Batman Mafia~~~GOTHAM WINS!!!!!!!!

[Talapus]

Gah That was addressed to Talapus, I was watching rocky horror picture show while I was posting

Great movie by the way, and I answered your question.


Let's do the time warp again.....

[pancakemix]

So there are 24 hours left of Day 4?

[Skoffin]

Well then.. since I am very tired, cranky and sore and cannot die (yet) then I might as well leave off what I was going to say till morn.

But Tal, I really don't like you right now. Who wants to have a mod lynch?

[Talapus]

So there are 24 hours left of Day 4?

Yep...24 real time hours. I knew a lot of players were gone for the weekend, so I needed to give them time to catch up on whats going on.

[Skoffin]

Gah That was addressed to Talapus, I was watching rocky horror picture show while I was posting

Great movie by the way, and I answered your question.


Let's do the time warp again.....

Oh man, don't start me. I've been going on about the time warp to people for the past 20 minutes.

[Huckleberryhound]

A forced no lynch....i sure hope there are no night lynches either.

unvote vote LSU


for having a naff avatar

[derfderf34]

so what do we do the rest of the day?

wtw im back

[Koesen]

Interesting. I guess now we just wait and see...

[jnd94]

As it sounds like this game will be getting harder, I want to clear my case a little more. As ML and a few others hae pointed out, I was asleep during kalishnikov's death. I didnt vote him earlieer because I wanted a reason for his voting the claimed cop, which never came when I was awake.

Another thing, what freezie pointed out about me being in cahoots with two-face. This cannot be possible. If Koesen and I were mafia, he would not be allowed back into the gmae, on account of he would kinow who was mafia. That also shows that two-face wasprobably in it by himself, which doersnt bring up as many leads, if instead it was mafia with a possible partner.

[Kernal_Kronic]

Okay, nice...i reread everything & then find out at the end of it all that there's no lynching Well tomorrow should be interesting, but anyway...Neutrino posted what i thought of ML vote & FOS's.

Kwanton more than anyone has seemed to be very careful with his vote...almost like you had to twist his arm to vote for kalish, and even after he voted for kalish, he still questioned Mandy.

I know some of you may be thinking how could anyone fully trust Mandy at the time? well, now that we know Mandy was Pro-Gotham and kalish was Anti-Gotham, we can view some of the players in this game as knowing who was on which side at the time.

Vote Kernal_Kronic

FOS Skoffin

You seem to be most suspicious of Kwanton there, yet he dosent even warrant a FOS. Why is this?

And aren't the Anti- players supposed to be in the dark about eachother's identities? How then could they know who their scum buddies are?

The reason i didn't vote kalish was because i was waiting for him to post some defense & someone had posted that if anybody drops the hammer until the defense came then he would be highly suspicious of that person & i wasn't 100% sure that kalish was scum. If i had brought down the hammer & he had turned out to be a townie then i would have had a rope around my neck...

Then there was something from some people concerning that lack of substance or simply lack of posts, but then are more than happy to leave someone around who's doing nothing to help the asylum & if a "Fool" is the same as a townie then why don't the mafia take out a known fool?

I think i'll use the fool approach next time i'm in a game. Actually...

Im A FoOl, whooohooo...VotE me! VoTe Me!

[freezie]

As it sounds like this game will be getting harder, I want to clear my case a little more. As ML and a few others hae pointed out, I was asleep during kalishnikov's death. I didnt vote him earlieer because I wanted a reason for his voting the claimed cop, which never came when I was awake.

Another thing, what freezie pointed out about me being in cahoots with two-face. This cannot be possible. If Koesen and I were mafia, he would not be allowed back into the gmae, on account of he would kinow who was mafia. That also shows that two-face wasprobably in it by himself, which doersnt bring up as many leads, if instead it was mafia with a possible partner.

Thanks, but I realised.

I would unvote, but what's the point now..

