[CLX] Clan League 10 - Main Thread - Completed May 17

[Lindax]

S&M are in thanks
1st contact and privs swifte
2nd contact MTIceman41

Seventeenth clan in.

Lx

[davekettering]

Of the clans remaining, is there any possibility of getting at least 1 more clan to even up at 18 or 3 more to go with 20. These would be most beneficial for setting up a good war plan.

Last day is today!!!

Dave

[Keefie]

I think the only two clans left who may join are FALL and LOW.

[IcePack]

the Fallen / FALL
First Contact: IcePack
Second Contact: N/A
Request Privileges for both Contacts: N/A

[Lindax]

the Fallen / FALL
First Contact: IcePack
Second Contact: N/A
Request Privileges for both Contacts: N/A

Eighteenth clan in.

Lx

[chard]

Legends Of War
First Contact: chard
Second Contact: N/A
Request Privileges for both Contacts: N/A

[ViperOverLord]

Manifest Destiny will join for this season.

First contact: ViperOverLord
Second contact: Aung Oakkar

Privileges Requested for both.

[benga]

Manifest Destiny will join for this season.

First contact: ViperOverLord
Second contact: Aung Oakkar

Privileges Requested for both.

Do you guys even have the 10 active players?

[Lindax]

Legends Of War
First Contact: chard
Second Contact: N/A
Request Privileges for both Contacts: N/A

Manifest Destiny will join for this season.

First contact: ViperOverLord
Second contact: Aung Oakkar

Privileges Requested for both.

Both in, that makes 20 clans.

Sign-up is now closed. I will post the divisions as soon as I have them.

Thanks,

Lx

[Lindax]

Ok guys, here are the 2 divisions, based on the rules posted in the 3 post of this thread:

Premier Division:

FOED
S&M
TOFU
FALL
TOP
OSA
LOW
SOH -p
ATL - p
AFOS - p

Second Division:

VNM - r
GON - r
FSC
BOB
A^
LHDD
RET
RGV
DBD
MD

----

Lx

[Lindax]

I know you're all waiting for them and I'm working on them. I will post the schedules tomorrow....

Lx

[shoop76]

Can you please make caymanmew the 2nd contact for Atlantis and remove me.
He will also need privileges. Thanks.

[Lindax]

Can you please make caymanmew the 2nd contact for Atlantis and remove me.
He will also need privileges. Thanks.

Done.

Lx

[davekettering]

Reminder..... CLX, the war of all wars starts this coming Sunday, October 14.

Good luck to all teams.

Dave

[uckuki]

hfa
go foed

[InnyaFacce]

WOW First Week Of CLX - Extentions Already Required ... Infractions Handed Out
Does Not Look Good To Start This Tourney
Wonder If The Clan World Should Be Worried

Mike22 is listed as a member for the Band of Brothers clan not Manifest Destiny
Should Band of Brothers get this Infraction instead of Manifest destiny ?
R1 - MD vs VNM: MD breaking 1 clan rule with player Mike22. Warning for Mike22. Reminder for MD.

I understand the rule :
A player who played for one clan in CL10, cannot play for another clan in CL10
But, CLX has not even started yet - so how can there be an Infraction ?

show: Extensions + Infractions

[rockfist]

There are typically more infractions and extensions in the first few rounds than in subsequent rounds.

[IcePack]

WOW First Week Of CLX - Extentions Already Required
Does Not Look Good To Start This Tourney
Wonder If The Clan World Should Be Worried

[spoiler=Extensions + Infractions]Premier Division
Extentions
R1 - SOH home games: 48hrs.
R1 - FALL home games: 24hrs.

I don’t think there’s any reason to worry, there was only two extensions and one infraction / warning for late games. I don’t know what SOH reason for it was but I was sick all week. Just sort of snuck up on me trying to survive life. I think we all run into that from time to time.

There are typically more infractions and extensions in the first few rounds than in subsequent rounds.

I haven’t looked but I wouldn’t be surprised. Once it gets going it’s easier to get into the flow of the event and not be surprised / caught unprepared at the beginning when planning occurs.

