A Cino Filled Mafia (2/27) *Game Over*

[ga7]

Ugh, I really don't get why you claimed Saf... Doc with 40 phds and regular doc isn't the same role, and while the fact TWO died (and your character for that matter) hints on you being an insane doc (kills his target), let's not forget TWO had Mandy the scum busdriver in his team... So your action might have reached someone else entirely.
In any case, FOS everyone voting Nark just because he voted for himself.
-Nark claimed doc with 40 phds since forever, although he claimed to be Commie's lyncher also
-Saf claimed doc which could be really vig
-Strike claimed not to be doc
It's pretty obvious who to pressure. I'm very curious what claim he'll come up with, not being a doc with 40 phds. The fact he believes Nark is town doesn't give me much confidence, it's a rather conciliatory approach, and a smart scum move.

Vote Strike Wolf

[Anarkistsdream]

I protected Doom Yoshi night one...

40 PhDs means I have too much time on my hands.

Actually, being furloughed does, which didn't end for me like it did for most everyone else... Damn grant funded jobs... Never work on strictly grant funded programs, friends.

I like how Jonty says town doc should never vote himself right after he votes me... Guaranteed mostly scum on my bandwagon, folks!

[ga7]

Thought Dr Phil was a joke scum role in this game, but Chu used it in this one also. Scary role list there:

For the 2011 Summer Mafia Awards
Roles for Roll Mafia I by Fircoal


Frenchie-chan (Dr. Phil) Night 3 - Killed
/ (Doc with 40 phDs)
Pancakemix (Doctor)
Aage (Doc with 41 phDs)
Skoffin (Dr. Mario)
Tails (replaced xuereb) (SK) - Day 3 - Daykill
Victor (Doctor Jester) - Night 2 - Nightkill
Naggy (Doctor with 39phDs) - Day 2 - Lynch
TWO (Kicker) - Night 1 - Nightkill
safari (Doctor with 0 phDs) - Day 1 -Lynch

When the town woke up they realized they sucked dick and screwed themselves over. / covered for pancake, and so did Frenchie-chan who sadly didn't know he was also blocking pancake who was trying to save him. In the end aage easily picked off Frenchie-chan and that was it.

Frenchie-chan (Dr. Phil) has died.
/ (Doc with 40 phDs) has been endgamed.
Pancakemix (Doctor) has been endgamed.

Aage (Doc with 41 phDs) and Skoffin (Dr. Mario) have won.

Skoffin now has to her credit the easiest win ever, not even having to do an action. The actions for teh scum team were still in Flores mode so AAge was sending both, and the action was sent before Skoffin replaced. Thusly she did NOTHING (and won).

Notes:
All players but Dr. SK, the kicker, and Dr. Mario could protect. (though Safari was naive) That means if NAggy and Victor got off their lazy buts and sent in actions, this could have been a different game.
All docs with more than 1 phD gave an extra live to the one they protected. (not just the one with 40phDs)

You know, considering DoomYoshi has supposedly an extra life now, I think we could just try to lynch him and see if Nark tells the truth. Win-win situation here!

[strike wolf]

Thought Dr Phil was a joke scum role in this game, but Chu used it in this one also. Scary role list there:

For the 2011 Summer Mafia Awards
Roles for Roll Mafia I by Fircoal


Frenchie-chan (Dr. Phil) Night 3 - Killed
/ (Doc with 40 phDs)
Pancakemix (Doctor)
Aage (Doc with 41 phDs)
Skoffin (Dr. Mario)
Tails (replaced xuereb) (SK) - Day 3 - Daykill
Victor (Doctor Jester) - Night 2 - Nightkill
Naggy (Doctor with 39phDs) - Day 2 - Lynch
TWO (Kicker) - Night 1 - Nightkill
safari (Doctor with 0 phDs) - Day 1 -Lynch

When the town woke up they realized they sucked dick and screwed themselves over. / covered for pancake, and so did Frenchie-chan who sadly didn't know he was also blocking pancake who was trying to save him. In the end aage easily picked off Frenchie-chan and that was it.

