Moderator: Community Team
‘Who the f--k is this guy?’: Defense world reacts to Trump’s surprise Pentagon pick
“Hegseth is undoubtedly the least qualified nominee for SecDef in American history,” one veterans’ advocate said.
President-elect Donald Trump’s Tuesday night surprise pick of a conservative commentator and television host as his Pentagon chief shocked Washington, which had expected the nominee to be a seasoned lawmaker or someone with defense policy experience.
National security officials and defense analysts had braced for surprises from Trump after experiencing his first four years in office. But even grading on that curve, they say the announcement of Fox News host and decorated Army veteran Pete Hegseth caught them totally off-guard.
“[Trump] puts the highest value on loyalty,” Eric Edelman, who served as the Pentagon’s top policy official during the Bush administration, said in an interview. “It appears that one of the main criteria that’s being used is, how well do people defend Donald Trump on television?”
One assessment was more blunt. “Who the f*ck is this guy?” said a defense industry lobbyist who was granted anonymity to offer candid views. The lobbyist said they had hoped for “someone who actually has an extensive background in defense. That would be a good start.”
The pick will do little to quell fears inside the Pentagon and beyond that Trump, who jousted with his own defense secretaries, plans this time to install a loyalist who will unquestioningly carry out his policies. Trump’s campaign trail rhetoric has primed fears that his second term could see a swift and divisive overhaul at the Pentagon.
Trump’s return is expected to bring a collective rollback of Biden administration policies, likely reinstating a ban on transgender troops, ending abortion travel policies, reigniting battles over bases named for Confederate figures, slashing diversity programs and the use of troops on U.S. soil against civil unrest and his political enemies.
(...)
“Hegseth is undoubtedly the least qualified nominee for SecDef in American history. And the most overtly political. Brace yourself, America,” Paul Rieckhoff, founder of Independent Veterans of America, said in a post on X Tuesday night.
He returned to active duty in 2012 as a captain. He deployed to Afghanistan with the Minnesota Army National Guard and acted as a senior counterinsurgency instructor at the Counterinsurgency Training Center in Kabul.
pmac666 wrote:Theres something in motion you cannot comprehend. Cant wait for the tears tho.
viewtopic.php?f=8&t=237819&p=5341485#p5341483
pmac666 wrote:Theres something in motion you cannot comprehend. Cant wait for the tears tho.
viewtopic.php?f=8&t=237819&p=5341485#p5341483
saxitoxin wrote:I'm not happy so far but not quite to the point of being unhappy.-Hegseth at Defense: No opinion. I like that he's not connected to the Military Industrial Complex. He's obviously a bright guy and has military experience. However, he doesn't seem to have any experience in complex management. Two Rand Paul staffers have commented that he's more of a Realist and Non-Interventionist than some people believe, which makes me cautiously optimistic. The fact Ben Shapiro likes him makes me very pessimistic. I'm curious to see who is Deputy Secretary.
-Gaetz at Justice: Cautiously optimistic. He is a supporter of Lina Kahn, Biden's best appointment, which means -- hopefully -- Trump will not dismiss her from the FTC and there'll be some major anti-trust busting happening. That said, I don't like the idea of putting bomb throwers into the cabinet. We can have a president who is a bomb thrower or cabinet members who are bomb throwers, but not both.
-Rubio at State: HARD OPPOSE. Hoping that this is just a ploy to get him out of the Senate and he'll be fired in six months.
-Gabbard at DNI: Most enthusiastic about this one, though, I'm not clear what her actual qualifications are to head DNI, though she did sit on the foreign affairs committee so cautiously optimistic here. I don't think this is a position you can really mess up, though. You don't actually run anything, you just collate and report information collected by other agencies.
- Tom Homan for Borders: Good.
- Musk and Ramaswarmy at Government Efficiency: I'm all for government efficiency but Musk is basically a 12 year-old autistic savant. He should be nowhere near the government. That said, I saw someone said this is just an advisory blue ribbon appointment to give him something to keep him busy on the sidelines with little or no actual power.
