Page 1 of 1

suspicious - airforceking2 and ronnyr game 4402113 [Cleared]

PostPosted: Thu Mar 12, 2009 5:39 am
by wez_mantooth
Accused:

airforceking2
ronnyr




The accused are suspected of:

Conducting Secret Diplomacy
possible multi accounting



Game number(s):

Game 4402113



Comments:
map= WW2 australasia

the position of 22 units by airforceking2 at Tiwi island, should have triggered a defensive position or attempt at defence by ronnyr at darwin. however for the past 2 turns, airforceking2 has attacked elsewhere (see below) and ronnyr has alos attacked elsewhere ( in the opposite direction to the 22 stationed men Twice! .) and niether side has chosen to attack each other, only me.

airforceking2's attack ( ternati to IJN shoho (strategically illogical as lone player)) took my units away from my front line with ronnyr (karumba), my counter attack ( karumba to ternati ) meant ronnyr was then able to attack ( birdrum - USS lexington via karumba ) this strategic move appears co-ordinated and planned, thus secret diplomacy must have taken place or this person is multi accounting.

see below for copy/paste of game log.

2009-03-06 05:30:37 - Game has been initialized
2009-03-06 08:18:58 - airforceking2 receives 7 troops for 22 regions
2009-03-06 08:19:36 - airforceking2 deployed 4 troops on Mareeba
2009-03-06 08:19:41 - airforceking2 deployed 3 troops on Cooktown
2009-03-06 08:19:48 - airforceking2 assaulted Bamaga from Cooktown and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-06 08:20:09 - airforceking2 assaulted Cairns from Mareeba and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-06 08:20:16 - airforceking2 assaulted Townsville from Cairns and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-06 08:20:36 - airforceking2 reinforced Karumba with 2 troops from Cooktown
2009-03-06 08:20:36 - airforceking2 gets spoils
2009-03-06 08:40:19 - wez_mantooth receives 6 troops for 20 regions
2009-03-06 08:40:42 - wez_mantooth deployed 6 troops on Destroyer Sims
2009-03-06 08:40:46 - wez_mantooth assaulted USS Lexington from Destroyer Sims and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-06 08:40:55 - wez_mantooth assaulted Cairns from USS Lexington and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-06 08:41:03 - wez_mantooth assaulted Mareeba from Cairns and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-06 08:41:05 - wez_mantooth assaulted Cooktown from Mareeba and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-06 08:41:26 - wez_mantooth assaulted Bamaga from Cooktown and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-06 08:41:43 - wez_mantooth reinforced USS Yorktown with 2 troops from RAN Hobart
2009-03-06 08:41:43 - wez_mantooth gets spoils
2009-03-06 08:45:31 - ronnyr receives 7 troops for 21 regions
2009-03-06 08:46:14 - ronnyr deployed 7 troops on Nhullunby
2009-03-06 08:46:21 - ronnyr assaulted Mullingimbi from Nhullunby and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-06 08:47:13 - ronnyr reinforced Birdum with 2 troops from Broome
2009-03-06 08:47:13 - ronnyr gets spoils
2009-03-06 08:47:13 - Incrementing game to round 2
2009-03-06 16:50:36 - airforceking2 receives 6 troops for 19 regions
2009-03-06 16:50:44 - airforceking2 deployed 6 troops on Karumba
2009-03-06 16:50:48 - airforceking2 assaulted Mareeba from Karumba and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-06 16:50:54 - airforceking2 assaulted Cooktown from Mareeba and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-06 16:51:05 - airforceking2 assaulted Bamaga from Cooktown and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-06 16:51:17 - airforceking2 reinforced Mareeba with 2 troops from Bamaga
2009-03-06 16:51:17 - airforceking2 gets spoils
2009-03-06 16:56:53 - wez_mantooth receives 2 troops for holding Allied Navy
2009-03-06 16:56:53 - wez_mantooth receives 7 troops for 22 regions
2009-03-06 16:57:19 - wez_mantooth deployed 9 troops on Horn Island