Frenchie-chan (Dr. Phil) has died.
/ (Doc with 40 phDs) has been endgamed.
Pancakemix (Doctor) has been endgamed.

Aage (Doc with 41 phDs) and Skoffin (Dr. Mario) have won.

Skoffin now has to her credit the easiest win ever, not even having to do an action. The actions for teh scum team were still in Flores mode so AAge was sending both, and the action was sent before Skoffin replaced. Thusly she did NOTHING (and won).

Notes:
All players but Dr. SK, the kicker, and Dr. Mario could protect. (though Safari was naive) That means if NAggy and Victor got off their lazy buts and sent in actions, this could have been a different game.
All docs with more than 1 phD gave an extra live to the one they protected. (not just the one with 40phDs)

You know, considering DoomYoshi has supposedly an extra life now, I think we could just try to lynch him and see if Nark tells the truth. Win-win situation here!

Does the Doc with 40 Ph Ds work that way? or is it just 1 shot bulletproof? I don't remember.

Safari I realized why you claimed but it's pretty useless since if anything you just left believability that you are naive or insane and leave room for another doctor to be in the game. So nothing was really proven.

For those wondering why I'm not a doc. The 40 Ph D role hasn't always been reserved for docs:

Aage
You are the Cop with 40 phDs. Your dad was so pushy on you, said you had to go to medical school or you couldn’t be considered his real son and would just be a failure at life. Well look where that got you! After 40 phDs trying to appease your dad it ends up in a large failure all because of a couple mistakes during heart surgery. But that’s ok, just because you can’t tell a taser from a gun doesn’t stop the police from taking you in. Each night you are able to investigate someone and find out if they are scummy mafia, scummy killers, neutral 3rd parties, or a nice helpful town. You win when the town is rid of all scummy threats. Confirm in thread.

viewtopic.php?f=610&t=138787&p=3045870&hilit=40+PhD*#p3045870

Unvote, vote Strike Wolf.

I don't believe Nark's and Strike's roles are different, and since Strike is not counter claiming Nark's claim of town doctor, Strike must be one of the scum factions. If not, then Nark is.

rishaed, nice of you to post but ignore the point I raised against you.

@Doom, why are you voting for rishaed? It's just causing more issues in lynching someone. Whilst I certainly don't trust rishaed, he is not a concern at the moment and not a priority. We need to to lynch between the doctors. It seems odd that you're trying to cause more confusion, as much of a troll that you are.

@Rodion, why vote for saf?

If I voted for everyone who voted me, logically or illogically, I wouldn't be a very good mafia player. I laid out my reasons why I think Nark is town. He pursued this idea that based on having similar PRs one of us must be town and the other scum. I could see a mafia or other anti-town role taking that up as evidence to support my lynch but Nark has gone after it so fervently that when I turn out to be town he would have to be lucky to survive the night just to be the main lynch target the next day. Scum will pursue cases on innocents, that's obvious but smart scum (And I do believe Nark to be smart, after all he has as many Ph Ds as I do) would not put themselves in an inescapable position to do so. So that leaves me with three possibilities:

1. Nark is town and believes the case he puts forward.
2. Nark is my lyncher and wins upon my death. Well he's certainly waited long enough to follow through on that if it was actually the case. Also wasn't he already Comm's lyncher? Wait Comm had a PR too...is Nark the PR lyncher? Does he have to get himself lynched as well? That last bit was sarcasm for those who couldn't tell.
3. Nark is a jester and hopes to get himself lynched indirectly when I turn up town. He did vote for himself but before that I didn't see much jester like behavior from him and his PR as far as I can tell is legitimate.

the first option seems the most likely to me. As people have said, fir isn't very predictable and I am not willing to say there are two people with similar PRs so one must be scum because of it.