I am more suspicious of skoffin than you now, but since I know skoffin's style is hardly any votes....I dont know.


Kwanton, I feel he's much more helpful than many people, and therefor doesn't got my suspicion.

Right now..I really don't know. Yet I am still having a bad feeling about ML. Not much, but still a little.

[freezie]

The reason i didn't vote kalish was because i was waiting for him to post some defense & someone had posted that if anybody drops the hammer until the defense came then he would be highly suspicious of that person & i wasn't 100% sure that kalish was scum. If i had brought down the hammer & he had turned out to be a townie then i would have had a rope around my neck...

He did post a defence. A very weak one.

FOS KK

[kwanton]

Everyone at least vote.

This line caught my eye.

"Those inmates unwilling to cooperate will be sentenced to lethal injection and said punishment will be carried out on live TV."

Maybe that means those who aren't posting much and voting will be modkilled. I'm probably wrong but better safe....

Vote Firecoal

[pancakemix]

Everyone at least vote.

This line caught my eye.

"Those inmates unwilling to cooperate will be sentenced to lethal injection and said punishment will be carried out on live TV."

Maybe that means those who aren't posting much and voting will be modkilled. I'm probably wrong but better safe....

Vote Firecoal

Maybe... but since there won't be a lynch, we can just do whatever and it won't matter, so I'm gonna Vote Random.

[Fircoal]

Everyone at least vote.

This line caught my eye.

"Those inmates unwilling to cooperate will be sentenced to lethal injection and said punishment will be carried out on live TV."

Maybe that means those who aren't posting much and voting will be modkilled. I'm probably wrong but better safe....

Vote Firecoal

Maybe... but since there won't be a lynch, we can just do whatever and it won't matter, so I'm gonna Vote Random.

you're in this game?

[pancakemix]

Everyone at least vote.

This line caught my eye.

"Those inmates unwilling to cooperate will be sentenced to lethal injection and said punishment will be carried out on live TV."

Maybe that means those who aren't posting much and voting will be modkilled. I'm probably wrong but better safe....

Vote Firecoal

Maybe... but since there won't be a lynch, we can just do whatever and it won't matter, so I'm gonna Vote Random.

you're in this game?

You voted for me first.

[Minister Masket]

"Trust No-One"
Well that was the last stepping stone. Welcome the X-Files people.
Anyhoo, if what Kwanton says is true, I'm going with my prime suspect.

VOTE FIRCOAL

[freezie]

Everyone at least vote.

This line caught my eye.

"Those inmates unwilling to cooperate will be sentenced to lethal injection and said punishment will be carried out on live TV."

Maybe that means those who aren't posting much and voting will be modkilled. I'm probably wrong but better safe....

Vote Firecoal

Maybe... but since there won't be a lynch, we can just do whatever and it won't matter, so I'm gonna Vote Random.

Basicly, you have no suspicion in head? Even aty this point, voting random means you got nothing to contribute..

[Minister Masket]

Everyone at least vote.

This line caught my eye.

"Those inmates unwilling to cooperate will be sentenced to lethal injection and said punishment will be carried out on live TV."

Maybe that means those who aren't posting much and voting will be modkilled. I'm probably wrong but better safe....

Vote Firecoal

Maybe... but since there won't be a lynch, we can just do whatever and it won't matter, so I'm gonna Vote Random.

Basicly, you have no suspicion in head? Even aty this point, voting random means you got nothing to contribute..

Voting random is considered scummish behaviour. I should know.

[freezie]

Everyone at least vote.

This line caught my eye.

"Those inmates unwilling to cooperate will be sentenced to lethal injection and said punishment will be carried out on live TV."

Maybe that means those who aren't posting much and voting will be modkilled. I'm probably wrong but better safe....

Vote Firecoal

Maybe... but since there won't be a lynch, we can just do whatever and it won't matter, so I'm gonna Vote Random.

Basicly, you have no suspicion in head? Even aty this point, voting random means you got nothing to contribute..

