[Official] D&D Mafia ~ Endgame

by **rishaed** on Thu Oct 10, 2013 10:21 am

Overall I still don't understand why you guys are trying to kill me other than, he may decide to vote with scum? Scum can kill me just as easily, therefor are just as much of a threat to me. Also how would I know who scum were as a commuter? Its not like i get a message from the sky from Edoc saying Hey look Scum!. Until I get endgamed/Killed I'm going to keep playing for town. -_- I would vote you mob, but you are pretty much confirmed, as well as aage, and I'm not getting into the lawful/chaot war. The most use for me is to keep me alive for you guys right now. Because I see no other option I will also vote No Lynch. The two people I would vote for today are both confirmed, so I'm not going to waste my time on them.

by **rishaed** on Thu Oct 10, 2013 10:25 am

rishaed wrote:Overall I still don't understand why you guys are trying to kill me other than, he may decide to vote with scum? Scum can kill me just as easily, therefor are just as much of a threat to me. Also how would I know who scum were as a commuter? Its not like i get a message from the sky from Edoc saying Hey look Scum!. Until I get endgamed/Killed I'm going to keep playing for town. -_- I would vote you mob, but you are pretty much confirmed, as well as aage, and I'm not getting into the lawful/chaot war. The most use for me is to keep me alive for you guys right now. Because I see no other option I will also vote No Lynch. The two people I would vote for today are both confirmed, so I'm not going to waste my time on them.

Scratch that No Lynch gets us nowhere. unvote Vote Ephitaph because I have no desire to get lynched, and depending on how long edoc is gone he is the next best person for a claim.

by **edocsil** on Thu Oct 10, 2013 11:19 am

My last exam is in an hour. Deadline is still tonight.

by **MoB Deadly** on Thu Oct 10, 2013 11:25 am

1. That is an easy fake claim for scum (pretty much unverifiable)
2. Keeping you alive lets the mafia count you in with the majority vote

suppose there are 4 mafia (ballpark number, could be logical if edoc was accounting for a mafia being recruited by cult)

11 players now,
10 players after lynch
9 players after night kill

As early as tomorrow mafia can say. Player A, B, C, D are mafia, Rishead vote with us and end the game. Obviously you will do that.

We are closer to a mylo situation than some of us may realize......

by **aage** on Thu Oct 10, 2013 11:48 am

rishaed wrote:Until I get endgamed/Killed I'm going to keep playing for town. -_-

I doubt it. If you are neut/neut, you are going to play for whatever lets you win. This quote is a lie. Besides, there is no town; only good/neutral which is the only thing that resembles town. You would also be fairly stupid if you didn't get into the chaot/lawful war because ending that conflict will decrease the chances of you getting caught in the crossfire. All in all you apparently want us to believe you have the best intentions but there is no way to prove it, nor is there a way to prove your claim. And seriously, Darkeyes? A human bard?

by **MoB Deadly** on Thu Oct 10, 2013 11:59 am

Either way, town has a small victory by lynching rishead. And It is a big win if he is lying. We need to lynch him because we dont have any direct evidence against anyone else

by **Epitaph1** on Thu Oct 10, 2013 1:46 pm

rishaed wrote:
rishaed wrote:Overall I still don't understand why you guys are trying to kill me other than, he may decide to vote with scum? Scum can kill me just as easily, therefor are just as much of a threat to me. Also how would I know who scum were as a commuter? Its not like i get a message from the sky from Edoc saying Hey look Scum!. Until I get endgamed/Killed I'm going to keep playing for town. -_- I would vote you mob, but you are pretty much confirmed, as well as aage, and I'm not getting into the lawful/chaot war. The most use for me is to keep me alive for you guys right now. Because I see no other option I will also vote No Lynch. The two people I would vote for today are both confirmed, so I'm not going to waste my time on them.

Scratch that No Lynch gets us nowhere. unvote Vote Ephitaph because I have no desire to get lynched, and depending on how long edoc is gone he is the next best person for a claim.

Give me a break. I'd love to hear about how I'm "the next best person for a claim" but you're just trying to deflect the attention from you in a last ditch effort to avoid the noose. I didn't care for Aage's case against you, but we've gone from that to your suspect claim and now this.

Vote rishaed

by **Rodion** on Thu Oct 10, 2013 2:06 pm

MoB Deadly wrote:We are closer to a mylo situation than some of us may realize......

Inorite?! I already said that twice!