[rishaed]

rishaed you often seem to do a good job of sidetracking away from the main focus, quite often too.

If you meant this as a point, then I just didn't deem it worth anything to respond to. I explore things, thoroughly if i can, to get a better understanding of things. If that means sidetracking a tiny bit then sure. However if I have a strong scum tell.....
Anyways:
If Nark was Comm's lyncher- then: he would have won when Comm9 was lynched?
Also, he just claimed doc, after doing random BS on the front of hey just b/c I have 40 PHD's doesn't mean that I'm a doc, he goes and claims doc.

Also night actions please, nark.
I have no desire to lynch a claimed town doc (not unless we have absolute evidence otherwise....)

[Anarkistsdream]

rishaed you often seem to do a good job of sidetracking away from the main focus, quite often too.

If you meant this as a point, then I just didn't deem it worth anything to respond to. I explore things, thoroughly if i can, to get a better understanding of things. If that means sidetracking a tiny bit then sure. However if I have a strong scum tell.....
Anyways:
If Nark was Comm's lyncher- then: he would have won when Comm9 was lynched?
Also, he just claimed doc, after doing random BS on the front of hey just b/c I have 40 PHD's doesn't mean that I'm a doc, he goes and claims doc.

Also night actions please, nark.
I have no desire to lynch a claimed town doc (not unless we have absolute evidence otherwise....)

Already gave you night actions, ya skimmer...

40 PhDs on the wall.. take one down, passit around, doesn't matter because my name is on it.

[safariguy5]

Ugh, I really don't get why you claimed Saf... Doc with 40 phds and regular doc isn't the same role, and while the fact TWO died (and your character for that matter) hints on you being an insane doc (kills his target), let's not forget TWO had Mandy the scum busdriver in his team... So your action might have reached someone else entirely.
In any case, FOS everyone voting Nark just because he voted for himself.
-Nark claimed doc with 40 phds since forever, although he claimed to be Commie's lyncher also
-Saf claimed doc which could be really vig
-Strike claimed not to be doc
It's pretty obvious who to pressure. I'm very curious what claim he'll come up with, not being a doc with 40 phds. The fact he believes Nark is town doesn't give me much confidence, it's a rather conciliatory approach, and a smart scum move.

Vote Strike Wolf

Wait, are you saying that Doc with 40 PHD's is different because of PR or because of something else?

If we assume both nark and I are telling the truth, then it's possible we have 2 doctors (one of which may not be sane). I know it was mentioned someone might have been a PGO and that is why we had the extra deaths, would a PGO negate a protection? Possibly multiple kills targeted TWO?

I understand that claiming now might not be the most productive, but I feel that if we can build consensus on something, that would be a step in the right direction. Seeing as how there is a non zero chance that we can get something from nark or strike in this case, it's a chance I'm willing to take.

Besides, based on the number of deaths, I get the feeling one protection isn't going to stop much killing, especially with the multiple scum factions.

[Anarkistsdream]

Ugh, I really don't get why you claimed Saf... Doc with 40 phds and regular doc isn't the same role, and while the fact TWO died (and your character for that matter) hints on you being an insane doc (kills his target), let's not forget TWO had Mandy the scum busdriver in his team... So your action might have reached someone else entirely.
In any case, FOS everyone voting Nark just because he voted for himself.
-Nark claimed doc with 40 phds since forever, although he claimed to be Commie's lyncher also
-Saf claimed doc which could be really vig
-Strike claimed not to be doc
It's pretty obvious who to pressure. I'm very curious what claim he'll come up with, not being a doc with 40 phds. The fact he believes Nark is town doesn't give me much confidence, it's a rather conciliatory approach, and a smart scum move.

Vote Strike Wolf

Wait, are you saying that Doc with 40 PHD's is different because of PR or because of something else?

