Yo Ho, A Pirate's Life! [2/16] Endgame: Pirates Win!

[thehippo8]

As for isaiah, maybe if he knows, he can say how he came across his gun.

All that I know is that I was given a gun, and that is the truth.

Hmmm ... I assume you were given the gun at the commencement of the game ... vote isaiah40

[new guy1]

Okay, so you were given a gun at the start of the game? Why did you shoot Neb?

[isaiah40]

As for isaiah, maybe if he knows, he can say how he came across his gun.

All that I know is that I was given a gun, and that is the truth.

Hmmm ... I assume you were given the gun at the commencement of the game ... vote isaiah40

Nope I was given the single shot gun yesterday.

Okay, so you were given a gun at the start of the game? Why did you shoot Neb?

Bad aim.

Like I said just send me out on the plank, and hold me, my fellow townies responsible for our lose

[DoomYoshi]

What do you mean by bad aim? You don't seem to be very generous with your information, which isn't helping the case.

[new guy1]

I think I get him. Either his character wont always hit the target he wants to or he thought someone was scum when they werent. Either way, I have another question. Why now? Why did you take the shot?

[TeeGee]

As for isaiah, maybe if he knows, he can say how he came across his gun.

All that I know is that I was given a gun, and that is the truth.

Hmmm ... I assume you were given the gun at the commencement of the game ... vote isaiah40

Hippo, I know for a fact that isaiah did not have the gun at the beginning of the game

[jak111]

As for isaiah, maybe if he knows, he can say how he came across his gun.

All that I know is that I was given a gun, and that is the truth.

Hmmm ... I assume you were given the gun at the commencement of the game ... vote isaiah40

Hippo, I know for a fact that isaiah did not have the gun at the beginning of the game

Okay, I am going to break my silence pack just to ask... why would you give him a gun?

[SPARTACUS1974]

for a start
vote teegee
he was placed in jail by me on N1 and only 2 kills i placed jak N2 and 3 attemted kills and i placed teegee again on N3 in jail and only 1 kill so i stopped his kill each night so i am sorry about clever but my role also blocks aswell as keeps players safe as i did in n2 to save jak

[jak111]

Unvote, Vote TeeGee... I dunno why I'm listening to you, but soundman tends to have an imagination so I wouldn't doubt it...

[SPARTACUS1974]

as for my claim
i am the quartermaster i shall the ships spoils
and each night i can place 1 of the crew in jail which will protect them but also stop any action they try to make so a doctor and role blocker in 1

[jak111]

as for my claim
i am the quartermaster i shall the ships spoils
and each night i can place 1 of the crew in jail which will protect them but also stop any action they try to make so a doctor and role blocker in 1

That actually sounds legit, so yes I will believe it.

[SPARTACUS1974]

Unvote, Vote TeeGee... I dunno why I'm listening to you, but soundman tends to have an imagination so I wouldn't doubt it...

sorry for double posting but i blocked him N1 as he was quiet then protected you N2 jak as you was open town so then i placed teegee in jail again N3 and saw less kills .

i also think we have a 3rd party which would be the navy of sorts who want all pirates dead?
fast posted by jak

[jak111]

Mhmm, thanks for the protection, didn't do much good considering they don't see me as a threat. That being said, I'm able to find and put things together quickly.

[SPARTACUS1974]

Mhmm, thanks for the protection, didn't do much good considering they don't see me as a threat. That being said, I'm able to find and put things together quickly.

you are a threat as for being a senior town player , as you have played a fair few mafia's and scum know that so that is why i protected you lol

[jak111]

Well I'm not that much of a senior. I've played 2 full games as of a few minutes ago and this is my 3rd with 2 others I am in the sign up stage in and making my own here soon (Check Mafia Discussion ;o) But I do have a bit of practice with LIVE mafia games on whirled :3.

[DoomYoshi]

Hmm. Well, this is what is happening now:

Isaiah kills our cop. TeeGee claims to have given him a gun. Spartacus seems to indicate that TeeGee is a probable mafia, although that analysis isn't as cut and dry as it seems.

