Page 1 of 2

Death From Above (Complete New Idea)

PostPosted: Thu Jun 12, 2008 1:40 pm
by RjBeals
Click image to enlarge.
image


You can pretty much get the concept from reading the map text. I guess it's

I would like to try an objective style map for my next project. I guess it looks like another video game (can you guess which one?). The skulls are just a placeholder. I'm not sure what objects I want there yet. I'm trying to work out the game-play before I get into graphics.

* Will objective games this work with assassin? Like if Red can never totally kill Green, will that short circuit the system?
* Could the skulls fight back? Like I know there are negative bonuses, but how could we work it in so it's not -1 army to your shooter every turn - thats boring.
* Should I start with 10 shooter spaces, in case the xml is ever updated to allow 10 players?
* Should I start with a lot more skulls, with only a neutral 3 on them instead?

* Different concept - what if the skulls can not attack each other. Instead, once you occupy them, each turn you lose 2 armies or something, until your down to just 1. Then a weaker player could steal your skulls and deploy more men (if he has them). ?

Jeez.. I don't know about all this.

:shock:

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Thu Jun 12, 2008 1:55 pm
by zimmah
RjBeals wrote:
* Will objective games this work with assassin? Like if Red can never totally kill Green, will that short circuit the system?


no point in playing assasin games on objective based maps, however it will still work. you will still win the game and get the points if you win an objective.

don't make more shooting places, 8 is fine IMO.

more skulls might be fine, put like 5~10 armies on each i guess.

the different concept is in fact better IMO

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Thu Jun 12, 2008 2:28 pm
by yeti_c
Ass & Term games will still work (just like Das Schloss) but the only way to win them is via the objective (Which I reckon is a good thing)

However - this looks like classic Space Invaders... which would be cool!!!!!

C.

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Thu Jun 12, 2008 2:49 pm
by seamusk
RjBeals wrote:* Different concept - what if the skulls can not attack each other. Instead, once you occupy them, each turn you lose 2 armies or something, until your down to just 1. Then a weaker player could steal your skulls and deploy more men (if he has them). ?


I've been working on an idea along these lines. I think it will work. If each skull is -2 though, then aren't folks just gonna build before attacking? Because I've been working on something similar I've struggled with this and I came up with the idea that you need to mix the incentives with the disincentives to prevent that. Maybe the skulls is an automatic +1. But the shooter starts with a +5 "continent" bonus that is overridden so that with each new skull you get a -1. I suggest building a spreadsheet and figuring out how this works best, without giving too much to the person who just builds and waits and taking too much from the person who is aggressive while still providing for a chance to come back. Careful balancing is key and you'll need to test this out somehow before trying to quench the gameplay. So you know it works.

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Thu Jun 12, 2008 3:13 pm
by ZeakCytho
I'd make it a more space-invaders themed map. Get rid of the skulls, set it in space, etc. Just leave enough differences to get around the copyright. And you could call it "Space Conquerors" or something like that.

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Thu Jun 12, 2008 3:18 pm
by t-o-m
i love this idea, fully support you

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Thu Jun 12, 2008 3:22 pm
by edbeard
it seems like it'll be like archery except longer and archery looks like it'll be a long game too

I just don't see how a game like this will end. stalemate city.

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Thu Jun 12, 2008 3:29 pm
by Balsiefen
edbeard wrote:it seems like it'll be like archery except longer and archery looks like it'll be a long game too

I just don't see how a game like this will end. stalemate city.



Exactly, I'm afraid you'll have to rethink the tactics for this one, at the moment its just dice wars, or at best, a one trick map. Nice idea though but be careful about it ending up as a novalty map.

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Thu Jun 12, 2008 3:36 pm
by RjBeals
A novelty map. I'm afraid that your correct. Kind of like Conquer Man is to me. I've played it once, and that was enough. I wanted to do (try) and objective map for my next project, but I may still have to brainstorm some better themes.

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Thu Jun 12, 2008 8:19 pm
by AndyDufresne
The game play is interesting, but I agree with some of the early sentiment. I love, however, the graphics. :D


--Andy

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Fri Jun 13, 2008 8:17 am
by MrBenn
At the moment, there is no incentive to be the first to attack... you might be in with a chance of getting a zombie, but you know that the next player will just take it from you...
If you can think of a way aorund that, then there is some potential here...