If we assume both nark and I are telling the truth, then it's possible we have 2 doctors (one of which may not be sane). I know it was mentioned someone might have been a PGO and that is why we had the extra deaths, would a PGO negate a protection? Possibly multiple kills targeted TWO?

I understand that claiming now might not be the most productive, but I feel that if we can build consensus on something, that would be a step in the right direction. Seeing as how there is a non zero chance that we can get something from nark or strike in this case, it's a chance I'm willing to take.

Besides, based on the number of deaths, I get the feeling one protection isn't going to stop much killing, especially with the multiple scum factions.

Well hell, Safari... Are you trying to tell me one save doesn't help town, when more than likely I will die tonight? I think you are a MAFIA DOC... Or definately anti town. One vote doesn't make a difference, so why vote? One protection doesn't help us, so why try, right? Scum scum SCUM! 40 PhDs.

And I am still correct about Strike, and so, again I say, I will not post again... I am tired of pointing out the obvious.

[shrewstur]

James said: If DY is scum, lynch me.

I said I would not reciprocate. Reciprocating would be: if James is scum, lynch me.

Therefore, if James is scum, do not lynch me.

I wasn't saying if James is town, don't lynch me. I am sorry that I wasn't clear there ga7.

Do you understand now?

err by logic what you said is this : if James is scum, do not lynch me. = if James is town, lynch me. sorry, but you explained it yourself ^^

I don't like how badly you're trying to twist Doom's words.

For those wondering why I'm not a doc. The 40 Ph D role hasn't always been reserved for docs:

Aage
You are the Cop with 40 phDs. Your dad was so pushy on you, said you had to go to medical school or you couldn’t be considered his real son and would just be a failure at life. Well look where that got you! After 40 phDs trying to appease your dad it ends up in a large failure all because of a couple mistakes during heart surgery. But that’s ok, just because you can’t tell a taser from a gun doesn’t stop the police from taking you in. Each night you are able to investigate someone and find out if they are scummy mafia, scummy killers, neutral 3rd parties, or a nice helpful town. You win when the town is rid of all scummy threats. Confirm in thread.

viewtopic.php?f=610&t=138787&p=3045870&hilit=40+PhD*#p3045870

Unvote, vote Strike Wolf.

I don't believe Nark's and Strike's roles are different, and since Strike is not counter claiming Nark's claim of town doctor, Strike must be one of the scum factions. If not, then Nark is.

rishaed, nice of you to post but ignore the point I raised against you.

@Doom, why are you voting for rishaed? It's just causing more issues in lynching someone. Whilst I certainly don't trust rishaed, he is not a concern at the moment and not a priority. We need to to lynch between the doctors. It seems odd that you're trying to cause more confusion, as much of a troll that you are.

@Rodion, why vote for saf?

If I voted for everyone who voted me, logically or illogically, I wouldn't be a very good mafia player. I laid out my reasons why I think Nark is town. He pursued this idea that based on having similar PRs one of us must be town and the other scum. I could see a mafia or other anti-town role taking that up as evidence to support my lynch but Nark has gone after it so fervently that when I turn out to be town he would have to be lucky to survive the night just to be the main lynch target the next day. Scum will pursue cases on innocents, that's obvious but smart scum (And I do believe Nark to be smart, after all he has as many Ph Ds as I do) would not put themselves in an inescapable position to do so. So that leaves me with three possibilities:

1. Nark is town and believes the case he puts forward.
2. Nark is my lyncher and wins upon my death. Well he's certainly waited long enough to follow through on that if it was actually the case. Also wasn't he already Comm's lyncher? Wait Comm had a PR too...is Nark the PR lyncher? Does he have to get himself lynched as well? That last bit was sarcasm for those who couldn't tell.
3. Nark is a jester and hopes to get himself lynched indirectly when I turn up town. He did vote for himself but before that I didn't see much jester like behavior from him and his PR as far as I can tell is legitimate.

the first option seems the most likely to me. As people have said, fir isn't very predictable and I am not willing to say there are two people with similar PRs so one must be scum because of it.

