Batman Mafia~~~GOTHAM WINS!!!!!!!!

[LSU Tiger Josh]

nevermind second read through it showed me that Huck Hound got hit with the vote.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

And this verifies my claim on Skoffin being up to no good that I did yesterday

[Skittles!]

It's obvious that Skoffin would of recruited some people into the cult.

I'm going to say the weird thing and read a few pages back.

[Skittles!]

No, wait, that wouldn't actually help, seeming a lot (most probably all) roles got switched around. We're gonna have to start all over again.

[Talapus]

No, wait, that wouldn't actually help, seeming a lot (most probably all) roles got switched around. We're gonna have to start all over again.

Yes, wonderful isn't it.....

[Skittles!]

No, wait, that wouldn't actually help, seeming a lot (most probably all) roles got switched around. We're gonna have to start all over again.

Yes, wonderful isn't it.....

It is actually wonderful. Brilliantly, insanely wonderful.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Kind of. It depends on whether poison Ivy got the recruiting power during Night 4. If so then she wouldn't have gotten anyone. If Ivy had the ability from the beginning of the game, then they would have some cult members. At this poitn though, I'm more concerned with finding the Joker then anyone that may have been chosen by Ivy.

[Skittles!]

Kind of. It depends on whether poison Ivy got the recruiting power during Night 4. If so then she wouldn't have gotten anyone. If Ivy had the ability from the beginning of the game, then they would have some cult members. At this poitn though, I'm more concerned with finding the Joker then anyone that may have been chosen by Ivy.

Hm, good point. If she didn't get it till night 4, then that would probably explain the note from Ivy to Hatter, as they would of been mafia, possibly.

[Talapus]

Kind of. It depends on whether poison Ivy got the recruiting power during Night 4. If so then she wouldn't have gotten anyone. If Ivy had the ability from the beginning of the game, then they would have some cult members. At this poitn though, I'm more concerned with finding the Joker then anyone that may have been chosen by Ivy.

Hm, good point. If she didn't get it till night 4, then that would probably explain the note from Ivy to Hatter, as they would of been mafia, possibly.

I might suggest looking towards the bottom of the rules at this point in time. It may help clarify...

[LSU Tiger Josh]

At least that is what I'm thinking. This is where having our cops still here would really help and even though Two Face seems to have been unknown what role he was, I'm guessing that after last night he would've been anti gotham if he wasn't already.

[pancakemix]

But there would still be cult members who switched along with Ivy, weren't there? If Skoffin's role changed, the recruits wold have probably changed as well.

[n8freeman]

Kind of. It depends on whether poison Ivy got the recruiting power during Night 4. If so then she wouldn't have gotten anyone. If Ivy had the ability from the beginning of the game, then they would have some cult members. At this poitn though, I'm more concerned with finding the Joker then anyone that may have been chosen by Ivy.

Hm, good point. If she didn't get it till night 4, then that would probably explain the note from Ivy to Hatter, as they would of been mafia, possibly.

that makes sence, except that it didnt say that she was in the mafia
it just said anti-gothom

[n8freeman]

But there would still be cult members who switched along with Ivy, weren't there? If Skoffin's role changed, the recruits wold have probably changed as well.

thats the thing, we dont know how long she has had the cult role

she could have just gained it during night 4

[Skittles!]

Kind of. It depends on whether poison Ivy got the recruiting power during Night 4. If so then she wouldn't have gotten anyone. If Ivy had the ability from the beginning of the game, then they would have some cult members. At this poitn though, I'm more concerned with finding the Joker then anyone that may have been chosen by Ivy.

Hm, good point. If she didn't get it till night 4, then that would probably explain the note from Ivy to Hatter, as they would of been mafia, possibly.

that makes sence, except that it didnt say that she was in the mafia
it just said anti-gothom

But why would a Mafia and cult recruiter be working with each other? Even though both are anti-gotham, it doesn't make that much sense that they would be working with each other.

And Talapus, I still don't know why you're meaning.. Unless it's

9)Skoffin - Pamela Lillian Isley A.K.A. “Poison Ivy” – Anti-Gotham/Evil Genius(Responsible for night 4)/Cult Recruiter

That.. But I'm still not sure. Are you talking about the end of the dead, or the actual rules?

[LSU Tiger Josh]

She may have been in mafia prior to the night as some people's alliegences changed during that night according to what Tal wrote. In reference to what he hinted at a minute ago I'm thinking it's this

Alright, so now that the basic rules have been posted, it’s time to clarify a few things. Over the last 48 hours I’ve received numerous PM’s asking for clarification of roles and wondering what Pro-Gotham & Anti-Gotham means. First off, I think it’s obvious to most of you that though there are some of the basic mafia roles in this game, there are also quite a few that aren’t. With such a wide range of characters to draw from, I just couldn’t do Batman justice by giving out all the same mafia type roles. So, don’t expect that everybody has a role that is simple or easily defined.