2009-03-06 16:57:21 - wez_mantooth assaulted Bamaga from Horn Island and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-06 16:57:33 - wez_mantooth assaulted Cooktown from Bamaga and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-06 16:57:37 - wez_mantooth assaulted Mareeba from Cooktown and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-06 16:57:42 - wez_mantooth assaulted Townsville from Mareeba and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-06 16:57:47 - wez_mantooth assaulted Karumba from Townsville and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-06 16:58:02 - wez_mantooth reinforced Bamaga with 4 troops from USS Yorktown
2009-03-06 16:58:02 - wez_mantooth gets spoils
2009-03-06 19:43:40 - ronnyr receives 7 troops for 22 regions
2009-03-06 19:43:48 - ronnyr deployed 7 troops on Birdum
2009-03-06 19:43:51 - ronnyr assaulted Karumba from Birdum and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-06 19:43:59 - ronnyr assaulted Pine Creek from Birdum and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-06 19:44:27 - ronnyr reinforced Wyndham with 2 troops from Derby
2009-03-06 19:44:27 - ronnyr gets spoils
2009-03-06 19:44:27 - Incrementing game to round 3
2009-03-06 20:29:12 - airforceking2 receives 5 troops for 17 regions
2009-03-06 20:29:37 - airforceking2 deployed 5 troops on Molucca
2009-03-06 20:29:42 - airforceking2 assaulted Flores from Molucca and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-06 20:29:54 - airforceking2 assaulted Kendari from Molucca and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-06 20:30:01 - airforceking2 gets spoils
2009-03-07 05:14:08 - wez_mantooth receives 2 troops for holding Allied Navy
2009-03-07 05:14:08 - wez_mantooth receives 8 troops for 25 regions
2009-03-07 05:15:02 - wez_mantooth deployed 10 troops on Townsville
2009-03-07 05:15:06 - wez_mantooth assaulted Karumba from Townsville and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-07 05:15:50 - wez_mantooth reinforced Fly River with 2 troops from Goroka
2009-03-07 05:15:50 - wez_mantooth gets spoils
2009-03-07 14:37:10 - ronnyr receives 7 troops for 21 regions
2009-03-07 14:37:44 - ronnyr deployed 7 troops on Birdum
2009-03-07 14:37:48 - ronnyr assaulted Karumba from Birdum and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-07 14:39:08 - ronnyr reinforced Birdum with 2 troops from Wyndham
2009-03-07 14:39:08 - ronnyr gets spoils
2009-03-07 14:39:08 - Incrementing game to round 4
2009-03-07 18:40:16 - airforceking2 receives 6 troops for 19 regions
2009-03-07 18:40:24 - airforceking2 deployed 6 troops on Kendari
2009-03-07 18:40:28 - airforceking2 assaulted Celebes from Kendari and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-07 18:40:36 - airforceking2 gets spoils
2009-03-08 04:18:07 - wez_mantooth receives 2 troops for holding Allied Navy
2009-03-08 04:18:07 - wez_mantooth receives 8 troops for 24 regions
2009-03-08 04:18:29 - wez_mantooth deployed 10 troops on Fly River
2009-03-08 04:18:38 - wez_mantooth assaulted Lae from Fly River and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-08 04:19:50 - wez_mantooth gets spoils
2009-03-08 05:35:56 - ronnyr receives 7 troops for 21 regions
2009-03-08 05:37:09 - ronnyr deployed 2 troops on Wyndham
2009-03-08 05:37:17 - ronnyr deployed 2 troops on Darwin
2009-03-08 05:37:26 - ronnyr deployed 3 troops on Karumba
2009-03-08 05:37:38 - ronnyr assaulted Townsville from Karumba and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-08 05:39:12 - ronnyr reinforced Wyndham with 3 troops from Nhullunby
2009-03-08 05:39:12 - ronnyr gets spoils
2009-03-08 05:39:12 - Incrementing game to round 5
2009-03-08 19:43:41 - airforceking2 receives 3 troops for holding East Indies
2009-03-08 19:43:41 - airforceking2 receives 6 troops for 20 regions
2009-03-08 19:43:52 - airforceking2 cashed in a group of Nhullunby, Kavieng, and Broome worth 4 troops
2009-03-08 19:44:10 - airforceking2 deployed 13 troops on Truk
2009-03-08 19:44:24 - airforceking2 assaulted Ternati from Truk and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-08 19:44:34 - airforceking2 assaulted Ambon from Ternati and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-08 19:44:49 - airforceking2 assaulted Tanimbar from Ambon and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-08 19:44:59 - airforceking2 assaulted IJN Kaga from Tanimbar and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-08 19:45:03 - airforceking2 gets spoils