I was thinking that it could be the mod being unpredictable, too. I would rather that one or the other's role could be investigated, preferably Strike Wolf's.

[Anarkistsdream]

James said: If DY is scum, lynch me.

I said I would not reciprocate. Reciprocating would be: if James is scum, lynch me.

Therefore, if James is scum, do not lynch me.

I wasn't saying if James is town, don't lynch me. I am sorry that I wasn't clear there ga7.

Do you understand now?

err by logic what you said is this : if James is scum, do not lynch me. = if James is town, lynch me. sorry, but you explained it yourself ^^

I don't like how badly you're trying to twist Doom's words.

For those wondering why I'm not a doc. The 40 Ph D role hasn't always been reserved for docs:

Aage
You are the Cop with 40 phDs. Your dad was so pushy on you, said you had to go to medical school or you couldn’t be considered his real son and would just be a failure at life. Well look where that got you! After 40 phDs trying to appease your dad it ends up in a large failure all because of a couple mistakes during heart surgery. But that’s ok, just because you can’t tell a taser from a gun doesn’t stop the police from taking you in. Each night you are able to investigate someone and find out if they are scummy mafia, scummy killers, neutral 3rd parties, or a nice helpful town. You win when the town is rid of all scummy threats. Confirm in thread.

viewtopic.php?f=610&t=138787&p=3045870&hilit=40+PhD*#p3045870

Unvote, vote Strike Wolf.

I don't believe Nark's and Strike's roles are different, and since Strike is not counter claiming Nark's claim of town doctor, Strike must be one of the scum factions. If not, then Nark is.

rishaed, nice of you to post but ignore the point I raised against you.

@Doom, why are you voting for rishaed? It's just causing more issues in lynching someone. Whilst I certainly don't trust rishaed, he is not a concern at the moment and not a priority. We need to to lynch between the doctors. It seems odd that you're trying to cause more confusion, as much of a troll that you are.

@Rodion, why vote for saf?

If I voted for everyone who voted me, logically or illogically, I wouldn't be a very good mafia player. I laid out my reasons why I think Nark is town. He pursued this idea that based on having similar PRs one of us must be town and the other scum. I could see a mafia or other anti-town role taking that up as evidence to support my lynch but Nark has gone after it so fervently that when I turn out to be town he would have to be lucky to survive the night just to be the main lynch target the next day. Scum will pursue cases on innocents, that's obvious but smart scum (And I do believe Nark to be smart, after all he has as many Ph Ds as I do) would not put themselves in an inescapable position to do so. So that leaves me with three possibilities:

1. Nark is town and believes the case he puts forward.
2. Nark is my lyncher and wins upon my death. Well he's certainly waited long enough to follow through on that if it was actually the case. Also wasn't he already Comm's lyncher? Wait Comm had a PR too...is Nark the PR lyncher? Does he have to get himself lynched as well? That last bit was sarcasm for those who couldn't tell.
3. Nark is a jester and hopes to get himself lynched indirectly when I turn up town. He did vote for himself but before that I didn't see much jester like behavior from him and his PR as far as I can tell is legitimate.

the first option seems the most likely to me. As people have said, fir isn't very predictable and I am not willing to say there are two people with similar PRs so one must be scum because of it.

I was thinking that it could be the mod being unpredictable, too. I would rather that one or the other's role could be investigated, preferably Strike Wolf's.

Well that ain't gonna happen during the goddamn day, so how about you focus on lynching someone and not on scummy useless posting?

40 PhDs in your mom....

[Minister Masket]

I don't know about this town doctor claim from Nark.

I feel that to get some resolution here, I should share relevant information. I am Dr. Phil (from the TV show) and I am Town Doc.

I protected TWO Night 1 (night action would be nice Nark).

However, since TWO died, I have a feeling that I am possibly Quack or CPR or however the role is called by Fir.