Secondly, in most mafia games there are two groups: mafia & townies. This game however is a bit different because all players are either Pro-Gotham, Anti-Gotham, or "The Others". Basically you know which side you’re on, but because everyone in Gotham has their own agenda and plan, there is no one player that knows who else is all on their side. So, there may be some mafia members, but they won’t know who else is technically Anti-Gotham, Pro-Gotham, or "other". Same thing for the Pro-Gotham players and "The Others" everyone is pretty much in the dark.

[Skittles!]

Also..

Players Killed:

1)XenCobra - A.K.A. “Commissioner Gordon/Chief Of Police” – Pro-Gotham/Cop
2)gimpyThewonder - A.K.A “The Riddler” – Anti-Gotham/Roleblocker
3)cmckinney - cmckinney – Dr. Milo – Pro-Gotham/Arkham Inmate(Hider)
4)nagerous - Jonah Hex - (Unknown)
5)Skittles! - Stell Bates - Pro-Gotham/Arkham Inmate(Fool)
6)kalishnikov - Dr.Victor Fries A.K.A. “Mr. Freeze” – Anti-Gotham/Asylum Mafia
7)mandalorian2298 - Detective Bullock A.K.A. “Detective” – Pro-Gotham/Detective
Koesen - Harvey Dent A.K.A “Two-Face” – (Unknown0
9)Skoffin - Pamela Lillian Isley A.K.A. “Poison Ivy” – Anti-Gotham/Evil Genius(Responsible for night 4)/Cult Recruiter
10)jnd94 - Oswald Cobblepot A.K.A. “Penguin” – Anti-Gotham/Asylum Mafia
11)Anarkistsdream - David Jolliffe – Unknown
12)Minister Masket - A.K.A. “Bat-mite” – Pro-Gotham/Arkham Inmate(Bomb)
13)Huckleberryhound - Tony Zucco - Pro-Gotham/Arkham Inmate(Fool)

It doesn't state who was the Hatter, does that mean that no one was actually the Hatter, it was just a role that Talapus put in?

[Koesen]

Once again I can't share what I think I know, hehe.

I'm not too worried about the cult, but that may be a mistake. I don't believe Skoffin was Cult Recruiter before last night.

What does it mean that the fool was lynched? Isn't that their goal?

[Skittles!]

Once again I can't share what I think I know, hehe.

I'm not too worried about the cult, but that may be a mistake. I don't believe Skoffin was Cult Recruiter before last night.

What does it mean that the fool was lynched? Isn't that their goal?

As Skittles! 1.0, I was a fool, and I got night-killed. It's not the fools goal to get lynched, you're thinking of a Jester.

[n8freeman]

Kind of. It depends on whether poison Ivy got the recruiting power during Night 4. If so then she wouldn't have gotten anyone. If Ivy had the ability from the beginning of the game, then they would have some cult members. At this poitn though, I'm more concerned with finding the Joker then anyone that may have been chosen by Ivy.

Hm, good point. If she didn't get it till night 4, then that would probably explain the note from Ivy to Hatter, as they would of been mafia, possibly.

that makes sence, except that it didnt say that she was in the mafia
it just said anti-gothom

But why would a Mafia and cult recruiter be working with each other? Even though both are anti-gotham, it doesn't make that much sense that they would be working with each other.

And Talapus, I still don't know why you're meaning.. Unless it's

9)Skoffin - Pamela Lillian Isley A.K.A. “Poison Ivy” – Anti-Gotham/Evil Genius(Responsible for night 4)/Cult Recruiter

That.. But I'm still not sure. Are you talking about the end of the dead, or the actual rules?

well no one could have known that ivy wasa cult recruiter, so she was in the mafia for protection and once she had enough recruits she went on her own, aka night 4

[Koesen]

Was that bit about "the others" already there in the first post? I only remember pro- and anti-gotham being mentioned, but I may have missed something.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

At most I'm thinking that at most we have 4 cult members left in the game. Hatter if he is in the game, and the 3 she recruited each of the first 3 nights. I'm thinking she targeted Robin last night when The Grey Ghost killed her. Evidently he was protecting Robin or else is a vigilante that targeted her. As many townies have died this game via last night and early in the game, it is possible that some of the recruits may have died as well.

However, it wouldn't surprise me if there were no other cult members in the game because I'm thinking she gained the power during the night.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

i want to say I've read that before so I think it's been there a while.

[Kernal_Kronic]

Tal, i think they need to lock you in the asylum cause this is madness...

[Talapus]

Tal, i think they need to lock you in the asylum cause this is madness...

That's the whole point...

[n8freeman]

basically


quite interesting though




im guessing this "gray ghost" must be a new role
is he sum type of vigilante?