HP: fight for freedom. Game over. Wizards won.

[chapcrap]

Well, since freezie is redefiniing majority and we need to verify SPART's legitimacy, I will unvote vote SPART

I believe that gives him 9 votes to 4. He is at L-1.

[TA1LGUNN3R]

I think we should save hippo for D2, and lynch spartacus today, because hippo's vote does seem to hop about more than usual but spartacus denied his own claim which is a greater offense in my ideas.

This. I mean I've never seen so many town who are willing to give someone who can't keep their own role straight such a high benefit of the doubt.

I might be inclined to agree with this. I'm all for giving noobs some slack, but stumbling over his claim like that...

I understand and hear you. For me the reason is that if he is innocent mafia knows he is innocent and smell blood. I would be less then honest if I were to say I have not been torn. BUT I have also been in the position he has been in in making a huge error in gameplay knowing I am innocent...that combined with the way certian players such as Dazza have jumped in to lynch after sunmarining only to disappear again makeses me side toward giving him the benifit of the doubt.

Could I be wrong? Yes.

In what way did I "just jump in to the lynch"?

I got far behind in the thread. I was busy at the end of the week and weekend as I said already. Then when I caught up he had acted scummy so i voted. Since then I have stayed active.

Are you saying if someone falls behind they are not allowed to think what they think when they catch up?

Seems crazy to me. If I continued to be inactive after voting I would understand your point.

Overreaction much?

I'm pleased I dropped the sparticus case, I am of the firm view that he is VT. Of course, DJ, you should go back and look at my posts - they are there for all to read. In doing so, you may twig to who I am. In the meantime, I'm still reading also and will let you know if I think there is a case worthy of pursuing.

What? He claimed commuter. It may be as useless as a VT when claimed, but it's not a VT.

TAILS...I'm not even sure he has more than 5 posts. He's not adding anything to this game.
Drake...same here. Very unmemorable posts. He's not adding anything to this game.

-----> This coming from the guy who was called out for being inactive ealier. There's a lot of flavor spec that I know nothing about. I read the first book and no more, and never watched the movies.

With Hippo I am now leading toward town...to be mafia and to say you have soft claimed your role and to play the way he has would be silly. I have played with him one other game and we lynched him for just such behavior and he turned town, though he was lynched for a good reason...my vote is still on him because i am not fully convinced.

If he has a (either provided or came up with on his own) a good fake-claim then he can hint at it all he wants and it only helps him...

I'm glad somebody else pointed this out. I'll bring the hammer down. vote Spartacus

-Tails

[Leehar]

Ah well, thats that. I'd still like to say for the record that I really don't think sparticus is town, come what may, and hippo was the next best case to go for, tho I read IB's comment that he's acted like this before and still flipped town so it's just his own style in a sense.

Interesting comment by the experienced guys on not splitting our votes here, which does make sense, but does that still not end up in a case of choosing the lesser of the 22 evils when they both aren't good options?

I suppose Tail's hammering and Chaps getting to l-1 could be a concern, but considering the deadline pressure, guess it makes sense

[freezie]

Vote Count

LynchedSpartacus(10): Spiesr, Alt, safari, Everywhere, Strike, Dazza, Jonty, TheHippo8, Chapcrap, Tails

Strike(1): Drake

TheHippo8(4): McHammer, Spartacus, Iron, Leehar,

With 18 alives, it takes 10 to lynch.


Lynched acheive. I am too tired to think of something not worse than my usual crappy imagination can think off, so scene will come tomorow. Feel free to send in your night actions.

Night 1 will last until Monday 22:00 Eastern standard time.

[freezie]

A small unit of wizards were keeping the top of the astronomy tower guarded and free ot any deatheaters, when they noticed one of them was flailing spells randomly outside the window, without seemingly hitting anything.

-Hey, what are you doing, and who are you? Lupin said

-I am trying to hit those deatheaters while they try to Apparate in here, and why, ''who are you?" I am your wife, tonks!

-But you don't even look like her! For the last time, who are you?

( The strange girl then changes her hair and nose back to her normal self )

-See? I am your wife.

-Hmm...Nope, you still don't look like her. And my wife has better aim than that. If you can't tell us who you are, then you're not one of them. Lupin then raised his wand, ready to confront the strange woman


Night has ben drawing near, and deatheaters has been retreating in the forest to re-group and rest. After every last of them reached the forest, wizards then turned back to rest in the great hall themselves. Only then, did they notice a body falling down from one of Hogwart's tower.

Lupin was never seen anywhere this night...


Spartacus---Nymphadora Tonks ( Wizard Commuter ) has been lynched.

Night will last until Monday, 22:00. Please send in your night actions.

[SPARTACUS1974]

like i said animorphagus so slow down HP fans

[safariguy5]

like i said animorphagus so slow down HP fans

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nymphadora_Tonks#Nymphadora_Tonks

"Nymphadora "Dora" Tonks is a Metamorphmagus, and an Auror."

[SPARTACUS1974]

like i said animorphagus so slow down HP fans

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nymphadora_Tonks#Nymphadora_Tonks

"Nymphadora "Dora" Tonks is a Metamorphmagus, and an Auror."

yes i know that but you can only follow what your role states now go to sleep

[freezie]

Shoosh. it's night.

[freezie]

Announcement

Drake has been replaced by Pancakemix.

There will also be no day scene tonight. Scene will come tomorow, as I don't feel so well tonight.