2009-03-09 05:30:35 - wez_mantooth receives 2 troops for holding Allied Navy
2009-03-09 05:30:35 - wez_mantooth receives 7 troops for 21 regions
2009-03-09 05:30:40 - wez_mantooth cashed in a group of Greenwich Island, Darwin, and Ternati worth 6 troops
2009-03-09 05:31:37 - wez_mantooth deployed 5 troops on Goroka
2009-03-09 05:31:47 - wez_mantooth deployed 10 troops on Kokoda
2009-03-09 05:31:54 - wez_mantooth assaulted Port Moresby from Kokoda and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-09 05:32:01 - wez_mantooth assaulted Milne Bay from Port Moresby and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-09 05:34:01 - wez_mantooth reinforced Mareeba with 5 troops from Goroka
2009-03-09 05:34:01 - wez_mantooth gets spoils
2009-03-09 05:54:53 - ronnyr receives 6 troops for 20 regions
2009-03-09 05:55:52 - ronnyr deployed 6 troops on Darwin
2009-03-09 05:56:03 - ronnyr assaulted Tiwi Islands from Darwin and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-09 05:56:12 - ronnyr assaulted IJN Kaga from Tiwi Islands and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-09 05:56:40 - ronnyr reinforced Tiwi Islands with 2 troops from Wyndham
2009-03-09 05:56:40 - ronnyr gets spoils
2009-03-09 05:56:40 - Incrementing game to round 6
2009-03-09 18:20:03 - airforceking2 receives 3 troops for holding East Indies
2009-03-09 18:20:03 - airforceking2 receives 7 troops for 21 regions
2009-03-09 18:20:15 - airforceking2 deployed 10 troops on Tanimbar
2009-03-09 18:20:19 - airforceking2 assaulted IJN Kaga from Tanimbar and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-09 18:20:34 - airforceking2 assaulted Tiwi Islands from IJN Kaga and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-09 18:20:38 - airforceking2 gets spoils
2009-03-10 03:38:21 - wez_mantooth receives 4 troops for holding Papua
2009-03-10 03:38:21 - wez_mantooth receives 2 troops for holding Allied Navy
2009-03-10 03:38:21 - wez_mantooth receives 7 troops for 23 regions
2009-03-10 03:38:50 - wez_mantooth deployed 13 troops on San Cristobal
2009-03-10 03:38:56 - wez_mantooth assaulted Guadalcanal from San Cristobal and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-10 03:39:07 - wez_mantooth assaulted Tulagi from Guadalcanal and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-10 03:39:20 - wez_mantooth assaulted Malaita from Tulagi and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-10 03:40:04 - wez_mantooth assaulted Townsville from Mareeba and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-10 03:40:31 - wez_mantooth reinforced Isabel with 8 troops from Malaita
2009-03-10 03:40:31 - wez_mantooth gets spoils
2009-03-10 03:59:18 - ronnyr receives 5 troops for 17 regions
2009-03-10 03:59:25 - ronnyr cashed in a group of Horn Island, Kupang, and New Hollandia worth 8 troops
2009-03-10 03:59:57 - ronnyr deployed 2 troops on Karumba
2009-03-10 04:00:05 - ronnyr deployed 11 troops on Darwin
2009-03-10 04:00:14 - ronnyr assaulted Tiwi Islands from Darwin and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-10 04:00:20 - ronnyr assaulted IJN Kaga from Tiwi Islands and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-10 04:00:53 - ronnyr reinforced Tiwi Islands with 3 troops from Birdum
2009-03-10 04:00:53 - ronnyr gets spoils
2009-03-10 04:00:53 - Incrementing game to round 7
2009-03-10 07:05:21 - airforceking2 receives 3 troops for holding East Indies
2009-03-10 07:05:21 - airforceking2 receives 6 troops for 20 regions
2009-03-10 07:05:28 - airforceking2 cashed in a group of Madang, Nhullunby, and Wadke worth 10 troops
2009-03-10 07:05:28 - airforceking2 gets bonus of 2 troops added to Madang
2009-03-10 07:05:32 - airforceking2 deployed 19 troops on Tanimbar
2009-03-10 07:05:42 - airforceking2 assaulted IJN Kaga from Tanimbar and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-10 07:05:49 - airforceking2 gets spoils
2009-03-10 07:06:53 - wez_mantooth receives 4 troops for holding Papua
2009-03-10 07:06:53 - wez_mantooth receives 2 troops for holding Allied Navy
2009-03-10 07:06:53 - wez_mantooth receives 9 troops for 27 regions
2009-03-10 07:07:11 - wez_mantooth deployed 10 troops on Mareeba
2009-03-10 07:07:27 - wez_mantooth deployed 5 troops on Aitape