I believe your claim, because as discussed, there's was a busdriver lurking around, and perhaps got lucky with switching your protection away from TWO.
Nark being Strike's lyncher is an interesting theory. Hell, maybe they're each other's lynchers. Either way, my vote's staying where it is.

No real point pressuring Strike. I have a funny feeling he's some kind of doc as it is.

[iAmCaffeine]

I'd love a vote count..

[jonty125]

I like how Jonty says town doc should never vote himself right after he votes me... Guaranteed mostly scum on my bandwagon, folks!

I don't believe your town doc claim, through you voting yourself shortly after claiming.

[FloresDelMal]

Thought Dr Phil was a joke scum role in this game, but Chu used it in this one also. (...)

You know, considering DoomYoshi has supposedly an extra life now, I think we could just try to lynch him and see if Nark tells the truth. Win-win situation here!

I love win-win situations, and a cop with 40 phd's role used before gives even more reasons to give strike the benefit of the doubt
Also my paranoid burst on talapus wont take us anywhere today, he is having problems for post, and he might be a great scumster playing townier than town, or town oO so i will stop waisting my vote there (but still could be cool get him investigated tonight, better safe than sorry)

Vote Doom Yoshi (uuuhh i have a nagging feeling of deja vu )


*goes to the pub with strike and wonder if mili is old enough for drink by now

[FloresDelMal]

Thought Dr Phil was a joke scum role in this game, but Chu used it in this one also. (...)

You know, considering DoomYoshi has supposedly an extra life now, I think we could just try to lynch him and see if Nark tells the truth. Win-win situation here!

I love win-win situations, and a cop with 40 phd's role used before gives even more reasons to give strike the benefit of the doubt
Also my paranoid burst on talapus wont take us anywhere today, he is having problems for post, and he might be a great scumster playing townier than town, or town oO so i will stop waisting my vote there (but still could be cool get him investigated tonight, better safe than sorry)

Vote Doom Yoshi (uuuhh i have a nagging feeling of deja vu )


*goes to the pub with strike and wonder if masket is old enough for drink by now

ebwop this cold is getting the best of me

[DoomYoshi]

So, does anyone find anything weird about this chain of events?

TWO makes his main case against me. He is probably one of the end-of-day votes on me. (obviously I can`t verify that)
DY spends day 1 doing what he does (drawing votes mostly)

N1 nark protects dY; saf protects TWO
TWO dies, dY lives

Nark says that because TWO died, this means that DY and Neb are scummy. He then trys to lynch dY, but changes mind after a while
Claims doctor and therefore strike wolf is evil? (I still don`t follow the case exactly, i.e. I don`t see how it was better than before strike wolf posted)
saf counterclaims nark

so nark, why did you protect me? clearly scum likes me alive since they think they can score a mislynch
saf, why TWO?

Anyways, Occam`s razor gives us (assuming no busdrive and nobody is lying): saf killed TWO, mafia killed mandy , hoodlums killed ag or nag, vig killed nag or ag

I am trying to think what to make of this. unvote I still think rishaed had no reason for saying that. Why bother posting the obvious when that comment in no way advanced the conversation whatsoever?

I really don`t like how Tal has vanished. i told him already to CLEAR THE CACHE! If he filed an e-ticket KA or bb would tell him to do the same thing. It`s the very top of the Bug reports section. After his case on me fizzled, he fizzled.

ga7 and flores are doing great. I will now refer to that user as FRA.

who is this shrewstur character and why is he posting in my game?

I need more time to think. I don`t want to lynch a doc. if I can think of a scenario in which we gain an appreciable amount of information from lynching one of them that outweighs the loss of a potential mislynch, I will vote one of them. otherwise, i am still in favor of an inactive. At this point either IB or shrew.

[DoomYoshi]

I'd love a vote count..

