (I'm awaiting confirmation from jsholty).
ViperOverLord wrote:At the All-Star break the top 4 players from each league should play a quads game. The league that wins would get home field advantage in the WS.
jrh_cardinal wrote:ViperOverLord wrote:At the All-Star break the top 4 players from each league should play a quads game. The league that wins would get home field advantage in the WS.
I guess, I know Serbia's MLB tourney did that, but this is a 1v1 tourney. I think it's better to stay with the tourneys premise
For example, I have no clue how good TalynStarburst is at quads, but he has the best record in the tournament right now (in 1v1's). If he absolutely sucks at quads for whatever reason, how is that a fair decider for home field advantage?
ViperOverLord wrote:jrh_cardinal wrote:ViperOverLord wrote:At the All-Star break the top 4 players from each league should play a quads game. The league that wins would get home field advantage in the WS.
I guess, I know Serbia's MLB tourney did that, but this is a 1v1 tourney. I think it's better to stay with the tourneys premise
For example, I have no clue how good TalynStarburst is at quads, but he has the best record in the tournament right now (in 1v1's). If he absolutely sucks at quads for whatever reason, how is that a fair decider for home field advantage?
Then make the All-Star Game a best of 5 1v1 top 5 teams vs top 5 teams.
jrh_cardinal wrote:ViperOverLord wrote:jrh_cardinal wrote:ViperOverLord wrote:At the All-Star break the top 4 players from each league should play a quads game. The league that wins would get home field advantage in the WS.
I guess, I know Serbia's MLB tourney did that, but this is a 1v1 tourney. I think it's better to stay with the tourneys premise
For example, I have no clue how good TalynStarburst is at quads, but he has the best record in the tournament right now (in 1v1's). If he absolutely sucks at quads for whatever reason, how is that a fair decider for home field advantage?
Then make the All-Star Game a best of 5 1v1 top 5 teams vs top 5 teams.
you're in the all star game as of now, you know that right? You're the wild card in the AL.
I like my way because it gives the best player a bit of an advantage for being the best, but still allows all of the playoff teams to have a say.
ViperOverLord wrote:Wild Card and All-Star game are different. In real life the All-Star game decides which league gets home field advantage in the World Series.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users