................................

[Jamie]

......................................

[Dlakavi]

I have an idea for the clan name:

"The feedback fishers"

What do you think?

[Jamie]

................................................

[Dlakavi]

Positive Whipped my butt, very good player 180418 Nephilim ( 46-5 )
2007-01-18 00:57:39
Positive Whipped our butts, very good player. 172499 grimsby reaper ( 14-0 )
2007-01-17 22:11:42
Positive Whipped our butts, very good player. 172499 forbert ( 35-3 )
2007-01-17 22:11:07
Positive Whipped our butts, very good player. 157505 Mepps ( 14-0 )
2007-01-17 22:10:22
Positive Whipped our butts, very good player. 157505 Lone.prophet ( 26-1 )
2007-01-17 22:09:57
Positive Whipped our butts, very good player. 157505 freyme ( 33-0 )
2007-01-17 22:09:21
Positive Whipped my butt, very good player 164119 lilwdlnddude ( 22-1 )
2007-01-16 14:45:13
Positive Whipped our butts, very good player. 163437 nickfoxx ( 8-0 )
2007-01-15 23:36:54
Positive Whipped our butts, very good player. 163437 casper ( 11-0 )
2007-01-15 23:36:33
Positive Whipped my butt, very good player 149795 buelldart ( 4-0 )
2007-01-15 17:17:42
Positive Whipped my butt, very good player 163430 Marvaddin ( 28-1 )
2007-01-15 16:22:00
Positive Whipped our butts, very good player. 163400 Evil Semp ( 42-1 )
2007-01-15 03:10:54
Positive Whipped our butts, very good player.



The list goes on and on and on...

If this is not fishing for feedbacks i don't know what is.

Don't get me wrong, i think too few people leave feedback after a game, and i don't care if someone fishes for feedback, but i think it is unfair that johnnyrocket gets all his positives deleted and you dont.

And clearly the reason for you leaving people feedback is only to get feedback in return.
Unlike AAFitz or Fireside Poet who take the time and write a nice descriptive feedback you just copy and paste them over and over

[Jamie]

I believe when someone beats you, they deserve acknowledgement. Many of the players I leave feedback for, don't leave one back. I don't complain about it, nor do I expect it. If a partner helps me win, I believe he/she deserves acknowledgement. I often do not get one back. I don't delete a positive if I don't get one in return. I also copy and paste alot of negatives. I believe if you deadbeat, you get a negative. Every single person on this site who has 100 positives or more leaves alot of feedback. If they didn't they wouldn't have that many positives. I don't do it to get a positve in return. I do it because I was either beaten, or got alot of help in a doubles game. If I lost because the dice killed me, I don't leave a feedback. A game I just finished is agood example. jeffbroomhead won the game, but I did not leave hom a positive, because he didn't really beat me. I deployed 45 men to take out 23, which would have got me a big set to take jeffbroomhead out, but I was unable to get the last two men of the 23 due to horrific luck with the dice. He did not win fair, and doesn't deserve a positive, so I didn't leave him one. I don't leave my P a positive either if he didn't help me win, even if we do win. If I did all the work, they don't get crap. Every positive i leave is deserved, and I don't give a crap if they leave one back or not.


JOHNNYROCKET24 has 107 positives. I doubt he has many, if any deleted. Deleting positives would be pointless.

[JOHNNYROCKET24]

i do have positives deleted. i was lazy and copied and pasted the same message which i guess was not permitted. There was actually alot more that are not listed because I told Lack I would delete them since he felt they were unappropiate. I played well over 1700 games and its very rare that I leave any feedback unless I felt someone went out of their way and demonstrated either good or poor decisions during the game. To be honest with you, the only reason I have so many feedbacks is probably because I played the most different players on this site. Alot more oppertunities for someone to remark on my games. Unfortunately, alot of players abuse the system and I have to have many removed by the admins..... like the most recent negative remark. That player left a feedback last week that was removed by the admin. now a week later he added another one when we dint even play a game together and I have him added to my ignore list.

[Vader_09]

just so u know, lack made it where u cnt make new clans for a while, enless he changed it today.

[clapper011]

just so u know, lack made it where u cnt make new clans for a while, enless he changed it today.

i would join but vadar is right lack said no more for awhile....

[what,me worry?]

I have to agree with everyone on this one. The requirement for 100 pos feedbacks invites most fishers not to say that people who have 100+ fish for them, but theres a good chance that some are bs.And just because someone beats you doesnt mean an automatic feedback either. I only leave feedback for good team mates who increased my game play or for people who are underrated on their score.

[Jamie]

I have to agree with everyone on this one. The requirement for 100 pos feedbacks invites most fishers not to say that people who have 100+ fish for them, but theres a good chance that some are bs.And just because someone beats you doesnt mean an automatic feedback either. I only leave feedback for good team mates who increased my game play or for people who are underrated on their score.

I don't leave feedback for everyone that beats me. I made that clear in my last post on this subject. If THEY beat me, they get a positive. If the dice beat me, they get nothing. I am a very good risk player, and don't get beat that often, so ifeel when someone outplays me, and wins, they get feedback. I also leave feedback if I get great luck to beat someone else that should have won. I left feedback for you in a game that took us only 3 rounds to win. You helped me absolutely destroy our opponents, and you deserved it.