However, one issue I have is that if spartacus jailkept teegee, but isaiah was blocked... this means we are dealing with a busdriver, most likely mafia.

@Spartacus: Quite frankly, your reasoning sucks. The SK is dead and the vig revealed, so the fact that there was only 1 kill could be due to the fact that only mafia is left. Also, it is nearly impossible to clear/convict someone based on roleblocks, especially when there is probably 2 mafia left.

I still think we should see what is going on with isaiah. Then, we need to figure out who the last possible connection to him is.

[jak111]

Hmm. Well, this is what is happening now:

Isaiah kills our cop. TeeGee claims to have given him a gun. Spartacus seems to indicate that TeeGee is a probable mafia, although that analysis isn't as cut and dry as it seems.

However, one issue I have is that if spartacus jailkept teegee, but isaiah was blocked... this means we are dealing with a busdriver, most likely mafia.

@Spartacus: Quite frankly, your reasoning sucks. The SK is dead and the vig revealed, so the fact that there was only 1 kill could be due to the fact that only mafia is left. Also, it is nearly impossible to clear/convict someone based on roleblocks, especially when there is probably 2 mafia left.

I still think we should see what is going on with isaiah. Then, we need to figure out who the last possible connection to him is.

Skimmer or forgetful Doom. Remember, CLEVER claimed to block Isaiah night 1....

[new guy1]

Im guessing he forgot, since I somehow forgot as well! I need to refresh my memory a little when I have time. Lol.

[DoomYoshi]

Hmm. Well, this is what is happening now:

Isaiah kills our cop. TeeGee claims to have given him a gun. Spartacus seems to indicate that TeeGee is a probable mafia, although that analysis isn't as cut and dry as it seems.

However, one issue I have is that if spartacus jailkept teegee, but isaiah was blocked... this means we are dealing with a busdriver, most likely mafia.

@Spartacus: Quite frankly, your reasoning sucks. The SK is dead and the vig revealed, so the fact that there was only 1 kill could be due to the fact that only mafia is left. Also, it is nearly impossible to clear/convict someone based on roleblocks, especially when there is probably 2 mafia left.

I still think we should see what is going on with isaiah. Then, we need to figure out who the last possible connection to him is.

Skimmer or forgetful Doom. Remember, CLEVER claimed to block Isaiah night 1....

No Isaiah was blocked N3 is what I am talking about. Clever is dead.

[jak111]

Aye, this is true. Hmm, Unvote, I need some rest >.<

[DoomYoshi]

Actually, I just over it again. Sorry for insulting you spartacus, I am the moron here. Night 1 only had 2 kills. But it appears jonty didn't kill anyone during the night. Which means, there might have been a 4th kill that night, if there are indeed 2 mafias. Which, to me, would make sense, due to how powerful town is.

[Victor Sullivan]

[color=BF0000]unvote[/color]

-Sully

[thehippo8]

unvote

I've been reviewing everyone who's left and it dawned on me that we have assumed newguy1 is town just because he was in on th vote against the Godfather. It is not inconceivable the mafia would loose one of their own to try and get another to the end. In perusing all of newguy1's posts (and I won't list them unless you care me to as I got growled at for that last time!) he is either bandwagoning or duckshoving or otherwise appearing agreeable. But what do we know about him really?

Time for some pressure ... vote newguy1

[new guy1]

unvote

I've been reviewing everyone who's left and it dawned on me that we have assumed newguy1 is town just because he was in on th vote against the Godfather. It is not inconceivable the mafia would loose one of their own to try and get another to the end. In perusing all of newguy1's posts (and I won't list them unless you care me to as I got growled at for that last time!) he is either bandwagoning or duckshoving or otherwise appearing agreeable. But what do we know about him really?

Time for some pressure ... vote newguy1

Actually all of you guys (being the rest of the community) cleared me because I visited sully and he did not die, so I am at least semi cleared on the grounds that he did not die the night I visited him.

[thehippo8]

Hmmm - not really. That is typical of what I am talking about. Sounds good but tells us nothing.