[OFFICIAL] C9 Mafia - GAME OVER - TOWN WINS!!

[MudPuppy]

Storr - At the very least wait for IB and Virus to give their comments on the situation before voting. A lot has changed since they last posted.

Unvote me PLEASE... You can always put it back on later if you feel I'm the best person to lynch.

[StorrZerg]

It's decent trade for scum to hammer MudPuppy

[StorrZerg]

So what was the purpose of tunneling with a poor scum read?

Seemed like you had been given plenty of opportunities to expand the case or do something else to draw less attention to yourself.

[MudPuppy]

It's decent trade for scum to hammer MudPuppy

to you maybe.

Yeah, you're right... that'll leave 4v1. Of course, you probably shouldn't have said that if you are Town thought there was a chance they would try to hammer me. So, perhaps your partner in crime is not a Mafia pro and you're trying to warn him to not flinch??? If it were a veteran like IB, no warning would've been necessary.

So what was the purpose of tunneling with a poor scum read?

The tunneling I'll mostly admit too... as for the poor scum read, we'll have to wait and see.

[virus90]

im not the cop, but im not to sure that mudpuppy is either.

**speculation**
i feel like if he realy is the cop, maybe mafia will nightkill him, besides, no one counterclaimed so; so far its plausible. maybe we can direct MP to investigate someone.. its all ofcourse still speculation on if he will be telling the truth but well..
i feel like the scenario with only vt's is not so likely cause i think the mod maybe wanted some kind of powerrole to make the game interesting. its based on nothing but well.. in that assumption there is a big chance of a cop, and no one counterclaimed..
**end speculation**

but then again his game hasnt been great, the points made by others that he is tunneling on just 1 are valid, and i miss something; reads on others...

anyway i have weighted the pros and cons and i am to conclude that i wont be hammering him now, since i first want to know more about what do you think about others except for storrzerg? we kind of know you suspect him, ok, but give some more, (new) information/opinion on others. You have been accused of that and instead of giving some more reads you keep saying, storr is scummy and please dont lynch me..

time to get some sleep.. grtz

[StorrZerg]

I'm trying to out myself in your shoes to understand why you did what you did. at this point I don't believe you. (answering all the questions I posed with your full thoughts would help me) like you claimed. Yet it doesn't feel like you are scared of being lynched.

So baiting mafia to hammer you would be nice, solves what you are. And gives me a mafia to lynch tomorrow.

No mafia hammering you, keeps putting more doubt on what you are...

[MudPuppy]

i first want to know more about what do you think about others except for storrzerg? we kind of know you suspect him, ok, but give some more, (new) information/opinion on others.

Yep, I definitely plan to... I'll try to get something written up later tonight.

At this point I think a lynch of me is probably a good bet by tomorrow. I'd understand if you do it tonight but I think Town gets more bang for their buck if they wait a day. If you allow me to live into the night, there's more than a decent chance I'll die then unless 1) there's a doc or 2) mafia wants to set me up for the D2 lynch... which, if I'm not shot... and no doc claims, I'd probably vote for myself at that point... even though I know I'm Town.

What I hope will happen is that you let me live tonight. I'll check whoever you want and if alive, report back in the morning. Then either the Doc claims to say they saved me last night which buys me another read... or you lynch me to confirm my role and know my check was valid.

What I also hope will happen, as it might give me another out (and because I'm suspicious as hell of him)... is that you lynch Storr today. If you lynch him and he flips scum... then I think I'm pretty much cleared. Chances are I'd still get shot N1 (75%)... but if I don't then that means we have two power roles and the game is Town's.

FP'd by Storr

[Iron Butterfly]

unvote WCG Vote mudpuppy

Time to claim. that puts you at three.

[virus90]

ehmmm IB...
im not saying its nescesarily a bad thing... but i think its 4...

[MudPuppy]

lol... well, there's your hammer. Think you found one scum. Good game, all!

[elonpuckhog]

VOTE COUNT:

MudPuppy (4) - IB, Endgame, slander, WCG (LYNCH)
Endgame (1) - virus90
virus90 (1) - storrzerg
storrzerg (1) - MudPuppy

MudPuppy has been lynched. Lynch seen coming shortly.

