PotC- AWE (cutler beckett is dead, game over)

[Iliad]

Somewhat. Though the theory against you was sound, as I said myself.

so the fact that I assumed that there was a godfather is a sound theory now? Clutching at straws much?

[Skittles!]

Somewhat. Though the theory against you was sound, as I said myself.

so the fact that I assumed that there was a godfather is a sound theory now? Clutching at straws much?

Did you even read what nagerous said?

[Iliad]

Vote Iliad

he slipped up when he said there must be a godfather that screwed up. Thats because he is the godfather and replaced the inactive dominationnation. Hes also pushing for information I may not want to share because it gives scum an idea who to target at night..

I assumed there was a godfather and I wanted to know if nag found scum. OMG I must be teh scumzor!

[Skittles!]

Vote Iliad

he slipped up when he said there must be a godfather that screwed up. Thats because he is the godfather and replaced the inactive dominationnation. Hes also pushing for information I may not want to share because it gives scum an idea who to target at night..

I assumed there was a godfather and I wanted to know if nag found scum. OMG I must be teh scumzor!

That's not really using base evidence against the theory

[lord voldemort]

u can add my msn wicked if u want so u can see its actually my naem
drewclark12345@hotmail.com

[nagerous]

Checked back last night no actions and night 1 protected you wicked

last night no actions yet I'm still alive and no kill

Unvote for now but I have another bit of evidence.

Lets just see if theres a counter might be what hes trying to force one out.

[nagerous]

Scenario
1) Godfather is skimming chose nag without reading that he was to be protected. Watch out for skimmers

3)Godfather is noob. He tried to kill nag when it was obvious that he would be protected

Iliad if you sent no protection then option 1 and 3 cannot be taken seriously nay?

[nagerous]

Unvote vote Skoffin


Move on to submariner #2 as a potential no kill sender.

[Skittles!]

Scenario
1) Godfather is skimming chose nag without reading that he was to be protected. Watch out for skimmers

3)Godfather is noob. He tried to kill nag when it was obvious that he would be protected

Iliad if you sent no protection then option 1 and 3 cannot be taken seriously nay?

He didn't know the protections then.

[diddle]

u can add my msn wicked if u want so u can see its actually my naem
drewclark12345@hotmail.com

Nothing like desperation

(mcad8@hotmail.co.uk)

[CrabNebula]

Sorry for not posting in the past 2 days, net died. Will read up and post again.

[Koesen]

Don't have much time right now, but as Skoffin's replacement, for what it's worth, I can confirm that the list of night actions was only given after I asked for it (meaning after I got my role PM).

In Skoffin's case, she didn't send in any night action, which is why I'm replacing her.

So the theory that Skoffin didn't send in the kill is correct, but the conclusion she's scum is wrong.

[lord voldemort]

Unvote vote Skoffin


Move on to submariner #2 as a potential no kill sender.

skoffin is replaced

[kalishnikov]

Unvote

Iliad's claim sounds legit enough, I'm not lynching our doc and I think we can get you a little protection tonight just to be sure.



Welcome Koesen, any fresh insight would be greatly appreciated.

[wicked]

well Kozy, mind telling us if skoffin learned anytthing of significance on night 1 then?

[Koesen]

Skoffin didn't send in anything at all ever, so even if she did read the thread, the information she gathered by herself must have been minimal (and none of her thoughts were passed on to me).

I'll have to reread to get a grip on this game (I always find substituting harder than participating from day one), but what I remember from reading up so far is that I see little or no basis for the attacks against Wicked, who played the same here as she did in other games I faced her in.

I do disagree with her statement that bandwagons are useless, since on Day One they're pretty much all you've got and you'd never get anywhere without one (or two or three), but that's not enough to make her look scummy in my eyes.

I remember feeling suspicious about Iliad as well, but his claim seems reasonable enough to keep me from voting until I reread.

The last thing I remember is that it took you guys a while before the first useful posts were made

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Unvote Wicked way to try to lead us all around in circles as the original comments were made against you. Putting someone at lynch - 2 is not that unheard of. Making them -1 is tightening the collar. When I know that I'm not on that much lately b/c of work and there was a solid argument made on the day, I will always put someone at minus 2 unless I had a good reason to trust them.

[CrabNebula]

Its quite possible that there is a Bulletproof vest.

And something about diddle doesn't seem right. The way he said "I have definite reason to believe Fircoal is scum" when his vote was the hammer...
If he is scum then he knows Fircoal will come out scum when lynched and thus its perfect to make yourself look townie by claiming to have evidence to Fircoal being scum.

[wicked]

Unvote Wicked way to try to lead us all around in circles as the original comments were made against you. Putting someone at lynch - 2 is not that unheard of. Making them -1 is tightening the collar. When I know that I'm not on that much lately b/c of work and there was a solid argument made on the day, I will always put someone at minus 2 unless I had a good reason to trust them.

haha I didn't lead you anywhere! And what comments? I asked how Iliad knew there was a godfather, that's all.

With the way the noobs and scum like to hammer/bandwagon, putting someone at L-2 or L-1 is never a good idea unless you're sure.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

There is nothing wrong with -2. if someone puts them closer then that it would be very scummy although it would lead to easy scum finders. Most people won't claim unless they are at -2 or less and as such -2 is the best bet for pressure on someone.

[kalishnikov]

Its quite possible that there is a Bulletproof vest.

And something about diddle doesn't seem right. The way he said "I have definite reason to believe Fircoal is scum" when his vote was the hammer...
If he is scum then he knows Fircoal will come out scum when lynched and thus its perfect to make yourself look townie by claiming to have evidence to Fircoal being scum.

Yea I also thought about this but then just kinda let it go as no one else mentioned anything but it could be something.

[Koesen]

Most people won't claim unless they are at -2 or less and as such -2 is the best bet for pressure on someone.

I agree.

[Minister Masket]

I notice that wicked once again provided the most pressure on our suspect. However, that is an easy townie-to-townie mistake and I'll let it go for now.

[Minister Masket]

Vote Iliad to up the pressure wtih a FOS on MM if Iliad does turn out to be scum.

LSU put the 5th vote on. That's more than "putting the pressure on" when 7 is a lynch.

vote LSU

I'm wondering why he was going to pressurize me when I was literally the only player protecting our probable cop.

[wicked]

I notice that wicked once again provided the most pressure on our suspect. However, that is an easy townie-to-townie mistake and I'll let it go for now.

I also helped clear him. Let's not have selective memory, mmk?