2009-03-10 07:07:46 - wez_mantooth assaulted Karumba from Mareeba and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-10 07:08:26 - wez_mantooth assaulted Choisuel from Isabel and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-10 07:09:13 - wez_mantooth reinforced Choisuel with 3 troops from Milne Bay
2009-03-10 07:09:13 - wez_mantooth gets spoils
2009-03-10 08:29:17 - ronnyr receives 5 troops for holding West Australia
2009-03-10 08:29:17 - ronnyr receives 5 troops for 16 regions
2009-03-10 08:29:55 - ronnyr deployed 10 troops on Birdum
2009-03-10 08:31:03 - ronnyr assaulted Truk from Greenwich Island and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-10 08:31:45 - ronnyr reinforced Birdum with 2 troops from Wyndham
2009-03-10 08:31:45 - ronnyr gets spoils
2009-03-10 08:31:45 - Incrementing game to round 8
2009-03-10 17:35:12 - airforceking2 receives 3 troops for holding East Indies
2009-03-10 17:35:12 - airforceking2 receives 6 troops for 20 regions
2009-03-10 17:35:25 - airforceking2 deployed 9 troops on IJN Shokaku
2009-03-10 17:35:41 - airforceking2 assaulted Truk from IJN Shokaku and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-10 17:35:55 - airforceking2 assaulted Greenwich Island from Truk and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-10 17:36:04 - airforceking2 assaulted Kavieng from Greenwich Island and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-10 17:36:19 - airforceking2 assaulted Rabaul from Arawera and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-10 17:36:46 - airforceking2 reinforced IJN Shokaku with 4 troops from Kavieng
2009-03-10 17:36:46 - airforceking2 gets spoils
2009-03-10 17:48:17 - wez_mantooth receives 4 troops for holding Papua
2009-03-10 17:48:17 - wez_mantooth receives 5 troops for holding East Australia
2009-03-10 17:48:17 - wez_mantooth receives 2 troops for holding Allied Navy
2009-03-10 17:48:17 - wez_mantooth receives 9 troops for 28 regions
2009-03-10 17:49:06 - wez_mantooth deployed 10 troops on Choisuel
2009-03-10 17:49:16 - wez_mantooth deployed 5 troops on Karumba
2009-03-10 17:49:22 - wez_mantooth deployed 5 troops on Bamaga
2009-03-10 17:49:33 - wez_mantooth assaulted Bouganville from Choisuel and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-10 17:49:43 - wez_mantooth assaulted Buka from Bouganville and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-10 17:50:02 - wez_mantooth assaulted New Hollandia from Buka and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-10 17:50:52 - wez_mantooth reinforced USS Lexington with 3 troops from Milne Bay
2009-03-10 17:50:52 - wez_mantooth gets spoils
2009-03-10 18:10:37 - ronnyr receives 5 troops for holding West Australia
2009-03-10 18:10:37 - ronnyr receives 4 troops for 14 regions
2009-03-10 18:15:27 - ronnyr deployed 9 troops on Admiralty Island
2009-03-10 18:15:31 - ronnyr assaulted Kavieng from Admiralty Island and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-10 18:15:36 - ronnyr assaulted New Hollandia from Kavieng and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-10 18:15:46 - ronnyr assaulted Buka from New Hollandia and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-10 18:15:50 - ronnyr assaulted Bouganville from Buka and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-10 18:16:12 - ronnyr reinforced Nhullunby with 3 troops from Wyndham
2009-03-10 18:16:12 - ronnyr gets spoils
2009-03-10 18:16:12 - Incrementing game to round 9
2009-03-10 23:36:34 - airforceking2 receives 3 troops for holding East Indies
2009-03-10 23:36:34 - airforceking2 receives 6 troops for 20 regions
2009-03-10 23:36:47 - airforceking2 deployed 9 troops on IJN Shokaku
2009-03-10 23:36:51 - airforceking2 assaulted IJN Shoho from IJN Shokaku and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 00:36:34 - airforceking2 ran out of time
2009-03-11 03:56:52 - wez_mantooth receives 4 troops for holding Papua
2009-03-11 03:56:52 - wez_mantooth receives 5 troops for holding East Australia
2009-03-11 03:56:52 - wez_mantooth receives 2 troops for holding Allied Navy
2009-03-11 03:56:52 - wez_mantooth receives 9 troops for 28 regions
2009-03-11 03:56:59 - wez_mantooth cashed in a group of Kavieng, Malaita, and Nhullunby worth 12 troops