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Mon Jun 16, 2008 10:44 am
by max is gr8
The way around the first person attacking failing is you can ONLY attack the one directly above you. then the skulls once up their can attack each other.

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Mon Jun 16, 2008 11:06 am
by Juan_Bottom
This is a really great concept, and this is a map that I would love to play.
But it does almost seem like a novelty. There doesn't seem to be enought strategy involved. If you did follow after space invaders(your map is fine in my opinion) you could use the differen't colored aliens as bonuses, but I'm just lobbing that up there. I really do like the map though, even if it only works out as a novelty.

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Mon Jun 16, 2008 11:29 am
by Androidz
There should be a 5 Demons Above the skulls(cant be attacked by the shooters.) Gives even larger bonus. So there will be a battle to reach those 5. (And Devils/ArchDemons)

Eksample.

(this is how the map looks now: (my idea is also inserted with attack routes (| - /).) Remmember its a sketch.

ArchDemon - Devil - ArchDemon
| / | \ |
skull Demon Demon Demon skull
| | | | |
Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull
Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull
Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull
Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull


This will be a even harder gameplay. Where no one can let no one get super bonus. And it wont mess up the gameplay of your game

(this is just to give you ideas)

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Thu Jun 19, 2008 12:35 pm
by max is gr8
Code: Select all
ArchDemon  -  Devil  -   ArchDemon
     |      /  |  \     |
skull-Demon-Demon-Demon-skull
   |    |    |     |    |
 Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull
Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull 
 Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull
Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull


I have just coded the diagram from above.

Re: From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Thu Jun 19, 2008 12:38 pm
by sam_levi_11
or it could be berlin city districts and the sooters are planes. makes sense i think.

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Thu Jun 19, 2008 12:45 pm
by max is gr8
Code: Select all
ArchDemon  -  Devil  -   ArchDemon
     |      /  |  \     |
skull-Demon-Demon-Demon-skull
   |    |    |     |    |
 Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull
Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull 
 Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull
Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull
  |      |      |      |      |
Shter Shter Shter Shter Shter


To be honest I think the ordering should be so you can only hit the one directly above. I also think that the skulls can be bonusified by having some silver some gold and a platinum one at the end which if you hold you can attack shooters.

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Fri Jun 27, 2008 4:42 pm
by Androidz
What happend to this one?

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Fri Jun 27, 2008 6:17 pm
by Juan_Bottom
Androidz wrote:What happend to this one?



Yeah, what happened?

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Fri Jun 27, 2008 9:15 pm
by RjBeals
One of those ideas that should just fall to the bottom. I'm not working on this. I am working on a way better map, that will kick this sites ass once I post the idea.

edit.. Ruben and I are working on the map ;)

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Sat Jun 28, 2008 4:07 am
by max is gr8
Change the title and say "looking for new map-maker"

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Sat Jun 28, 2008 5:38 am
by Androidz
now seriously haveing a good map like this die is a shame. Can any1 who wants use your map and keep working on it??

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Sat Jun 28, 2008 8:09 am
by RjBeals
Androidz wrote:now seriously haveing a good map like this die is a shame. Can any1 who wants use your map and keep working on it??


I don't care. Sure.

Re: Death From Above (Free to Good Home)

PostPosted: Sat Jun 28, 2008 8:14 am
by Androidz
ok i might work on it after im fininsh with my 2 maps. If any1 else want to take it to the level before me say so in the forum pliss:P

Re: Death From Above (Help with Objective Idea)

PostPosted: Tue Sep 23, 2008 8:32 pm
by RjBeals
Androidz wrote:There should be a 5 Demons Above the skulls(cant be attacked by the shooters.) Gives even larger bonus. So there will be a battle to reach those 5. (And Devils/ArchDemons)

Eksample.

(this is how the map looks now: (my idea is also inserted with attack routes (| - /).) Remmember its a sketch.

ArchDemon - Devil - ArchDemon
| / | \ |
skull Demon Demon Demon skull
| | | | |
Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull
Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull
Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull
Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull-Skull


This will be a even harder gameplay. Where no one can let no one get super bonus. And it wont mess up the gameplay of your game

(this is just to give you ideas)


Hmm.. rethinking this...