ConfederateSS wrote: Vote for Kamala
saxitoxin wrote:I've previously said that Donald Trump is the president America needs, not the president America deserves. I'm prepared to be extremely disappointed by what's coming in the next four years and still maintain that a hard reset from the Biden administration was needed.
riskllama wrote:Koolbak wins this thread.
pmac666 wrote:Theres something in motion you cannot comprehend. Cant wait for the tears tho.
viewtopic.php?f=8&t=237819&p=5341485#p5341483
Why do people take almost instantaneous dislike to @SenTedCruz when they first meet him? They are only saving time. I told you what he was in 2016, why does his breath smell of George W. Bush's d*ck? #FatDracula
https://x.com/RogerJStoneJr/status/1855917547515682874
pmac666 wrote:Theres something in motion you cannot comprehend. Cant wait for the tears tho.
viewtopic.php?f=8&t=237819&p=5341485#p5341483
saxitoxin wrote:I'm not happy so far but not quite to the point of being unhappy.-Hegseth at Defense: No opinion. I like that he's not connected to the Military Industrial Complex. He's obviously a bright guy and has military experience. However, he doesn't seem to have any experience in complex management. Two Rand Paul staffers have commented that he's more of a Realist and Non-Interventionist than some people believe, which makes me cautiously optimistic. The fact Ben Shapiro likes him makes me very pessimistic. I'm curious to see who is Deputy Secretary.
-Gaetz at Justice: Cautiously optimistic. He is a supporter of Lina Kahn, Biden's best appointment, which means -- hopefully -- Trump will not dismiss her from the FTC and there'll be some major anti-trust busting happening. That said, I don't like the idea of putting bomb throwers into the cabinet. We can have a president who is a bomb thrower or cabinet members who are bomb throwers, but not both.
-Rubio at State: HARD OPPOSE. Hoping that this is just a ploy to get him out of the Senate and he'll be fired in six months.
-Gabbard at DNI: Most enthusiastic about this one, though, I'm not clear what her actual qualifications are to head DNI, though she did sit on the foreign affairs committee so cautiously optimistic here. I don't think this is a position you can really mess up, though. You don't actually run anything, you just collate and report information collected by other agencies.
- Tom Homan for Borders: Good.
- Musk and Ramaswarmy at Government Efficiency: I'm all for government efficiency but Musk is basically a 12 year-old autistic savant. He should be nowhere near the government. That said, I saw someone said this is just an advisory blue ribbon appointment to give him something to keep him busy on the sidelines with little or no actual power.
jusplay4fun wrote:saxitoxin wrote:I'm not happy so far but not quite to the point of being unhappy.-Hegseth at Defense: No opinion. I like that he's not connected to the Military Industrial Complex. He's obviously a bright guy and has military experience. However, he doesn't seem to have any experience in complex management. Two Rand Paul staffers have commented that he's more of a Realist and Non-Interventionist than some people believe, which makes me cautiously optimistic. The fact Ben Shapiro likes him makes me very pessimistic. I'm curious to see who is Deputy Secretary.
-Gaetz at Justice: Cautiously optimistic. He is a supporter of Lina Kahn, Biden's best appointment, which means -- hopefully -- Trump will not dismiss her from the FTC and there'll be some major anti-trust busting happening. That said, I don't like the idea of putting bomb throwers into the cabinet. We can have a president who is a bomb thrower or cabinet members who are bomb throwers, but not both.
-Rubio at State: HARD OPPOSE. Hoping that this is just a ploy to get him out of the Senate and he'll be fired in six months.
-Gabbard at DNI: Most enthusiastic about this one, though, I'm not clear what her actual qualifications are to head DNI, though she did sit on the foreign affairs committee so cautiously optimistic here. I don't think this is a position you can really mess up, though. You don't actually run anything, you just collate and report information collected by other agencies.
- Tom Homan for Borders: Good.
- Musk and Ramaswarmy at Government Efficiency: I'm all for government efficiency but Musk is basically a 12 year-old autistic savant. He should be nowhere near the government. That said, I saw someone said this is just an advisory blue ribbon appointment to give him something to keep him busy on the sidelines with little or no actual power.
I basically agree with Saxi on most of his assessments. I do disagree about Rubio; I find him a good Senator and potentially good at the Cabinet appointment.
I think Gaetz is a HUGE MISTAKE. He is ONLY a flame thrower.
Hegseth is a lightweight, as I said already. BUT maybe we need someone LESS connected to the Military Industrial Complex. BUT come on, a Captain ordering around Generals? He will not get much respect and thus be ineffective in many areas. Yes, his deputy/deputies will be very important here to make up for his lack of experience and connections. He too is basically a flame thrower, but has some credentials.
Gaetz has few, if any, credentials, except he was investigated by DOJ and thus has an axe to grind, an axe TRUMP LOVES.
pmac666 wrote:Theres something in motion you cannot comprehend. Cant wait for the tears tho.
viewtopic.php?f=8&t=237819&p=5341485#p5341483
saxitoxin wrote:jusplay4fun wrote:saxitoxin wrote:I'm not happy so far but not quite to the point of being unhappy.-Hegseth at Defense: No opinion. I like that he's not connected to the Military Industrial Complex. He's obviously a bright guy and has military experience. However, he doesn't seem to have any experience in complex management. Two Rand Paul staffers have commented that he's more of a Realist and Non-Interventionist than some people believe, which makes me cautiously optimistic. The fact Ben Shapiro likes him makes me very pessimistic. I'm curious to see who is Deputy Secretary.