Voting random is considered scummish behaviour. I should know.

Thanks for ALMOST learning me something. But we're getting a no lynch ANYWAY.

So, I understand pancake just doing this because it means nothing, but we still should use our 23 hours wisely. Anyway.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Well then.. since I am very tired, cranky and sore and cannot die (yet) then I might as well leave off what I was going to say till morn.

But Tal, I really don't like you right now. Who wants to have a mod lynch?

Yet again Skoffin contributes nothing . I'm about to go through and find her posts from days 2and 3 to post how very unhelpful that she has been this game..

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Here is a continuation of Skoffin's lack of helpfulness in this game.

Day 2

Posted: 15 Jun 2007 19:35 Post subject:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

First I'd just like to say awesome job on the night scene Talapus. Even if it was a bit long =P
And how do you lot make so many pages of posts so quickly? I'm going through it all now

Anarkistsdream wrote:
Vote: Gethine
for being Welsh

*smacks you* The welsh are awesome.




Posted: 15 Jun 2007 21:07 Post subject:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Okay I read through all this and then went to do something.. but then I forgot what I was going to say *hangs head*

Well for now I'd like to add that, if memory serves me right(I haven't seen batman for quite a while now) that the Riddler worked with Two-face, so those two could be a team with maybe a few minions.
And ML, brilliant thought about the possibility of Mr.Freeze, I never would of thought of that, and it makes sense.

Last thing, why are we leaving Derf alive? He's acting like a loon, and The joker was a complete loon. And say he is telling the truth, he even said he has to vote randomly. If he can't vote for whom everyone suspects to be scum, because that wouldn't be random, doesn't that make him completly useless to us?



Posted: 15 Jun 2007 21:40 Post subject:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Where the heck is Spin? I haven't seen him make any post here since he replaced whatsit


Posted: 15 Jun 2007 23:17 Post subject:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Catwoman was in Batman, she also worked with Penguin for a bit.

Who was the Mad Hatter? I don't remember such a character.

Posted: 15 Jun 2007 23:27 Post subject:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Skittles! wrote:
Ah, that clears things up. So Catwoman could be working with the Penguin, or she could be a Townie.


I don't think she'd be townie, she tried to kill Batman afterall. She could even be a serial killer.

Thus ends her day 2 contributions. Worthwhile posts in there stating her belief in why catwoman could possibly be a serial killer and stating that she thought possibly two face could work with the riddler. However, the riddler died back on night 1

[derfderf34]

since everyone is still voting

vote skoffin for only posting in red

[Minister Masket]

You do realise there's a No Lynch tommorow? Not much point in gathering others to your cause LSU, it's every man/woman for themselves now.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Day 3 posts by Skoffin

Posted: 19 Jun 2007 20:34 Post subject:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Heh I was going through this and I was actually thinking along the lines of D Koesen. What I don't get is why he claimed when he wasn't even in the line of fire, usually people make such claims when they're nearly at a lynch. Claiming possible insane cop is a good way for scum to lynch off a townie and still look somewhat innocent in the process. But there's still reason to suspect you, but at the same time we shouldn't just take Mandy's word for it. Either everyone needs to look back through and find something concrete or we need to find another suspect for now.

Posted: 19 Jun 2007 20:37 Post subject:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

MountainLion wrote:
I don't know what to think right now, but like I said before, Talapus hasn't even set a time limit for this day, so please LET'S TAKE OUR TIME.

We haven't even heard from everyone. Let's wait for everyone to post. Maybe someone will say "I'm Bullock," or we could get more clues in one direction or another.

Unvote

Vote gethine


No! I am Bullock! I mean Spartacus.

Ahem. Thing is, if someone else claimed the role, should we believe them? I've played games before where one person claimed cop or doc, then someone else said that they were and the other was lying, so everyone killed the real doc/cop. So be wary, always.