2009-03-11 03:56:59 - wez_mantooth gets bonus of 2 troops added to Malaita
2009-03-11 03:57:20 - wez_mantooth deployed 32 troops on USS Lexington
2009-03-11 03:57:26 - wez_mantooth assaulted IJN Shoho from USS Lexington and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-11 03:57:42 - wez_mantooth assaulted IJN Shokaku from IJN Shoho and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-11 03:57:47 - wez_mantooth assaulted Truk from IJN Shokaku and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-11 03:58:05 - wez_mantooth assaulted Greenwich Island from Truk and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-11 03:58:17 - wez_mantooth assaulted Kavieng from Greenwich Island and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 03:58:33 - wez_mantooth assaulted New Hollandia from Kavieng and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 03:58:41 - wez_mantooth assaulted Buka from New Hollandia and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 03:58:46 - wez_mantooth assaulted Bouganville from Buka and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 03:59:32 - wez_mantooth reinforced Buka with 2 troops from Malaita
2009-03-11 03:59:32 - wez_mantooth gets spoils
2009-03-11 04:27:56 - ronnyr receives 5 troops for holding West Australia
2009-03-11 04:27:56 - ronnyr receives 4 troops for 13 regions
2009-03-11 04:28:00 - ronnyr cashed in a group of Pine Creek, Birdum, and Madang worth 15 troops
2009-03-11 04:28:00 - ronnyr gets bonus of 2 troops added to Pine Creek
2009-03-11 04:28:00 - ronnyr gets bonus of 2 troops added to Birdum
2009-03-11 04:28:25 - ronnyr deployed 24 troops on Admiralty Island
2009-03-11 04:28:31 - ronnyr assaulted Kavieng from Admiralty Island and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 04:28:46 - ronnyr assaulted Greenwich Island from Kavieng and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 04:28:54 - ronnyr assaulted New Hollandia from Kavieng and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 04:28:59 - ronnyr assaulted Buka from New Hollandia and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 04:29:04 - ronnyr assaulted Bouganville from Buka and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 04:29:08 - ronnyr assaulted Choisuel from Bouganville and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 04:29:11 - ronnyr assaulted Isabel from Choisuel and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 04:29:22 - ronnyr assaulted Tulagi from Isabel and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 04:29:28 - ronnyr assaulted Malaita from Tulagi and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 04:29:37 - ronnyr assaulted Guadalcanal from Tulagi and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 04:29:45 - ronnyr assaulted San Cristobal from Guadalcanal and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 04:29:57 - ronnyr gets spoils
2009-03-11 04:29:57 - Incrementing game to round 10
2009-03-11 07:32:39 - airforceking2 receives 3 troops for holding East Indies
2009-03-11 07:32:39 - airforceking2 receives 5 troops for 17 regions
2009-03-11 07:32:42 - airforceking2 deployed 8 troops on Ternati
2009-03-11 07:32:46 - airforceking2 assaulted Truk from Ternati and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 07:33:00 - airforceking2 assaulted IJN Shokaku from Truk and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 07:33:12 - airforceking2 assaulted IJN Shoho from IJN Shokaku and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 07:33:35 - airforceking2 reinforced IJN Shoho with 2 troops from Celebes
2009-03-11 07:33:35 - airforceking2 gets spoils
2009-03-11 07:39:58 - wez_mantooth receives 4 troops for holding Papua
2009-03-11 07:39:58 - wez_mantooth receives 5 troops for holding East Australia
2009-03-11 07:39:58 - wez_mantooth receives 2 troops for holding Allied Navy
2009-03-11 07:39:58 - wez_mantooth receives 7 troops for 22 regions
2009-03-11 07:40:02 - wez_mantooth cashed in a group of Timor, IJN Shoho, and Port Moresby worth 20 troops
2009-03-11 07:40:02 - wez_mantooth gets bonus of 2 troops added to Port Moresby
2009-03-11 07:41:05 - wez_mantooth deployed 30 troops on USS Lexington
2009-03-11 07:41:19 - wez_mantooth deployed 4 troops on Karumba