-Gaetz at Justice: Cautiously optimistic. He is a supporter of Lina Kahn, Biden's best appointment, which means -- hopefully -- Trump will not dismiss her from the FTC and there'll be some major anti-trust busting happening. That said, I don't like the idea of putting bomb throwers into the cabinet. We can have a president who is a bomb thrower or cabinet members who are bomb throwers, but not both.
-Rubio at State: HARD OPPOSE. Hoping that this is just a ploy to get him out of the Senate and he'll be fired in six months.
-Gabbard at DNI: Most enthusiastic about this one, though, I'm not clear what her actual qualifications are to head DNI, though she did sit on the foreign affairs committee so cautiously optimistic here. I don't think this is a position you can really mess up, though. You don't actually run anything, you just collate and report information collected by other agencies.
- Tom Homan for Borders: Good.
- Musk and Ramaswarmy at Government Efficiency: I'm all for government efficiency but Musk is basically a 12 year-old autistic savant. He should be nowhere near the government. That said, I saw someone said this is just an advisory blue ribbon appointment to give him something to keep him busy on the sidelines with little or no actual power.
I basically agree with Saxi on most of his assessments. I do disagree about Rubio; I find him a good Senator and potentially good at the Cabinet appointment.
I think Gaetz is a HUGE MISTAKE. He is ONLY a flame thrower.
Hegseth is a lightweight, as I said already. BUT maybe we need someone LESS connected to the Military Industrial Complex. BUT come on, a Captain ordering around Generals? He will not get much respect and thus be ineffective in many areas. Yes, his deputy/deputies will be very important here to make up for his lack of experience and connections. He too is basically a flame thrower, but has some credentials.
Gaetz has few, if any, credentials, except he was investigated by DOJ and thus has an axe to grind, an axe TRUMP LOVES.
Hopefully Gaetz gets KO'ed by the Senate and we get someone serious in there. I'm for cleaning house, not burning the house to the ground.
Hegseth might work if they get a really strong Deputy SecDef. To be honest, I was hoping Chris Miller would be SecDef. I'm not sure he'd take the Deputy job after he was already Acting.
With some of these I'm starting to wonder if Trump isn't putting forward people he knows can't get confirmed simply to give the Senate a chance to reject a few? On the armed services committee you have a couple senators-for-life like Ernest and Fischer on the GOP side who may block Hegseth but don't have the political capital to block his replacement without being denounced as obstructionists. Trump might know that and already have someone like Miller waiting in the wings.
A source in room where House Republicans are waiting to start leadership elections says there were audible gasps when Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-Fla.) was announced as President-elect Trump’s pick for attorney general.
https://thehill.com/homenews/house/4987 ... -election/
pmac666 wrote:Theres something in motion you cannot comprehend. Cant wait for the tears tho.
viewtopic.php?f=8&t=237819&p=5341485#p5341483
President-elect Donald Trump on Monday confirmed he would declare a national emergency to carry out his campaign promise of mass deportations of migrants living in the U.S. without legal permission.
Overnight, Trump responded to a social media post from Judicial Watch's Tom Fitton, who said earlier this month there are reports the incoming administration is preparing such a declaration and to use "military assets" to deport the migrants.
"TRUE!!!" Trump wrote.
ABC News Chief Global Affairs Correspondent Martha Raddatz recently reported from California on the impact Trump's immigration and mass deportations plans could have on the American agriculture industry.
"If you took away my workforce, you wouldn't eat. If you go into the San Joaquin Valley and you start doing what you're saying, it's over. The country will stop, literally stop because the food system won't move," said Manuel Cunha Jr., the president of the Nisei Farmers League.
President-elect Donald Trump on Monday confirmed he would declare a national emergency
"If you took away my workforce, you wouldn't eat. If you go into the San Joaquin Valley and you start doing what you're saying, it's over. The country will stop, literally stop because the food system won't move," said Manuel Cunha Jr., the president of the Nisei Farmers League.
pmac666 wrote:Theres something in motion you cannot comprehend. Cant wait for the tears tho.
viewtopic.php?f=8&t=237819&p=5341485#p5341483
Return to Out, out, brief candle!
Users browsing this forum: No registered users