Moderator: Community Team
terrafutan wrote:trinicardinal wrote:terrafutan wrote:Apologies for been MIA, was sick.
Is it normal for a player to be subbed by a player that has already died in game ?
I've seen it happen... thing is it should mean that the 2 roles don't affect one another... meaning that a mafia that was killed cannot return as a townie... etc.. I'm wondering how this affects this game... and what the roles are
While it should be possible, I can't see how an informant should be brought back into the game.
Probably just been pedantic though, so ignore me.
I'll jump on the current bandwagon
VOTE TIGER
thehippo8 wrote:dazza2008 wrote:Hippo is bouncing around here from waggon to waggon. He seems really eager to lynch someone and get to night. That along with a fair few crazy statements i will vote Hippo.
You must have missed the point that we are chruning our way through the submariners.It is crazy. If the SK knows who the mafia are the game would be done quick. Also it would not be a sk it would be a vig. No? Sometimes your posts make loads of sense and I think you are ok then you do some crazy shit
Given you are always so obtuse and never follow what the town are doing FOS Dazzer! But otherwise get on board and help put -pressure on Irish Tiger!
thehippo8 wrote:All I can suggest now is that we hammer the submariners and hope like hell that works!!
thehippo8 wrote:I am just sitting back and waiting to see what happens now. I'm still thinking that the submariners are the ones to go for at this stage. In fact, if we do some quick days getting rid of them then the game may become more interesting? Vio indicated earlier that she thought the game was going slowly and all I can suggest is that we speed up the days from the mod end of things. My vote remains.
thehippo8 wrote:Oh, and the reference to speeding up the time limit was my (frustrated) desire to see others committing to this game a bit more! But again, if everyone is happy in silence then fine!
I don't disagree with getting rid of dead weight but we are just giving the 2 killers an opportunity to further their chances of gaining the upper hand.
Yes shield I did have a quick bandwagon vote for Zimmah, but that was more of a plan to try and get us off of all the joke voting, and start working some actual pressure. I am pretty sure the SK would have killed off LSU since he was pointing them out, and not wanting LSU to continue to try and help lead to their lynch. Which leaves Zimmah being killed by mafia.
Last vote count gave Sully on 8, and chapchap, conzocool and edocsil all voted. I almosted posted the same thing. But there are 22 players, so half +1 would make it 12 for a lynch. I think the mods forgot that they replaced the person they mod-killed.
He is also tends to focus on the people who haven't posted at all rather than the ones who post vary rarely, which in my opinion is scummier than the ones who don't show up.
The LSU death wasn't surprising to me at all after his major clue as to who the scum players were. Town Vig or a SK would be interesting to have in this game, the vig I think is out the door since I wouldn't qualify them as an anti-town roll, and if there is a vig, they seem a bit over-eager. The two mafia fractions would be an interesting twist to the game. I disagree with you on Victor not being town though edoc, I think he was a VT. Especially since he didn't try to create a very strong case to protect himself, If I were in Victors place, and scum I would have tried to pull something off to save my life, instead of just letting yourself die so early on. I have a feeling zimmah wasn't town, or at least a vanilla, he could have been an informant of some kind. I do have very strong feelings that Hippo isn't telling us the truth, and if he is scum he could have targeted zimmah since he couldn't get everyone to lynch him. As for the layout, I would think that it is totally plausible to have 6 scum, with 1 pigeon to know who each of them are, 1 pigeon to know who all the true VT, then finally 1 pigeon to know all possible 3rd party roles. This could be slightly altered if there are 2 fractions, and 1 pigeon for each, which would bring us very close to our total of 22 players. I am working on LSU's hint and removing the people who were killed, as well as all the odd, and even number combinations since he said they weren't all one, and will post the results once I get everything removed.
And Hippo can you please point out my errors, and your logic behind why the player would be a 3rd party killer? I do buy your logic for replacing Jens if he was a 3rd party killer, but just not sure how you could possibly conclude to that, and not consider the possibility of 2 Fractions. Now the chances of having 2 fractions is probably smaller than the probability of having a 3rd party killer.