2009-03-11 07:41:26 - wez_mantooth deployed 4 troops on Lae
2009-03-11 07:41:36 - wez_mantooth assaulted Arawera from Lae and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-11 07:41:41 - wez_mantooth assaulted Rabaul from Arawera and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-11 07:41:57 - wez_mantooth assaulted IJN Shoho from USS Lexington and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-11 07:42:00 - wez_mantooth assaulted IJN Shokaku from IJN Shoho and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-11 07:42:05 - wez_mantooth assaulted Truk from IJN Shokaku and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-11 07:42:14 - wez_mantooth assaulted Greenwich Island from Truk and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 07:42:25 - wez_mantooth assaulted Kavieng from Greenwich Island and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 07:42:38 - wez_mantooth assaulted New Hollandia from Kavieng and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 07:42:49 - wez_mantooth assaulted Buka from New Hollandia and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 07:42:52 - wez_mantooth assaulted Bouganville from Buka and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 07:42:54 - wez_mantooth assaulted Choisuel from Bouganville and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 07:42:57 - wez_mantooth assaulted Isabel from Choisuel and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 07:43:05 - wez_mantooth assaulted Tulagi from Isabel and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 07:43:16 - wez_mantooth assaulted Guadalcanal from Tulagi and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 07:49:02 - wez_mantooth assaulted Admiralty Island from Kavieng and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 07:52:21 - wez_mantooth reinforced Admiralty Island with 2 troops from Rabaul
2009-03-11 07:52:21 - wez_mantooth gets spoils
2009-03-11 08:30:57 - ronnyr receives 5 troops for holding West Australia
2009-03-11 08:30:57 - ronnyr receives 4 troops for 14 regions
2009-03-11 08:31:35 - ronnyr deployed 9 troops on Malaita
2009-03-11 08:31:47 - ronnyr assaulted Tulagi from Malaita and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 08:31:53 - ronnyr assaulted Guadalcanal from Tulagi and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 08:32:05 - ronnyr assaulted Isabel from Tulagi and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 08:32:18 - ronnyr reinforced Nhullunby with 2 troops from Pine Creek
2009-03-11 08:32:18 - ronnyr gets spoils
2009-03-11 08:32:18 - Incrementing game to round 11
2009-03-11 17:42:07 - airforceking2 receives 3 troops for holding East Indies
2009-03-11 17:42:07 - airforceking2 receives 5 troops for 15 regions
2009-03-11 17:42:24 - airforceking2 deployed 8 troops on IJN Kaga
2009-03-11 17:42:34 - airforceking2 assaulted Tiwi Islands from IJN Kaga and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 17:42:57 - airforceking2 gets spoils
2009-03-11 18:02:44 - wez_mantooth receives 4 troops for holding Papua
2009-03-11 18:02:44 - wez_mantooth receives 4 troops for holding The Bismarks
2009-03-11 18:02:44 - wez_mantooth receives 5 troops for holding East Australia
2009-03-11 18:02:44 - wez_mantooth receives 2 troops for holding Allied Navy
2009-03-11 18:02:44 - wez_mantooth receives 11 troops for 34 regions
2009-03-11 18:03:10 - wez_mantooth deployed 15 troops on Choisuel
2009-03-11 18:03:50 - wez_mantooth deployed 11 troops on Aru
2009-03-11 18:03:57 - wez_mantooth assaulted Fak Fak from Aru and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-11 18:04:05 - wez_mantooth assaulted Nabir from Fak Fak and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 18:04:09 - wez_mantooth assaulted Mimika from Nabir and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 18:04:18 - wez_mantooth assaulted Isabel from Choisuel and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 18:04:24 - wez_mantooth assaulted Tulagi from Isabel and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 18:04:30 - wez_mantooth assaulted Malaita from Tulagi and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 18:04:38 - wez_mantooth assaulted Guadalcanal from Tulagi and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 18:04:42 - wez_mantooth assaulted San Cristobal from Guadalcanal and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 18:05:52 - wez_mantooth reinforced Mimika with 9 troops from San Cristobal
