eddie2 wrote:make that infrindgement 6..
nmic coyboyz was online earlier signing up to games and playing shots. game was jamaica.
http://www.conquerclub.com/game.php?game=12837487lol you just got a warning for it. in the das scholls game then do it again
Lets look at these infringements.
eddie2 wrote:.
so 5 times they have broke event rules or clan rules and still no forfeits of games this is a joke.
eddie2 wrote:1)home game sign up round 1 (kort players delaying signing up to get advantage of screen shot)
No violation here. There were no rules for this You should not have joined the games so quickly. If Kort did do this then it is only because you gave them the opportunity to. No one to blame but yourself here, you had 5 days to join Korts home games. No one forced you to join the games straight away. It is worth noting that you did not exchange AKAs home games until the 27th not the 26th as Kort did, and you sent your games with only invites not fully joined. Kort also exchanged their games invited but on the correct date.
eddie2 wrote:2) signing up to away games 2 days late.
We never actually made it to two full days. After the Cds were informed Kort joined the games within 24 hours as requested. Enforcing the rules as written no violation occurred. Most games started a matter of hours late, a few started up to a day and a half late.
eddie2 wrote:3)sitting abuse in the poland game (because no fog rule.)
There were 18 hours from the last turn taken by the player, this is legal in terms of Clan sitting rules, and emergency cover
eddie2 wrote:4)signing up late to kort home games round 2.
One invite expired, One game game started 12 hours late at the very most as far as i am aware. This is a very trivial matter. This is not abusive, this has not given Kort an advantage and has not caused a delay to the competition.
eddie2 wrote:5)sitting abuse in the das game.
cowboyz has yet to come online and be able to defend himself until he does this will not be finalised. The evidence has been considered and it has been determined by the multi hunters and the Cds that this turn was not covered for the intent of gaining a strategical advantage, and no benefit was gained.
eddie2 wrote:make that infrindgement 6..
nmic coyboyz was online earlier signing up to games and playing shots. game was jamaica.
As far as Clan sitting rules go, this has been cleared and noted. There were 15 hours at least in between turns and this falls under emergency sitting guidelines. Unless other evidence is provided by the multi hunters it is closed.
Now that just leaves 2 from 6. One is extremely trivial, and one didn't actually provide Kort with any advantage and wasn't deemed abusive as such. It had no impact on this tie whatsoever.
Let us categorically state every clan will be treated the same regardless of who they are or where they are ranked.
There have been many minor delays in many ties, and these have been far worse in comparison to the ones KORT have caused, nobody has received a punishment. When we add it all up I believe its 4 games delayed between 3 and 36 hours. Over the entire tie. This is irrelevant in the grand scheme of things.
By your own admission you have purposely and actively sort every opportunity you could to beat Kort "off the field" This list is just a snippet of what you have actually accused them of and have been subsequently been disproved. This has to be one of the worst displays of poor sportsmanship we have ever witnessed. You have drained the CD resources in regards to work hours, leaving us little time to do anything else or get any of our regular duties completed. For me personally i have had to give up at least 10 hours above and beyond what i normally put in dealing with your spurious reports.
You have misinterpreted our rules to try and gain an advantage and screamed abuse when we haven't let you. You expect us somehow use our rules by your deliberate misinterpretation to punish Kort when we have not punished anyone else for worse time delays. Why on earth would we do that, it's the fairness that needs to happen
Just to clarify we want this comp to run to time. We want everyone to try their very best not to be late otherwise we will be even later starting next year. Our rules are there to prevent the significant delays like the ones we had involving Dynasty last year. That incident was the only time a punishment had become necessary but even then it was resolved amiably. We have these rules to prevent these significant delays. Enforcing them after a few hours or a day is not appropriate. As stated we will be a little lenient because we understand that this is a game and real life has a habit of getting in the way of everyone's best intentions.
We want a fair tournament without abuse. And that is what our rules are for. Minor time delays and especially the ones caused by KORT are utterly insignificant. A day or two is perfectly permissible as part of the leniency we try to uphold for every clan. Forfeits & punishments should always remain a last resort if there's willful disregard for the rules. As with any clan war everything needs to be done to resolve matters amicably and not chase penalties because it obviously shows bad faith in playing the war in a good spirit. Kort are not without fault but 99% of the issues have been extremely trivial that should have been resolved without CD input in an amicable manner.
The Cd team