The reason why I had omitted Edoc was because as you said we had to remove numbers 3, 6, and 18. This first set on your list is 22, 18, 1. Which would remove edoc from the list entirely, since that is the only combination that would allow for him to reach a total of 41. I must have just missed the completely odd sets of numbers then.
Now that we have come to a better conclusion that it is probably a SK instead of a group of scum, which was my first initial thoughts, so the list I created and removed numbers from is no longer valid.
off of the clue LSU gave there are a few key words that I first overlooked and am now pretty sure it is one person instead of a fraction. ... If there is a SK, and they are town, I would advise them to not kill unless they were completely sure of one person's alignment.
LSU Tiger Josh wrote:I'm still rereading, but a couple of things. One a 3rd party/townie generally can come back without affecting the power of the game in any role since most townies can't talk and once dead lose their "powers" that they may have had. Third parties by nature tend to keep to themselves so no new knowledge comes with that role and becoming scum would make them aware of who the actual scum is in the game. With that said, I am not claiming scum or third party lmao. I am NOT allowed to really talk about my past life and transgressions and what is said although for the most part they are mute with the numbers being changed now and deaths that have occurred since I gave out that prior clue. I do think that all informants should "float" their clues out there in some form so town can work on solving who is bad or not. Either tomorrow or Friday, I'll throw my new clue out for discussion, but for now I'll say it is double the trouble with what I do know this go round.
FoxMists wrote:You may wish to specify a Tiger, there, bloke
terrafutan wrote:FoxMists wrote:You may wish to specify a Tiger, there, bloke
Good spot, sorted.
UNVOTE VOTE IRISH
terrafutan wrote:Apologies for been MIA, was sick.
Is it normal for a player to be subbed by a player that has already died in game ?
everywhere116 wrote:You da man! Well, not really, because we're colorful ponies, but you get the idea.
shieldgenerator7 wrote:wildiwlliam, we are voting the guy to get him out of the game, or to get him replaced. We realize that he probably won't come back soon, tho he might. We are just voting him to make sure something happens
wildwilliam wrote:shieldgenerator7 wrote:wildiwlliam, we are voting the guy to get him out of the game, or to get him replaced. We realize that he probably won't come back soon, tho he might. We are just voting him to make sure something happens
I understand what you are trying to do but it makes no sense. I would understand this if he had played in games, posted in other forums, but this is not the case. He has not logged into the site since early October. He is not submarining, he is not hiding, he is just gone and no matter how many vote you put on him he is not coming back. So to vote him is a waste of time. Lets get him replaced and move on. He is a potential PRO TOWN role and may have a clue that will help us.
Commander9 wrote:Trust Edoc, as I know he's VERY good.
zimmah wrote:Mind like a brick.
Commander9 wrote:Trust Edoc, as I know he's VERY good.
zimmah wrote:Mind like a brick.
edocsil wrote:wildwilliam wrote:shieldgenerator7 wrote:wildiwlliam, we are voting the guy to get him out of the game, or to get him replaced. We realize that he probably won't come back soon, tho he might. We are just voting him to make sure something happens
I understand what you are trying to do but it makes no sense. I would understand this if he had played in games, posted in other forums, but this is not the case. He has not logged into the site since early October. He is not submarining, he is not hiding, he is just gone and no matter how many vote you put on him he is not coming back. So to vote him is a waste of time. Lets get him replaced and move on. He is a potential PRO TOWN role and may have a clue that will help us.
Replacing or mod killing are the only options at this point. I reluctantly pursued inactives yesterday due to time constraints and the general ineffectiveness of D1. We however cannot continue to do so again today. Perhaps if we run out of time we can quickly lynch an inactive, it is better then nothing. However, pursuing inactives straight from the get go is foolish at best and is a classic move by scum to appear pro-town and highly active. It however is a facade, it allows the scum to quickly advance to their night phase. To that point I will VOTE HIPPO for attempting to force the lynch of inactives and discouraging all relevant hunting.
thehippo8 wrote:@ Skill, you said ...I don't disagree with getting rid of dead weight but we are just giving the 2 killers an opportunity to further their chances of gaining the upper hand.