2009-03-11 18:05:52 - wez_mantooth gets spoils
2009-03-11 18:08:43 - ronnyr receives 3 troops for 9 regions
2009-03-11 18:09:30 - ronnyr deployed 3 troops on Mullingimbi
2009-03-11 18:09:36 - ronnyr assaulted Merauke from Mullingimbi and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-11 18:10:04 - ronnyr reinforced Darwin with 5 troops from Nhullunby
2009-03-11 18:10:04 - ronnyr gets spoils
2009-03-11 18:10:04 - Incrementing game to round 12
2009-03-11 18:44:03 - airforceking2 receives 3 troops for holding East Indies
2009-03-11 18:44:03 - airforceking2 receives 4 troops for 14 regions
2009-03-11 18:44:08 - airforceking2 cashed in a group of Aitape, Choisuel, and Bamaga worth 25 troops
2009-03-11 18:44:17 - airforceking2 deployed 32 troops on Ternati
2009-03-11 18:44:26 - airforceking2 assaulted Sansapor from Ternati and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 18:44:49 - airforceking2 assaulted Truk from Ternati and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 18:44:57 - airforceking2 assaulted Greenwich Island from Truk and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 18:45:16 - airforceking2 assaulted IJN Shokaku from Truk and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 18:45:19 - airforceking2 assaulted IJN Shoho from IJN Shokaku and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-11 18:45:24 - airforceking2 gets spoils
2009-03-11 19:12:06 - wez_mantooth receives 4 troops for holding Papua
2009-03-11 19:12:06 - wez_mantooth receives 4 troops for holding Solomons
2009-03-11 19:12:06 - wez_mantooth receives 5 troops for holding East Australia
2009-03-11 19:12:06 - wez_mantooth receives 2 troops for holding Allied Navy
2009-03-11 19:12:06 - wez_mantooth receives 12 troops for 37 regions
2009-03-11 19:13:38 - wez_mantooth deployed 27 troops on USS Lexington
2009-03-11 19:13:42 - wez_mantooth assaulted IJN Shoho from USS Lexington and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-11 19:13:49 - wez_mantooth assaulted IJN Shokaku from IJN Shoho and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-11 19:13:53 - wez_mantooth assaulted Truk from IJN Shokaku and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-11 19:14:14 - wez_mantooth assaulted Greenwich Island from Truk and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-11 19:14:32 - wez_mantooth assaulted Ternati from Truk and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-11 19:15:02 - wez_mantooth assaulted Sansapor from Ternati and conquered it from airforceking2
2009-03-11 19:15:16 - wez_mantooth assaulted Merauke from Mimika and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 19:15:29 - wez_mantooth assaulted Nhullunby from Karumba and conquered it from ronnyr
2009-03-11 19:16:39 - wez_mantooth reinforced Bamaga with 2 troops from Rabaul
2009-03-11 19:16:39 - wez_mantooth gets spoils
2009-03-12 04:26:55 - ronnyr receives 3 troops for 8 regions
2009-03-12 04:26:59 - ronnyr cashed in a group of Mullingimbi, Destroyer Sims, and Buka worth 30 troops
2009-03-12 04:26:59 - ronnyr gets bonus of 2 troops added to Mullingimbi
2009-03-12 04:28:00 - ronnyr deployed 33 troops on Birdum
2009-03-12 04:28:08 - ronnyr assaulted Nhullunby from Birdum and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-12 04:28:15 - ronnyr assaulted Karumba from Nhullunby and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-12 04:28:22 - ronnyr assaulted Mareeba from Karumba and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-12 04:28:27 - ronnyr assaulted Townsville from Mareeba and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-12 04:28:36 - ronnyr assaulted Cairns from Townsville and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-12 04:28:42 - ronnyr assaulted USS Lexington from Cairns and conquered it from wez_mantooth
2009-03-12 04:29:27 - ronnyr reinforced Karumba with 15 troops from USS Lexington
2009-03-12 04:29:27 - ronnyr gets spoils
2009-03-12 04:29:27 - Incrementing game to round 13