You also forgot to mention Sniper's likely modkill and some potential LawxChaos day/night vigs. D4 could theoretically start with 6-7 players. And going by the theory that mafia is L/E and N/E, L/N also wins with mafia (and C/N wins with part of it). Considering we've seen no L/N claims so far, I feel that Rishaed is not the game's only survivor (I could be wrong because NG/Comm9 could be L/N).

by **edocsil** on Thu Oct 10, 2013 11:58 pm

That's the end of the day.

Vote Count:

Rishaed (4) ~ Epitaph, aage, rodion, mob
Epitaph (2) ~ Rishaed, doomyoshi

Rishaed has been lynched.

The old threat was over, so the the mighty adventures went exploring. There were rumors of a silver skeleton stowed away in one of the local dwarven ruins. They found the ruins easily enough and began to make their way though the tunnels. A variety of unimportant monsters blocked their way, all of which the party easily cleared. Once they neared their goal of the skeleton however one of their members began to act erratically. Being the heartless souls they were a few adventures put him to the question. Not believing her answers they quickly strung her up and lefter her to dangle while the others continued to explore the ruins.

Rishaed ~ Nerissys Mineshadow ~ Janitor ~ Evil/Neutral Duergar Rouge has been hung

I will now go and replace any remaining inactives.

by **edocsil** on Fri Oct 11, 2013 12:09 am

Spiesr replaces Dazza
The Weird One replaces skillfusniper33

3 days for Night 3

by **rishaed** on Fri Oct 11, 2013 6:40 am

I regret nothing. Doom ya forgive me?

by **The Weird One** on Fri Oct 11, 2013 10:18 am

Confirm...now for fifty pages of reading...the joys.

by **spiesr** on Fri Oct 11, 2013 10:21 am

The same.

by **The Weird One** on Sat Oct 12, 2013 8:51 pm

Sorry for the delay...Just saying that I'm done but not going to have a chance to do a full post 'till the morrow, sometime...just a busy couple of days. I'll be more active, starting tomorrow. Sorry.

by **spiesr** on Sat Oct 12, 2013 8:52 pm

The Weird One wrote:Sorry for the delay...Just saying that I'm done but not going to have a chance to do a full post 'till the morrow, sometime...just a busy couple of days. I'll be more active, starting tomorrow. Sorry.

It is night...

by **edocsil** on Mon Oct 14, 2013 9:02 pm

All actions are now in. Scene tomorrow evening.

by **edocsil** on Wed Oct 16, 2013 7:11 pm

Four adventurers all walk out of a bar far too late into the night. One sets a trap set to kill a foolish paladin. A snare springs and a dagger flashes and the paladin's brief cry is silenced.

The other kill is somewhat more messy. Recognizing her target an orc draws her battleaxe and slams it into a fighter's broad unsuspecting back. Some fighter's just die hard. The goliath should have been dead already, but some primal instinct kept him going. With a might roar the fighter turned and brought his sword to bear on his attacker. Quickly drawing a hand axe the orc frantically parried, and managed to strike the fighter once more in the side. Some threshold was reached, and the berserk fighter went down, dead before he struck the ground.

Doomyoshi ~ Davmorn Loyalar ~ Daykiller ~ Good/Lawful Human Paladin has been killed.

aage ~ Elben Songsteel ~ Jailkeeper ~ Good/Neutral Goliath Fighter has been killed.

It is day 4, 8 are alive 5 to hang. Deadline is ~ 2 weeks.

by **DoomYoshi** on Wed Oct 16, 2013 8:52 pm

edocsil wrote:Doomyoshi ~ Davmorn Loyalar ~ Daykiller ~ Good/Lawful Human Paladin Pro-town Hero and Saviour of the Masses has been killed.

Fixed. GG all. I had fun. And rishaed, I will forgive you, since at least you aren`t chaotic.

by **MoB Deadly** on Wed Oct 16, 2013 8:53 pm

I killed DoomYoshi..... I had to for a chance to win.

fasposted

by **MoB Deadly** on Wed Oct 16, 2013 8:58 pm

A couple things I would like to see...

The 2 replacements to say something... A couple of fresh eyes could really help us out today. Sometimes when you are in a game so large its hard to see the forest through the trees. (or however that saying goes).

There are a few "big named" mafia players out there. Rodion, Strike Wolf, Epitaph..... I need to comb through their posts to see if I can see any slips.