[MudPuppy]

With my last breath, I think WCG and slander are worth checking... Endgame was my only real Town read and I'm not sure about him either. Virus is Townish.

[Iron Butterfly]

WTF??

[MudPuppy]

Shoot... sorry... FP'd... VERY sorry elon... tried to go so fast I didn't bother to preview.

[Iron Butterfly]

I was arguing with wife and was not paying attention full focus (wives can do that)...did not realize there were already three votes.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

WTF??

Did you miss an entire page of posts or something?

[elonpuckhog]

Back at the community center, the crowd approached the mayor. They demanded MudPuppy be killed, believing he was one of the killers.

MudPuppy (Vanilla Townie)has been lynched.

If you have a night action, please send it in by 6 PM CCT tomorrow.

[elonpuckhog]

Everyone gathered in the community room the next morning. The mayor took the podium to speak:

"There was a lot of commotion last night. I hope everyone got some sleep. If everyone could hold still a minute, I just want to get a count to make sure everyone is here. 1,2,3,4,5,6...yes, it appears everyone has survived the night."

Day 2 begins. Soft deadline is 4/23 at 15:30 CCT

With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

[StorrZerg]

Well ib what's up.....

Probably both mafia pushed mp with votes

[StorrZerg]

If I'm cop I checked endgame mafia.

Also everyone claim cop checks plz

[Iron Butterfly]

Thank God we have a doc!

Ok here is whats up. I am the Cop. What happened yesterday was a prime example of why you NEVER lie about your role when claiming if you are Town. PERIOD

When MP claimed I thought for sure we had mafia. I was torn between claiming and giving it a night and weighed the pros and cons. If I kept silent and was night killed People would see I was cop and know MP was mafia. I thought of perhaps focusing on someone else and acting as if I believed MP.

The other option was to claim my role which would mean we would lynch MP but I knew I would be night killed if there was no doc.

In both above scenarios I never fora moment though MP would be Town and weighed my decision on believing he was mafia, which is why I played the bumbling fool card. I purposely hammered MP under the charade I created thinking that when he flipped mafia we would only need to worry about 1 mafia left AND it would make mafia second guess on weather to target me or not.

Needless to say...when the results came in I wanted to kick myself for not taking into consideration that he was VT.

I cop checked Storr he is Town. I agree normally I would not have if MP had flipped mafia, when he flipped Town my whole way I saw the game changed. I thought we more likely then not had Town on MP and we could narrow it down from there.

Anyways...there are a whole bunch of WIFO me scenarios that can be created. Here's the good news the doc also knows they saved Town.

I know I am cop, I know Storr is Town. LOL I hope Storr is not the doc.

If you choose not to believe me and think I may be mafia KNOW for a fact there is a DOC, which is just as good as a cop because they saved Town.

I know I am Town and I know Storr is Town. If any one comes forward to claim doc and is counter claimed, we know there is Mafia between the two....*grin* unless a VT claims otherwise.

Town has been save by sheer luck of probabilities!!

[StorrZerg]

You hard claiming cop? any counter claims?

waiting to decide if i am

[StorrZerg]

If the doc claims then we have majority if the save was not on IB....

since who ever doc saved is confirmed...

SO doc please claim, games auto.

[StorrZerg]

Also, IB why check me if you had a light town read on me?

[Iron Butterfly]

I'm trying to out myself in your shoes to understand why you did what you did. at this point I don't believe you. (answering all the questions I posed with your full thoughts would help me) like you claimed. Yet it doesn't feel like you are scared of being lynched.

So baiting mafia to hammer you would be nice, solves what you are. And gives me a mafia to lynch tomorrow.

No mafia hammering you, keeps putting more doubt on what you are...

This. I second guessed when he flipped Town.

If it's any consolation the mod is SUPER quick...I changed my mind after 30 min or so...he had already given results. Can't prove it but whatever. I would have checked WCG or Slander.

With you seeming not to be doc we should be good.