7

[Anarkistsdream]

My 40 PhDs have taught me only one thing... DY is town... I think Minister Masket and Saf are scum buddies... read the little exchange at the top of page 70... I also still wonder about IB. I also don't believe ga7 and his flamingo PR... Great wau to make yourself look like a target... Where is Skoff? If you don't care enough or have time to participate, why join? You know how much time a 27 person Fircoal game is gonna last. Hahaha. Hurry up and finish this day, for the love of God.

[Minister Masket]

My 40 PhDs have taught me only one thing... DY is town...[1] I think Minister Masket and Saf are scum buddies... read the little exchange at the top of page 70... I also still wonder about IB. [2]I also don't believe ga7 and his flamingo PR... Great wau to make yourself look like a target... Where is Skoff? If you don't care enough or have time to participate, why join? You know how much time a 27 person Fircoal game is gonna last. Hahaha. Hurry up and finish this day, for the love of God.

1) Really? I've been casually buddying up to ga7 and Flores for all of Day 2, and yet I say I believe Saf once and you think we're scum buddies? Okaayyy then.

2) Pardon? You're saying he'd want to look like a target?

[safariguy5]

To answer your question about why TWO Doom, I protected TWO because I agreed with his assessment on the Com9 wagon. I though the cult suggestion was ridiculous and said so. TWO was one of the other people against the Com wagon as well.

I have no idea what you're talking about there nark. Honestly, accusing me because of a doc claim doesn't paint you in the best light.

[FloresDelMal]

OK guys, i haven't had my coffee yet, so i might be even less articulated than usual but here is what i got:

as i understood a doc with 40Phd's doesn't work like a traditional doc, what it does, is that it gives an extra-life to the person that targets, so in theory if we lynch DY and he was really visited by nark, he shouldn't die, he could just use up his extra life;

Then it shocks me to see anarks making less and less sense, how could a doc be certain about the alignment of DY, he claims to be townie and townies don't know anyone, and a doc that on top of his abilities could investigate at the same time that he protects could be ridiculously over powered, i have never seen a role like this, so the gig is up

if i remember well only masons, scumsters and cults could know where someone's allegiances fall without an investigation...

[ga7]

I think many needed a coffee here
As pointed out by DY, Nark started day 2 voting him, so it's not like Nark knows anything with his claimed night action.

After everything I reread and everything I could find, I really feel my vote is between Neb, JamesKer1, Exile and Doomyoshi

VOTE: DOOMYOSHI

I srsly can`t play this anymore. Either lynch me or replace me.

I'm TRYING!!!

Does the Doc with 40 Ph Ds work that way? or is it just 1 shot bulletproof? I don't remember.

The role has always been giving the person you target an extra life. For instance, if two people had targeted for a kill DY on the same night or a different night Nark targeted him, he would still die. He can survive dying once basically.

My 40 PhDs have taught me only one thing... DY is town... I think Minister Masket and Saf are scum buddies... read the little exchange at the top of page 70... I also still wonder about IB. I also don't believe ga7 and his flamingo PR... Great wau to make yourself look like a target... Where is Skoff? If you don't care enough or have time to participate, why join? You know how much time a 27 person Fircoal game is gonna last. Hahaha. Hurry up and finish this day, for the love of God.

Making myself look like a target because of flamingos? I don't think a role dishing out PRs is automatically scum so I don't see your point there.

What I question the most in all this flipflopping is you of all people not willing to try the one way to prove your role without putting any claimed doc at risk. I understand most people being unfamiliar with doc with 40 phds, I had to dig up the games to make sure it was working like this in all the games which used this role. But if it's your freaking role you should be familiar with its mechanics, no?

[Anarkistsdream]

Nope... None of that was mentioned in the role

[ga7]

Urgh... Fucking chu, now who knows if the role is the same or he changed it... Blah, I guess I'll keep my vote on Strike and go for some pilsner goodness

[FloresDelMal]

Nope... None of that was mentioned in the role

unvote vote shadow so we can get a claim