[Iron Butterfly]

ZZZZZZzzzzzzzz *Yawn*

[freezie]

The night was dark, darker than it normally is. Hogwart has been silent for a few hours, many still mourning the death of Tonks. A handful, many of the Order, has been preparing for the next day's battle, has it would not be over until Voldemort acheived full victory over the wizards, they knew it. Harry knew it. He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named told him to surrender in the Forbidden Forest so that his fellow wizards wouldn't be harmed. He started his march, without talking to anyone. But his friends were waiting for him

-Don't you dare think you're going in that forest, Harry. We'll fight him with all we've got! Hermione said

-But I must. I've placed everyone in danger, everyone will be safe. Anyway, I've had an idea why I could peer in Voldemort's mind because of my scar. Now, I know. Don't try to stop me.

-But...

-No.

Harry continued his march in the forest, and for the rest of the night, nobody saw him. A few, however, thought they seen a flash of green light. As dawn approached, the wizards knew the battle would begin anew. Voldemort didn't keep his promise

-Jonty: Harry Potter (wizard hero) Has been found dead near the entrance to the forbidden forest.


Day 2 begins. Deadline in 14 days.

[strike wolf]

What the hell? Who forgot to protect Harry?

[Nebuchadnezer]

Are you effin' kidding me? We have a body guard, presumably a doc, most likely a bus drive...and you all pick a different target? Holy crap!

Who the hell is our claimed body guard again? My vote goes there.

[safariguy5]

I protected Harry last night. Dunno what happened, may have gotten roleblocked.

[everywhere116]

I protected Harry last night. Dunno what happened, may have gotten roleblocked.

He was driven.

Mr. Bus Driver, who did you switch jonty with?

[spiesr]

I protected Harry last night. Dunno what happened, may have gotten roleblocked.

He was driven.

Possible

Mr. Bus Driver, who did you switch jonty with?

Fishing for the bus-driver now?

[thehippo8]

Maybe someone roleblocked and they got driven?

[everywhere116]

I protected Harry last night. Dunno what happened, may have gotten roleblocked.

He was driven.

Possible

Mr. Bus Driver, who did you switch jonty with?

Fishing for the bus-driver now?

The bus driver knows who the Death Eaters targeted. We can clear them both.

[strike wolf]

I protected Harry last night. Dunno what happened, may have gotten roleblocked.

He was driven.

Mr. Bus Driver, who did you switch jonty with?

First of all there was no evidence in scene to suggest busdriver so how can you say this so certainly? Second are you fishing for the busdriver.
fos everywhere.

[spiesr]

The bus driver knows who the Death Eaters targeted. We can clear them both.

Unless it is a mafia bus-driver or something...

[everywhere116]

The bus driver knows who the Death Eaters targeted. We can clear them both.

Unless it is a mafia bus-driver or something...

In which case we are screwed.

[strike wolf]

If you could point out one part of the scene that points to a busdriver being responsible than I may be slightly more inclined to believe you but even then it seems a bit far fetched if it was a town busdriver for them to attempt to kill the very same person that was switched and a bit careless (if not scummy) of you to try to get a busdriver to claim so early. Right now I don't see how you could know it was a busdriver.

Beyond that some various scenarios (not calculated for likeliness):

1. Safari was roleblocked but because he claimed he would protect Harry other protective roles backed off protecting Harry and mafia took the chance to kill Harry. Everywhere isn't directly implicated as mafia either way in this scenario. Flaw: others could still decide to protect or drive Harry.
2. Safari is mafia and used the BG claim to deter others from protecting Harry. Mafia could get a free shot and Safari could act like he had been role blocked. Everywhere again isn't directly implicated. Flaws: same as above.
3. Town BDed mafias target with Harry. If this is the case don't claim yet. Everywhere could be scum aware of the drive and trying to fish out a Power Role or he could be town who made a hasty call in his actions. Safari is not directly implicated.
4. Mafia BDed someone with harry to get the free kill. Everywhere could be scum trying to falsely clear two SBs or he could be town making a hasty decision. Safari is not directly implicated. Flaw: person busdrived with Harry could have been protected, driver could be blocked and it potentially exposes a powerful mafia role early in the game.

[strike wolf]

Ebwop: forgot to mention scenario 5 which would imply that some kind of game mechanic other than the normal mafia selects kill was activated somehow last night.

[everywhere116]

If you could point out one part of the scene that points to a busdriver being responsible than I may be slightly more inclined to believe you but even then it seems a bit far fetched if it was a town busdriver for them to attempt to kill the very same person that was switched and a bit careless (if not scummy) of you to try to get a busdriver to claim so early. Right now I don't see how you could know it was a busdriver.

Beyond that some various scenarios (not calculated for likeliness):

1. Safari was roleblocked but because he claimed he would protect Harry other protective roles backed off protecting Harry and mafia took the chance to kill Harry. Everywhere isn't directly implicated as mafia either way in this scenario. Flaw: others could still decide to protect or drive Harry.
2. Safari is mafia and used the BG claim to deter others from protecting Harry. Mafia could get a free shot and Safari could act like he had been role blocked. Everywhere again isn't directly implicated. Flaws: same as above.
3. Town BDed mafias target with Harry. If this is the case don't claim yet. Everywhere could be scum aware of the drive and trying to fish out a Power Role or he could be town who made a hasty call in his actions. Safari is not directly implicated.
4. Mafia BDed someone with harry to get the free kill. Everywhere could be scum trying to falsely clear two SBs or he could be town making a hasty decision. Safari is not directly implicated. Flaw: person busdrived with Harry could have been protected, driver could be blocked and it potentially exposes a powerful mafia role early in the game.

I'll concede that I might have been a bit hasty in trying to get the driver to tell us who he switched. I will admit, I was a little shocked and frustrated that a driver would switch jonty when he knew that he was going to be protected anyway. The only thing it did was to put jonty in danger, and we got the worst case scenario.

But I assure you, he must have been driven.