Conquer Club

Accused:
magoo15
capn nick

The accused are suspected of:
Other:
Both accounts being owned by one person

Game number(s):
4872480
4840822
4680548
4672936
4614279

Comments:
The following are extracted from 4872480 game log. Note how the two players manage to start their turns within seconds of each other. This becomes even more suspect when both players miss the same turn as each other!
Upon investigation the same appears to happen in other game numbers as highlighted above.

2009-05-14 20:35:03 - magoo15 receives 5 troops for 16 regions
2009-05-14 20:35:26 - capn nick receives 5 troops for 16 regions

2009-05-15 01:38:00 - magoo15 receives 5 troops for 16 regions
2009-05-15 01:38:05 - capn nick receives 5 troops for 16 regions

2009-05-15 21:31:08 - magoo15 receives 2 troops for holding ?
2009-05-15 21:31:34 - capn nick receives 5 troops for 16 regions

2009-05-17 09:02:12 - capn nick receives 4 troops for 14 regions
2009-05-17 09:02:13 - magoo15 receives 2 troops for holding ?

2009-05-18 18:34:29 - capn nick missed a turn
2009-05-18 18:34:29 - magoo15 missed a turn

Accused:
magoo15
capn nick

The accused are suspected of:
Other:
Both accounts being owned by one person (multi)

Game number(s):
Game 4872480
Game 4840822
Game 4680548
Game 4672936
Game 4614279

Comments:
The following are extracted from 4872480 game log. Note how the two players manage to start their turns within seconds of each other. This becomes even more suspect when both players miss the same turn as each other!
Upon investigation the same appears to happen in other game numbers as highlighted above.

2009-05-14 20:35:03 - magoo15 receives 5 troops for 16 regions
2009-05-14 20:35:26 - capn nick receives 5 troops for 16 regions

2009-05-15 01:38:00 - magoo15 receives 5 troops for 16 regions
2009-05-15 01:38:05 - capn nick receives 5 troops for 16 regions

2009-05-15 21:31:08 - magoo15 receives 2 troops for holding ?
2009-05-15 21:31:34 - capn nick receives 5 troops for 16 regions

2009-05-17 09:02:12 - capn nick receives 4 troops for 14 regions
2009-05-17 09:02:13 - magoo15 receives 2 troops for holding ?
comment: they take turning within a second of each other,this would probally make an ip check pointless because if this is a multi, he/she has mutiplecomputers so could easily use two ip addresses.

2009-05-18 18:34:29 - capn nick missed a turn
2009-05-18 18:34:29 - magoo15 missed a turn

46 games together. 39 as doubles. only 7 games together against each other. in 7 games magoo15 wins won and capn nick wins won. thats still only a 28.6% win. this is lower than both of their average wins.

i don't think this could be a case of multi, maybe neibours or brother/sisters or something. but if they are multi's they doing pritty bad.
it seems clear their play may have favoured each other due to highest ranks in game.and if you lose to a high rank you lose less point.


hope this helps, added links riodeisher

magoo15 and capn nick are Cleared of being multis with one another.

Thankyou lancehoch for investigating and clearing up my suspision.

I am happy that my suspision has been proved wrong.