[Lindax]

WOW First Week Of CLX - Extentions Already Required ... Infractions Handed Out
Does Not Look Good To Start This Tourney
Wonder If The Clan World Should Be Worried

Mike22 is listed as a member for the Band of Brothers clan not Manifest Destiny
Should Band of Brothers get this Infraction instead of Manifest destiny ?
R1 - MD vs VNM: MD breaking 1 clan rule with player Mike22. Warning for Mike22. Reminder for MD.

I understand the rule :
A player who played for one clan in CL10, cannot play for another clan in CL10
But, CLX has not even started yet - so how can there be an Infraction ?

show: Extensions + Infractions

CLX started October 14. At the time of the infraction he was registered with both clans. He was also in games with BOB and had joined 2 games with MD.

After my PM the situation got resolved quickly and you would not have noticed the infraction.

I hope this clears it up for you,

Lx

[Lindax]

There are typically more infractions and extensions in the first few rounds than in subsequent rounds.

This is absolutely true in my experience.

Lx

[InnyaFacce]

This does not clear up anything

My interruption of the Rule - correct me if I am wrong
A player who played for one clan in CL10, cannot play for another clan in CL10
If Mike22 had played a game in CLX for Manifest Destiny
Would not be eligible to play in any CLX games for Band of Brothers or any other Clan for the remainder of CLX
This would be an infraction according to the Rules as shown in the CLX Main Thread

I do not see how games that are not CLX related as playing for 2 Clans during CLX
If there is an infraction for games that are not involved with CLX
This RULE needs to be changed to include every scenario that would constitute an Infraction
Once again My interruption of the Rule - there has been no infraction from either Clan

Active War, Retribution vs Band of Brothers - Sept 2018. Started 2018-10-18 Ended 2018-10-19. Played over 2 Rounds.
Mike22 is active in games for Band of Brothers
Complete War, RL7 - Rd15 - MD vs FOED. Started 2017-06-18 Ended 2017-07-27. Played over 1 Rounds.
This is the last Active Clan War that Manifest Destiny was involved in [ Mike22 - was not active in any games ]
So where / how exactly did this infraction occur ?

CLX started October 14. At the time of the infraction he was registered with both clans. He was also in games with BOB and had joined 2 games with MD.

After my PM the situation got resolved quickly and you would not have noticed the infraction.

I hope this clears it up for you,

Lx

WOW First Week Of CLX - Extentions Already Required ... Infractions Handed Out
Does Not Look Good To Start This Tourney
Wonder If The Clan World Should Be Worried

Mike22 is listed as a member for the Band of Brothers clan not Manifest Destiny
Should Band of Brothers get this Infraction instead of Manifest destiny ?
R1 - MD vs VNM: MD breaking 1 clan rule with player Mike22. Warning for Mike22. Reminder for MD.

I understand the rule :
A player who played for one clan in CL10, cannot play for another clan in CL10
But, CLX has not even started yet - so how can there be an Infraction ?

[rockfist]

It’s really quite simple. There are clan rules that apply at all times and there are clan league rules that apply only to clan league. The one clan rule applies at all times. Think of it like federal law applies no matter what state you are in, but a state law of Michigan does not apply in Ohio. Federal law would apply in both Michigan and Ohio.

[InnyaFacce]

It’s really quite simple. There are clan rules that apply at all times and there are clan league rules that apply only to clan league. The one clan rule applies at all times. Think of it like federal law applies no matter what state you are in, but a state law of Michigan does not apply in Ohio. Federal law would apply in both Michigan and Ohio.

I know the differences between State Laws and Federal Laws - my wife is a Lawyer
You did not give any proof to any infraction that has occured

[JPlo64]

It’s really quite simple. There are clan rules that apply at all times and there are clan league rules that apply only to clan league. The one clan rule applies at all times. Think of it like federal law applies no matter what state you are in, but a state law of Michigan does not apply in Ohio. Federal law would apply in both Michigan and Ohio.

I know the differences between State Laws and Federal Laws - my wife is a Lawyer
You did not give any proof to any infraction that has occured

This is stated in the Rules for CLX (see Rules spoiler of first post of this thread):

All the CC and Clan rules will be in effect, unless stated otherwise in this post.

The 1 Clan rule is a general Clan Department Rule.
It is repeatedly referenced throughout here: Clan Guidelines

The 1 clan rule was violated.
The 1 can rule is a general clan rule.
The rules for CLX implies that the general clan rules are in effect.
Thus, a CLX violation occurred.