Actors Mafia Endgame: Town Wins

[BGtheBrain]

****

[BGtheBrain]

****

[safariguy5]

EBWOP unvote vote blake

Tired of playing games. We'll find out soon enough who's lying.

I agree. I figure there's enough room for 1 doc in this game, but definitely not two. drake sounds like his night actions are more consistent with trying to benefit town.

[drunkmonkey]

Christ Im voting in blue.

It wasn't even real blue - it was scummy blue.

[BGtheBrain]

****

[safariguy5]

Ok, if Blake comes up as the doc, i feel Drake and Saf will need to pay for this.

Why Saf? Bc he was quick to believe it and convinced me to switch my vote.

unvote vote Blake Bowling

that is the hammer correct?

What exactly do you want me to say? If blake isn't the doc, then obviously we lynch drake. Remember, I never cast a vote for blake until I heard the counterclaim. Go back and read my posts a couple nights ago when zimmah was pushing for a lynch. I said we should go investigate more leads first and talk it out.

Now we know either blake or drake are lying, and that's a lot better than just lynching blake and not really having any other possible leads.

[safariguy5]

Ok, if Blake comes up as the doc, i feel Drake and Saf will need to pay for this.

Why Saf? Bc he was quick to believe it and convinced me to switch my vote.

unvote vote Blake Bowling

that is the hammer correct?

What exactly do you want me to say? If blake is the doc, then obviously we lynch drake. Remember, I never cast a vote for blake until I heard the counterclaim. Go back and read my posts a couple nights ago when zimmah was pushing for a lynch. I said we should go investigate more leads first and talk it out.

Now we know either blake or drake are lying, and that's a lot better than just lynching blake and not really having any other possible leads.

EBWOP

[jonty125]

that damn blue!

I did not expect a whole discussion from that vote blake in case BG can't count

[BGtheBrain]

****

[blakebowling]

Knew it couldn't last forever. Great job distancing though.

[spiesr]

So, here is what you guys wanted, the summation of the info I have collected.

Click image to enlarge.

My point here I guess, is that it appears that the nights when I blocked pancakemix match up with the nights where the mafia roleblocker didn't block anybody. So, if Blakebowling doesn't come up as the mafia roleblocker, we should probably look into that or something...

[drunkmonkey]

So, here is what you guys wanted, the summation of the info I have collected.

Click image to enlarge.

My point here I guess, is that it appears that the nights when I blocked pancakemix match up with the nights where the mafia roleblocker didn't block anybody. So, if Blakebowling doesn't come up as the mafia roleblocker, we should probably look into that or something...

BG claimed to have been blocked on N3. However, I still think there's a good chance pcm is (one of) our remaining scum.

[drunkmonkey]

EBWOP: never mind, I got your(spiesr) N3 and N4 actions mixed up. Looks like a good lead.

[drunkmonkey]

Sorry for the triple post, but if pcm is the mafia roleblocker, it makes a case for Mr. Squirrel being mafia too. BG was pretty clear about his intentions...

[BGtheBrain]

****

[drunkmonkey]

Actually, I forgot about the busdrives, which mean you were roleblocked by accident.

[BGtheBrain]

****

[safariguy5]

Don't forget that Mr. Squirrel claimed when BG shot him with the proton pack, Mr. S had a one-shot bulletproof vest. I'm not going to declare that he's the mafia godfather, but there seems to be circumstantial evidence that points towards that. Definitely a good lead for Day 6.

[drunkmonkey]

I think spiesr's lead on pcm is more promising. I also made a note of this earlier, during the case on VS:

First off, Travis Bickle? Town vig? Hell no. Bickle is a psychopath, not a vigilante. If he is a vig, he's overeager at best, and that just makes him dangerous.

I actually watched Taxi Driver the other night (been meaning to for a while; this just further inspired me). Travis Bickle only kills 4-5 people in the movie. 1 was robbing a store at gunpoint, and the other 3-4 (can't remember) he killed trying to free a 12-year-old Jodie Foster from prostitution. He's absolutely a vigilante character. When I re-read this, it seemed like pcm was falsifying information about the character to speed up the case. I could be wrong, but I wanted to get it out there now that blake has been hammered and it won't detract from that case, and in case I die tonight.

[Mr. Squirrel]

Don't forget that Mr. Squirrel claimed when BG shot him with the proton pack, Mr. S had a one-shot bulletproof vest. I'm not going to declare that he's the mafia godfather, but there seems to be circumstantial evidence that points towards that. Definitely a good lead for Day 6.

I know this is a WIFOM argument, but why would I want to confirm BG's claim if I was scum?

[spiesr]

I know this is a WIFOM argument, but why would I want to confirm BG's claim if I was scum?

Because in a scenario where the usual sources of fudging up an action like that have been eliminated, (We know that he was not roleblocked and that the busdriver did not effect that action.) you are basically forced to either confirm his action or deny his entire claim. Presumably you would have felt that his claim was too solidly accepted for denying to be a safe option at this point. So I would guess that you thought that collaborating his claimed action would win you more town points that any of the other options available to you.

[safariguy5]

I think spiesr's lead on pcm is more promising. I also made a note of this earlier, during the case on VS:

First off, Travis Bickle? Town vig? Hell no. Bickle is a psychopath, not a vigilante. If he is a vig, he's overeager at best, and that just makes him dangerous.

I actually watched Taxi Driver the other night (been meaning to for a while; this just further inspired me). Travis Bickle only kills 4-5 people in the movie. 1 was robbing a store at gunpoint, and the other 3-4 (can't remember) he killed trying to free a 12-year-old Jodie Foster from prostitution. He's absolutely a vigilante character. When I re-read this, it seemed like pcm was falsifying information about the character to speed up the case. I could be wrong, but I wanted to get it out there now that blake has been hammered and it won't detract from that case, and in case I die tonight.

Yeah, but he tried to kill the politician too. So I definitely think overeager vig at the very least, especially when you consider he got the guns illegally.

[zimmah]

I don't understand what you want me to post. I've told you the truth about everything, either you believe me (or you know lynching a doc would be horrible for town), or you lynch me today. I'm more than willing to answer questions, but I am the doc. I just don't know how I can verify that today.

a doc not taking half his night actions is not horrible?

[blakebowling]

I don't understand what you want me to post. I've told you the truth about everything, either you believe me (or you know lynching a doc would be horrible for town), or you lynch me today. I'm more than willing to answer questions, but I am the doc. I just don't know how I can verify that today.

a doc not taking half his night actions is not horrible?

It was a lie, what did you expect?

[zimmah]

I don't understand what you want me to post. I've told you the truth about everything, either you believe me (or you know lynching a doc would be horrible for town), or you lynch me today. I'm more than willing to answer questions, but I am the doc. I just don't know how I can verify that today.

a doc not taking half his night actions is not horrible?

It was a lie, what did you expect?

i knew you was lying all along, but the rest didn't really believe me. in the end we did get the real doctor to claim tho, not sure if that's a good thing, but i doubt it will hurt us much either, as we were getting a clear image on what's going on this day. i have a feeling this game will be over soon.