MarshalNey wrote:...
P.S. I didn't give a rationale for my suggestions for raising or lowering the bonuses (other than Rail D), but if one compares the values between like rails, most of them are self-explanatory. Rail M is too good of a deal for +2... I think that a bonus should not be both easy and more efficient than larger bonuses; rather a small bonus should be a tradeoff (easier to take and hold, but less efficient). Otherwise it dominates the strategy disproportionately.
My side of the coin for Rail M being +2 is that it still have two borders to defend therefore if the player who gets that railway is to defend it, they need one each side to continue to hold it, the same with Indonesia and Japan, and it backs onto that large Southern Chinese Rail.
After digesting these figures, I have the following recommendations:
Rail M bonus lowered from +2 to +1
I'd like to keep the +2
Not sure what you mean with the "and one extra border added" - do you want another border added in order to justify the bonus?
Rail G bonus raised from +2 to +3, and one extra border added
Now Rail I Arabian - Done
Rail J bonus raised from +3 to +4 and one extra border added
Now Rail L Indian - Done
Rail H bonus raised from +3 to +4
Now Rail J Iranian - Done
Rail K bonus raised from +4 to +5
Now Rail M SE Asia - Done
The second thing that I would do with the neutrals is to get rid of the neutral on Rail H. It's not needed... if it turns out that you need the neutral for your total region count to be a golden number, move it to Rail L.
I don't think there are any need for neutrals now
Finally, as mentioned earlier the total number of deployable regions for this map (73 regions) is a non-golden (one might say black) number. Some adjustments need to be made to either increase or decrease it to a golden number.
-- Marshal Ney
Golden number should now be 80, i hope.
Version 12
Beijing D will have to be noted as D1 and D2...not put in yet, but will adjust.
Confirmed in the xml there is now 80 regions.
Version 12
- Click image to enlarge.
![image](http://i155.photobucket.com/albums/s282/cairnswk/RAIL%20ASIA/_rail_asia_V12S.jpg)