Well, don’t you change your tune … at page 10 you vote for Zimmah because he was silent ... and at page 25 you explained …Yes shield I did have a quick bandwagon vote for Zimmah, but that was more of a plan to try and get us off of all the joke voting, and start working some actual pressure. I am pretty sure the SK would have killed off LSU since he was pointing them out, and not wanting LSU to continue to try and help lead to their lynch. Which leaves Zimmah being killed by mafia.
Meanwhile at page 21 you said ...Last vote count gave Sully on 8, and chapchap, conzocool and edocsil all voted. I almosted posted the same thing. But there are 22 players, so half +1 would make it 12 for a lynch. I think the mods forgot that they replaced the person they mod-killed.
Your major gripe with me is …He is also tends to focus on the people who haven't posted at all rather than the ones who post vary rarely, which in my opinion is scummier than the ones who don't show up.
What gives you the right to do that but then FOS someone else for doing the same thing. This is no reason to FOS me, it is logical considerations in a mire of silence.
So what does that say about you?.
On a more important note, we first met at page 3 when you corrected me for seeing Willy! on the site when in fact he had been banned. You’d think that would be the end of it but no, you persist in your attacks on me on pages 13, 15 and 18.
SO let’s look at some of your other behaviour. On page 23 you seek to confuse LSU’s clue and further your attack on me with...The LSU death wasn't surprising to me at all after his major clue as to who the scum players were. Town Vig or a SK would be interesting to have in this game, the vig I think is out the door since I wouldn't qualify them as an anti-town roll, and if there is a vig, they seem a bit over-eager. The two mafia fractions would be an interesting twist to the game. I disagree with you on Victor not being town though edoc, I think he was a VT. Especially since he didn't try to create a very strong case to protect himself, If I were in Victors place, and scum I would have tried to pull something off to save my life, instead of just letting yourself die so early on. I have a feeling zimmah wasn't town, or at least a vanilla, he could have been an informant of some kind. I do have very strong feelings that Hippo isn't telling us the truth, and if he is scum he could have targeted zimmah since he couldn't get everyone to lynch him. As for the layout, I would think that it is totally plausible to have 6 scum, with 1 pigeon to know who each of them are, 1 pigeon to know who all the true VT, then finally 1 pigeon to know all possible 3rd party roles. This could be slightly altered if there are 2 fractions, and 1 pigeon for each, which would bring us very close to our total of 22 players. I am working on LSU's hint and removing the people who were killed, as well as all the odd, and even number combinations since he said they weren't all one, and will post the results once I get everything removed.
As we have all discerned, LSU was warning us about an SK, pure and simple. Again, the attack on me is worthless given Skill did the same. But Skill takes the confusion further that page with a version of LSU's puzzle,w hich is in error and misleading. And even more misleading information to edoc, Skill further attacks me with ...And Hippo can you please point out my errors, and your logic behind why the player would be a 3rd party killer? I do buy your logic for replacing Jens if he was a 3rd party killer, but just not sure how you could possibly conclude to that, and not consider the possibility of 2 Fractions. Now the chances of having 2 fractions is probably smaller than the probability of having a 3rd party killer.
To which there is a backtrack on page 24 to allay suspicion ...The reason why I had omitted Edoc was because as you said we had to remove numbers 3, 6, and 18. This first set on your list is 22, 18, 1. Which would remove edoc from the list entirely, since that is the only combination that would allow for him to reach a total of 41. I must have just missed the completely odd sets of numbers then.
Which could hardly be deemed a backdown on the attacks on me, nor even after Skill agrees with me without crediting me ...Now that we have come to a better conclusion that it is probably a SK instead of a group of scum, which was my first initial thoughts, so the list I created and removed numbers from is no longer valid.
