Secret Diplomacy [Cleared]

by **jricart** on Tue Jan 26, 2010 8:14 pm

Accused:
aligator_al
MyTurnToWin
Moonchild

The accused are suspected of:
Conducting Secret Diplomacy

Game number(s):
Game 6322704

Comments:
The game is too early to attack just one person! 4 players game with Nuke spoils.
I had my troops spread out in different regions with at least 4 on each.
Then, in the same round I got attacked by all of them.

by **AAFitz** on Tue Jan 26, 2010 8:19 pm

hmm.. cant blame you for being mad on this one...but youll probably need to find some other example of them playing suspiciously... in any one game, nearly anything is possible....

to be honest, my guess is green just got great dice and kept going with it...but it is odd...no doubt they exterminated you.

check their other games though... its impossible to really base any allegation on one game on circus like this.

by **Bruceswar** on Tue Jan 26, 2010 8:35 pm

Wait so moonchild takes a single army and now he is included in your very false claims? Nice to know....

Can we lock this already?

by **karelpietertje** on Tue Jan 26, 2010 8:42 pm

jricart wrote:wheeee I'm a baby, wheee!
I'm telling my mommy!!!

Wow.
What a sore loser.
So pathetic.
:sick:

by **the.killing.44** on Tue Jan 26, 2010 8:46 pm

Moonchild has attacked you one time. CONZPIRACY!!1@!

by **SuicidalSnowman** on Tue Jan 26, 2010 9:54 pm

I have played a bunch of games with MyTurnToWin as well as observed him in some of my tournaments, and have never seen anything but fair play. I would be surprised (and deeply disappointed) to see him involved in a rule violation.

by **jricart** on Tue Jan 26, 2010 10:35 pm

karelpietertje wrote:
jricart wrote:wheeee I'm a baby, wheee!
I'm telling my mommy!!!

Wow.
What a sore loser.
So pathetic.

First, I never see my self writing anything like that karelpietertje! Do not post fake quotes about me please! and please stay away from this if you are not going to help!

I think this part of the forum you can write complains, and I know the way that I played was so good and didnt have any clue why they pick me on that game, specially if I had regions with more than 1 troop.

On nuclear spoils sometimes you avoid getting a card, so there is no way to think they will go after my cards!

I not a sore loser, I dont care if I win o lose a game, but the way they act in that game make me think about a secret diplomacy.

I might be wrong, so Close this if you want! This is just a report!

by **king sam** on Sun Jan 31, 2010 10:57 pm

The explanation for the move is in the game chat, and is the assessment I got from reviewing it as well as the game log.

In a SD case it takes more substantial evidence to warrant punishment. I have reviewed the a majority of games played between these users and see no such warrant in those games to suggest that their has been a diplomacy in those or these.

aligator_al & MyTurnToWin have only played in tourneys together.
aligator_al has not played Moonchild in any other game besides this one.
MyTurnToWin & Moonchild have played 3 other games together all legit ones.

The move was made due to good dice and a opportunity to advance in the tournament. Tournament play is often very different then regular gameplay. In this tournament you advanced if you weren't the 1st one out, when aligator_al got good dice against you MyTurnToWin saw and opportunity to secure his status in the next round by targeting you as well. And as stated in the chat Moonchild attacked you for an easy card. Re-read the game chat if you have further questions.

Cleared

KS