Epitaph has been creeping up on the suspect list..

by **MoB Deadly** on Wed Oct 16, 2013 9:01 pm

The way the vote count was formed on yesterdays lynch.. it looks like Epitaph started the wagon on rishead, but that is not the case. he was the last vote cast. I just wanted to make sure that was clear moving forward.

by **The Weird One** on Wed Oct 16, 2013 9:10 pm

MoB Deadly wrote:A couple things I would like to see...

The 2 replacements to say something... A couple of fresh eyes could really help us out today. Sometimes when you are in a game so large its hard to see the forest through the trees. (or however that saying goes).

There are a few "big named" mafia players out there. Rodion, Strike Wolf, Epitaph..... I need to comb through their posts to see if I can see any slips.

Epitaph has been creeping up on the suspect list..

For now I shall say simply that I agree with you on the Epitaph looking suspicious bit. That being said, I have a midterm tomorrow afternoon that I need to go study for some more....I'll get to posting a fully reasoned argument for that after my exam.

by **strike wolf** on Wed Oct 16, 2013 9:34 pm

8 people left. At least 1 mafia probably more. Chaos and Lawful infighting...I'm not sure we aren't at mass claim time. Thoughts?

by **Epitaph1** on Thu Oct 17, 2013 6:59 am

I'm not sure how I'm climbing up the suspect list. If we mass claim, it will put a short end to that.

But before we lay it all out on the line with a full mass claim, perhaps a mass alignment claim would be more in order.

by **anamainiacks** on Thu Oct 17, 2013 7:48 am

Epitaph1 wrote:But before we lay it all out on the line with a full mass claim, perhaps a mass alignment claim would be more in order.

I'm fine with that, though I'm not sure how that benefits us much over going straight to a mass claim - since, I assume, we'll be heading towards that eventually.

And yep, orc in the scene definitely indicates we have at least 1 scum left.

Going into last night, Epitaph did set off my scumdar a bit too.

He started the alternate wagon on rishaed:

Epitaph1 wrote:Aage suggested rishaed, who I'm not opposed to pressuring, but I think there is another candidate who is more deserving if our cases are going to be built on a person's activity/contribution: Skillful

Skillful's activity had been petering off even before everyone else went dormant and he's basically nowhere to be found today (aside from 1 post). Prior to today, he was hopping along the wagons (Aage then Stubbs. . .although Stubbs had it coming) and maintaining a level of participation that was pretty minimal. If I had to put his contributions in quotes since page 30, I don't think it would fill half a page. In sum, he's been flying under the radar at least since page 30, which is when I started my review.

Vote Skillful

He acknowledges at one point that the rishaed lynch is inevitable:

Epitaph1 wrote:I don't think rishaed is getting off the hook. If skill does get modkilled, it seems like rishaed would take his place as the person with the most votes and would get the noose instead (although, I haven't done a VC to confirm).

And later puts his vote on rishaed, possibly to gain town cred:

Epitaph1 wrote:
rishaed wrote:
rishaed wrote:Overall I still don't understand why you guys are trying to kill me other than, he may decide to vote with scum? Scum can kill me just as easily, therefor are just as much of a threat to me. Also how would I know who scum were as a commuter? Its not like i get a message from the sky from Edoc saying Hey look Scum!. Until I get endgamed/Killed I'm going to keep playing for town. -_- I would vote you mob, but you are pretty much confirmed, as well as aage, and I'm not getting into the lawful/chaot war. The most use for me is to keep me alive for you guys right now. Because I see no other option I will also vote No Lynch. The two people I would vote for today are both confirmed, so I'm not going to waste my time on them.

Scratch that No Lynch gets us nowhere. unvote Vote Ephitaph because I have no desire to get lynched, and depending on how long edoc is gone he is the next best person for a claim.

Give me a break. I'd love to hear about how I'm "the next best person for a claim" but you're just trying to deflect the attention from you in a last ditch effort to avoid the noose. I didn't care for Aage's case against you, but we've gone from that to your suspect claim and now this.

Vote rishaed

The only thing is that rishaed did vote Epi as well (wagon initiated by DoomYoshi, IIRC). Could've genuinely been a last ditch effort to escape a lynch, or a final attempt to help his scummate earn town cred with the inevitability of his lynch.

Also bear in mind that rishaed's Janitor role means that his scummate might have a good fakeclaim from new guy1's death on N1. This of course assumes that rishaed didn't use it for himself - possibly using Commander9's role as his fakeclaim.