Smile [rating's complaint, noted]

[King Dain II]

Accused:

• Smile

The accused are suspected of:

• Other: Leaving 1 star ratings in all categories for no reason whatsoever

Game number(s):

• Game 2934107

Comments:
This guy gave me a 1 star rating in every single category.

It was a 2 player game which was played rt with both of us taking our turns at the same time and finishing within one or two minutes of each other. Why the 1 for fair play?

The only thing said in chat was Good game by me, and he responded by saying the same thing back except in abreviated form. Why the 1 star for attitude when he says everything I do in chat which was a single friendly statement?

What puzzles me most is that he won the game. I have received several 1 star ratings from people, with no explanation (I would like to have those ratings deleted as well, just look at the ratings I have responded to) but in all those cases, I simply assumed it was sore losing, which apparently is not the case since he won.

I did leave him all 3s (average) in all categories with the tag silent because so little was said in chat (by both, so he could also have left that tag for me had he wished to do so). This may be a case of retaliatory ratings, but I am pretty sure that even that is abuse.

P.S. If you are going to advise me (again...) to simply reply to the rating and put them on my ignore list, pretty soon I am going to have a really low rating soon, since I seem to run into these people a lot. And I do not think that most people spend the time to look through the games in which the bad ratings were given to the host when they are trying to join one of his games.

Note: My rating would be a 4.7 in every category if the 4 ratings I have responded to were deleted. (you can look through the game logs, and see for yourself if you consider them fair). And that is only 4 ratings dragging me down by half a star, and you have suggested me so far to put the people on my foes list and let it balance out. The problem is that it takes a long, long time to balance out, and by the time it does start balancing out, another one of these unfair ratings comes along and bumps you back to the place you were at the previous rating which has already been canceled out by 5s

[Joodoo]

The usual stuff:
1.Foe him/her

and if you meet anyore n00bs like these then:
2.Leave them crappy ratings and expanatory tags too

[King Dain II]

I have two problems with that: that is retaliatory ratings, though I would say that they deserve it, and I can no longer leave the ratings for them since the games have been archived.

And the policy of ignoring the problem only makes it worse by the fact that they continue to leave these ratings, and it does not even out! People say that eventually you will get honest ratings, this only works if one person in all of conquerclub leaves these types of ratings, since his rating is balanced out by others. The problem is that there are plenty of people that leave 1 star for no reason, making your overall rating drop and can not be balanced out since more and more of these people will leave you ratings.

The Advice of foeing the person will only work once I foe everyone that does this in conquerclub, so that only honest ratings are left. But even foeing every single person that does this will not work since someone new will come, and will leave a rating as such again, making you need to balance that rating out, foeing the person, then someone else joins the site.

I hope you see why I do not want to just foe them and leave this alone. 4 people out of nearly 100 people I have played leave me a bad rating and it drops by .5 points.

For the last time: IGNORING THE PROBLEM DOES NOT WORK! SOMETHING NEEDS TO BE DONE ABOUT IT.

[king achilles]

Checking Smile's ratings, it appears it is only you that he gave a rating like that. So far, the ratings he gave to others is not like what he gave to you. We do not know what transpired between you two or if there was anything at all. This can be unfair for you if you do not really deserve it however, we no longer moderate the new ratings system. If you can settle this between yourselves, it would be better. Ratings are based on our member’s opinions and therefore we do not want to second guess them.

For now, as what the others said, if you want, put him in your foes list. Or try to settle this with him.