Mafia Role Tier List

[Fircoal]

Yes When I do Something like this You know I'm bored.

This is a tier list of all the roles in one of my games so far. At the top are the best roles (or the most befitting to their side on a general scale) and at the bottom are the roles that are the worse for their side. (Or just not that good like Townie) Anyway, they are mainly based on my rules, though some roles won't have much change while others will (Like PGO being Top Tier in Fircoal games because of PGO > All, probably would be a lot lower if it wasn't for that.)

Uber:
Extreme Communter
Extreme Rolebloker/ Survivor
Mod's Assassant (BATorchic)
PGO/Mason
Weekend Killer

Top Tier:
PGO

High Tier:
Copier
Day Time Cop
Doc with 40 PHDs
Mafia Doc
Mafia Godfather
Mafia Mason

High-Middle Tier:
Cop
Doc
Host
Host (Shippo)
Mafia Cop
Mafia Copier
Mafia Godmother
Recruiting Mason
Super Doc
Super Roleblocker

Middle Tier:
Bullet proof townie
Bus Driver
Chu
Day SK
Day Time Vig
Deputy
Inventor
Jack-of-all trades
Mafia Framer
Mafia Roleblocker
Mafia Wacther
Nexus
Nurse
Roleblocker
Snow of Enetral Doom
Super Townie
Weird Life Pattern

Low-Middle Teir:
Bomb
bomb with gun
Hider
Insane Cop
Insane Doc
Insane Vig
locked role - Cop-Doc
Present Giver/ Tracker/ Mason
Present Looker/ Mason
Present Lucky/ Mason
SK
Spider
Survivor/ Mason/ Theif
Tracker
watcher

Low Teir:
1337 chatter
Double Voter
Mafia
mayor
Survivor
Traitor
Vig
Vig-Townie
Wannabe Host

Bottom Teir:
Townie
Bevolved Princess
Bob
Miller
Dragula
Gun Owner
Hated Townie
Naïve Cop
Paranoid Cop
Priest
Savor

Teirless:
Jester
Jester/Lyncher
Lyncher
Reverse Jester
Target Rapier (Ditto)

Useless:
AD
Everywhere
Fircoal
Senfive
SheepofDumb
Town idiot
Vote Less Townie (The only non-Awesome Mafia Role sucky enough to deserve the title of useless XD)
Random Person

Unknown:
50% Roleblocker
Begnion General
Begnion Leader
Crack Seller
Crimea General
Cult Leader
Cult Leader Apprentice
Daein General
Drunk Cop
drunk cop/doc/vig/roleblocker
Drunk Cop's Wife
Elincia
Forensic Investagor
UNKNOWN ROLE
Hi Guy
Jigglypuff
UNKNOWN ROLE
UNKNOWN ROLE
UNKNOWN ROLE
Mafia Daughter
UNKNOWN ROLE
Mafia Stealer
UNKNOWN ROLE
UNKNOWN ROLE
UNKNOWN ROLE
Prince Pelleses

Now time to debate on where these roles should be. NOA!!!

Edit: if you want a role added in tell me and desrcibe the role and where it should be.

[jnd94]

Christ, your bored.

[lord voldemort]

estel no allegience, and no win condition
useless but funny
pretty much im gonna mod kill them when im bored

[Fircoal]

estel no allegience, and no win condition
useless but funny
pretty much im gonna mod kill them when im bored

XD, that goes into the catergory of useless.

[CrabNebula]

Where is the "Host (Batman)"?

[Fircoal]

Where is the "Host (Batman)"?

it goes plainly under Host. the only reason Shippo is different is because he wasn't a playable role, and was my way of getting random.org into the game.

[Iliad]

Psychic
Psychic roleblocker


See all actions but not who's doing them. Psychic can see who is doing one of the actions, psychic roleblocker can stop one

Necromancer- can make one dead person a zombie-he can use it's night actions and the zombie acts as a bodyguard. But he can only necromance every second night

[cena-rules]

cenas elite joat

[Skittles!]

Oh, a Guider.

Guides someone's night action to someone else.

Or is this already a role?

[Iliad]

There are a few roles I will also reveal after my game is done

[mr. incrediball]

i think we can all agree the best mafia role is.

you are chuck norris.

you have already won, so do what you want for the rest of the mafia

[Minister Masket]

Where is Paranoid Mafia Gun Owner?

[animorpherv1]

You might want some sort of Doctor

[DoomYoshi]

are you going to finish the list?

[aage]

I distinctly remember being a doctor with 41 phd's in one of your games. My phd's demand that it be added to the list.

[strike wolf]

I distinctly remember being a doctor with 41 phd's in one of your games. My phd's demand that it be added to the list.

I still don't get how no one suspected you of being that role in that game.

[aage]

I distinctly remember being a doctor with 41 phd's in one of your games. My phd's demand that it be added to the list.

I still don't get how no one suspected you of being that role in that game.

I don't get how it was a mafia role.

[safariguy5]

Didn't see lover in that role list.

Would rank it low for handicapping two roles, can be mid-low if it's mafia-town couple.

Also, Innocent Child, mod announced townie at the beginning of the game. Low tier, only utility being confirmed townie, usually a VT role otherwise. Possibly useful at endgame if survives for that long.

[DoomYoshi]

Didn't see lover in that role list.

Would rank it low for handicapping two roles, can be mid-low if it's mafia-town couple.

Also, Innocent Child, mod announced townie at the beginning of the game. Low tier, only utility being confirmed townie, usually a VT role otherwise. Possibly useful at endgame if survives for that long.

I find Innocent Child to be powerful. From the standpoint of the doc: who do you protect N1? The confirmed townie.

[aage]

Didn't see lover in that role list.

Would rank it low for handicapping two roles, can be mid-low if it's mafia-town couple.

Also, Innocent Child, mod announced townie at the beginning of the game. Low tier, only utility being confirmed townie, usually a VT role otherwise. Possibly useful at endgame if survives for that long.

I find Innocent Child to be powerful. From the standpoint of the doc: who do you protect N1? The confirmed townie.

Meh. It locks some actions but none of those are mafia.