Posted: 19 Jun 2007 20:41 Post subject:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Koesen wrote:
Koesen wrote:
b) I am, unknowingly, the kind of character that gives the opposite result when investigated (Miller? I forget what they're called). In that case, a lynch is a loss for the town.

c) There's a bus driver who switched me and somebody else. Again, this will result in a loss for the town if I am lynched.


I agree with Kwanton that b and c appear far fetched, but b happende to me last week in Maxisg8's Zombie mafia game, where Spinwizard looked scummy but was town, and c may have happened to me in the fishing trip mafia, where Mandy himself claimed he bus drove me to somebody else's place.

Unlikely, yes. Impossible, no. Unlike this back up cop theory, which can't be true if he was investigating people already in the first night.


Ha yeah, I was the cop that investigated that and got scum on a innocent. C has happened to me also. Makes you want to just gang up on the mod doesn't it?

Posted: 20 Jun 2007 21:39 Post subject:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I'm still not sure if I should trust Mandy on this at this time, and even he's not sure what kind of cop he is. I personally would rather have him double check someone to make sure of his mental status before we start lynching on his whim.

And just wondering, does anyone else have this irrisitible urge to kill off Derf? I know people keep saying he's a fool and all, but Skittles was too and they posted coherent sentences and tried to somewhat help the town. So what's Derf's excuse?

Posted: 20 Jun 2007 23:10 Post subject:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Koesen wrote:
You mean someone who claims to be an actual pro townie. There is no solid proof that Mandalorian is pro town, as far as I know.

I agree that your point about the lack of a counterclaim is valid, but on the other hand, I think there are quite a few people who haven't said anything yet, so who knows?


You're a bit agressive there. Am I expressing myself that badly or did you have a cup of coffee too many?


Yes there is, he said so.

Who who counterclaim cop anyway? That's just getting a noose over your neck while you're at it.

Perhaps he is wearing his cranky pants?

Posted: 21 Jun 2007 00:09 Post subject:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Yeah, little disappointing defence there. How many votes are currently on him anyway?

Posted: 21 Jun 2007 00:12 Post subject:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

LSU Tiger Josh wrote:
I think we're at -1 for lynch on him. Given his lack of defense it should be safe enough for anyone to hammer him.


I'm thinking about it, but I think I might just give him a few more minutes for him to think if there's anything else he'd like to add.


Posted: 21 Jun 2007 00:15 Post subject:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

kalishnikov wrote:
Skoffin wrote:
Yeah, little disappointing defence there. How many votes are currently on him anyway?


Jesus, I wanted to reply to that one specific post, in the like 5 minutes it took to right the next one you guys sure have jumped to an awful lot of conclusions...


That's what I figured so I decided to wait for you, I didn't see your name anywhere so I thought you might of went offline.


Posted: 21 Jun 2007 00:17 Post subject:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Chad22342 wrote:
Chad22342 wrote:
It says you need a replacement. I'll play if it's ok. My role was replaced earlier when I was modkilled for inactivity but I'm back now and I don't know who took my role.


You don't need to repeat yourself, the mod will see it when he goes through to tally votes.


Posted: 21 Jun 2007 00:53 Post subject:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Chad22342 wrote:
kwanton wrote:
Chad22342 wrote:
Chad22342 wrote:
It says you need a replacement. I'll play if it's ok. My role was replaced earlier when I was modkilled for inactivity but I'm back now and I don't know who took my role.



It says it on the first post. Neutrino FYI.


Well then why would it have replacement needed ASAP on the top.


He means it says who replaced you on the front page. Thus you cannot replace anyone in this game.

Closest thing to real helpfulness in here is in regards to explaining why we shouldn't just trust mandy for his claim and brought up an example of what had happened with her. Other then that she wanted to make fun of mandy and also my going after scum Kalish. She did say that Kalish's argument was a bit disapointing, but evidently still wasn't enough for her to vote. While I don't know for sure that she is scum, to me her actions dictate scumlike tendencies.