Another backtrack (and another uncredited repetition of a point I made) at page 25 ...off of the clue LSU gave there are a few key words that I first overlooked and am now pretty sure it is one person instead of a fraction. ... If there is a SK, and they are town, I would advise them to not kill unless they were completely sure of one person's alignment.
All in all, you have to credit Skill for being consistent in attack but for goodness sake, give it up already!
So, enough banter ... back to the game.
Unless we have any specific plan then it remains the consensus (and yes that still includes you Skill) that we need to get the silent to speak up. LSU is right that informants need to speak up. On that note, please read my posts carefully – particularly the ones that have been criticised for irrationality. There’s more than one reason to come from left field!! Removing Sully was one of a three part puzzle for me but to unravel it requires removal of at least one more.
thehippo8 wrote:@ Skill
Aha, I understand. Fair enough, we have said our respective pieces. Incidentally, all is fair in Mafia War but nothing here is personal so please don't take offence.
So (throws dice) ... I wonder where the dice will land ...
Just to divert away from the fuedette for a moment, you (and the others) should consider again my three part conundrum. Whilst I am not at liberty to say more, my information includes a puzzle between Victor and two others but I am not at liberty to say more - at least not until more information is known. LSU (#2) is right, the other informants need to start giving us something here to avoid the potential to squable.
And, credit where credits due, I loved the idea of just FOSing evyone and being done with that exercize!!
thehippo8 wrote:@ Skill
Aha, I understand. Fair enough, we have said our respective pieces. Incidentally, all is fair in Mafia War but nothing here is personal so please don't take offence.
So (throws dice) ... I wonder where the dice will land ...
Just to divert away from the fuedette for a moment, you (and the others) should consider again my three part conundrum. Whilst I am not at liberty to say more, my information includes a puzzle between Victor and two others but I am not at liberty to say more - at least not until more information is known. LSU (#2) is right, the other informants need to start giving us something here to avoid the potential to squable.
And, credit where credits due, I loved the idea of just FOSing evyone and being done with that exercize!!
Commander9 wrote:Trust Edoc, as I know he's VERY good.
zimmah wrote:Mind like a brick.
edocsil wrote:thehippo8 wrote:@ Skill
Aha, I understand. Fair enough, we have said our respective pieces. Incidentally, all is fair in Mafia War but nothing here is personal so please don't take offence.
So (throws dice) ... I wonder where the dice will land ...
Just to divert away from the fuedette for a moment, you (and the others) should consider again my three part conundrum. Whilst I am not at liberty to say more, my information includes a puzzle between Victor and two others but I am not at liberty to say more - at least not until more information is known. LSU (#2) is right, the other informants need to start giving us something here to avoid the potential to squable.
And, credit where credits due, I loved the idea of just FOSing evyone and being done with that exercize!!
Gah, he is claiming informant guys, lay off him. Unvote I should have seen that earlier.
LSU Tiger Josh wrote:Hippo is claiming informant based off of his post. Despite that consistantly pushing for an inactive to vote off is very anti town at this point seeing how we had 2 deaths on night one from a mafia group and a sk most likely. Wild william at this point seems like town to me by pointing out that we had several people want to vote for someone that isn't a part of the site anymore. If we're going to vote for someone for being inactive, then I vote for Pancakemix as he seems to be quite quiet and I think a bit suspicious.
thehippo8 wrote:ok SO INVITING A MOD KILL HERE it was sully or terra or jens .... duh ...ok?
thehippo8 wrote:LSU Tiger Josh wrote:Hippo is claiming informant based off of his post. Despite that consistantly pushing for an inactive to vote off is very anti town at this point seeing how we had 2 deaths on night one from a mafia group and a sk most likely. Wild william at this point seems like town to me by pointing out that we had several people want to vote for someone that isn't a part of the site anymore. If we're going to vote for someone for being inactive, then I vote for Pancakemix as he seems to be quite quiet and I think a bit suspicious.
but that has to be the most reasoned thing I have heard in this VERY long day ... unvote vote panecakemix
aage wrote:Never trust CYOC or pancake.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users