Late response to Oaktown's post 4 months ago. I figure we can get all of this done now and be ready for a quick quench when the XML update is here.
oaktown wrote:I'd like to see a horizontal line in the top left legend separating the "Revert to 30 neutrals" line with the rest fo the info in that box, since they aren't related. You've used lines in that way elsewhere in the legend.
DONE
oaktown wrote:So really the high neutral reset is just to make walls, yes? That's cool.
Yes that is the main point. Allow easy movement first to get everyone settled. Then Build your walls to protect your bonus.
oaktown wrote:That said, the key to holding any color bonus is going to be setting up walls around yourself as you advance. The easiest colors to hold - and therefor the colors that should receive the smallest bonuses - will be the ones that can be taken progressively, with walls being easily constructed behind you for defense. Obviously the corner and side colors will be the easiest starts. For example, you can hold yellow by creating 14 walls and holding three points. White can be held with 17 walls and defending six points. To hold red you need to create 21 walls and hold 6 defense points. Gray requires just 12 walls and 5 defense points. Yellow and gray seem to be the easier holds, yet they are both worth more than either white or red. And yellow seems to be worth way to much relative to, say, the light green, which will require you to create 16 wall squares and hold two points: +27 for a region that may be more difficult to hold than a +42 region?
I haven't looked all the way back through this thread to see how the bonuses were calculated, but I think that the main ingredient has to be how many unique individual points of contact a region has with neighbors. The light green may look nice and safe against the top edge, but it has almost as many unique points of contact (18) as the white region (23). And poor purple: 25 points of contact yet it's worth less than white, yellow, and gray.
of course, this only takes into consideration ease of holding the entire region, not the ease of setting up walls as you advance. Some regions (like white) will require you to create more walls along the way to keep your enemies from breaking through from other arms of the white region. Whew!
That is a bunch to respond to but I will try my best. First of all the bonus were setup to make sure that the overall bonus for holding the entire color set more than the individual bonuses. Basically if a color set has more sub sets, the entire color is worth more. Now I think the sub set bonuses are ok. This means the overall color bonuses will need to be tweaked higher to reflect the actual difficulty or easy of holding a region.
Below are the numbers (that I found) as far as direct connections (i.e. a border with another color group and wall connections (borders to a wall that directly border another color NO diagonals). They are sorted from smallest to largest starting withteh first category.
- Code: Select all
Color / # of Sub Groups / # of Terts / Direct connections / Wall / Bonus
Purple / 3 / 15 / 2 / 9 / +21
Blue / 3 / 15 / 3 / 14 / +24
Dark Green / 3 / 16 / 2 / 9 / +22
Light Green / 4 / 19 / 3 / 18 / +27
Magenta / 4 / 22 / 5 / 20 / +36
Brown / 4 / 22 / 6 / 12 / +39
Orange / 4 / 22 / 6 / 19 / +39
Cyan / 4 / 22 / 6 / 25 / +40
Cream / 4 / 23 / 6 / 17 / +40
Red / 5 / 26 / 6 / 22 / +41
Yellow / 5 / 27 / 3 / 15 / +42
Dark Gray / 6 / 30 / 5 / 16 / +44
This way is easier to see and compare. What are your suggestions? I think that Dark Green could go to 25 and Blue to 22 or 23. Brown goes to 35 or 36. Cream to 39 so it is same as Orange.
oaktown wrote:Is there a segment line missing in orange? You have a 13 territory sub-region. White has a 12.
Fixed. I just missed them on the large map.
oaktown wrote:The similarities between the "I" and the "J" still bother me.
DONE
oaktown wrote:I'm pleased with the bonus rather than the victory condition - placing 454 armies is pretty much a victory anyway.
I like the bonus armies instead of the win. People like TONS of armies and the 454 is significant as well.
oaktown wrote:alright... I hope I gave you some things to chew on widow.
You sure did. And I responded almost 4 months later.