Re: suspicious - airforceking2 and ronnyr game 4402113

PostPosted: Thu Mar 12, 2009 6:05 am
by Stroop
You have almost 40 regions and several bonuses... Of course they're attacking you, fighting each other would just hand you the game...

Re: suspicious - airforceking2 and ronnyr game 4402113

PostPosted: Thu Mar 12, 2009 8:22 pm
by king sam
Most important part of Game Log and Chat is lost in the extremely horrendous log you referenced.

Here it is below:

Game 4402113 Chat wrote:2009-03-11 20:13:06 - wez_mantooth: hmm i'm sure secret diplomacy is against the rules!


Game 4402113 Game Log wrote:2009-03-11 19:08:43 - ronnyr receives 3 troops for 9 regions
2009-03-11 19:09:30 - ronnyr deployed 3 troops on Mullingimbi

2009-03-11 19:44:03 - airforceking2 receives 3 troops for holding East Indies
2009-03-11 19:44:03 - airforceking2 receives 4 troops for 14 regions
2009-03-11 19:44:08 - airforceking2 cashed in a group of Aitape, Choisuel, and Bamaga worth 25 troops
2009-03-11 19:44:17 - airforceking2 deployed 32 troops on Ternati

2009-03-11 20:12:06 - wez_mantooth receives 4 troops for holding Papua
2009-03-11 20:12:06 - wez_mantooth receives 4 troops for holding Solomons
2009-03-11 20:12:06 - wez_mantooth receives 5 troops for holding East Australia
2009-03-11 20:12:06 - wez_mantooth receives 2 troops for holding Allied Navy
2009-03-11 20:12:06 - wez_mantooth receives 12 troops for 37 regions
2009-03-11 20:13:38 - wez_mantooth deployed 27 troops on USS Lexington


At the time of your post your opposition held 23 regions and 1 bonus together.
You held 37 regions and 4 bonuses. (NOTE: This is also after airforceking conquered 5 of your territories.


Stroop is right, when it looks like 1 player has the game decided it often turns to alliances that make practical sense for the remaining players to help them stay in the game.

I and everyone else will most likely assume this is the case here, as both the accused are making moves to keep alive in the game.

Best of Luck though
King Sam

Re: suspicious - airforceking2 and ronnyr game 4402113

PostPosted: Thu Mar 12, 2009 8:44 pm
by lancehoch
airforceking2 and ronnyr are Cleared of being multis with one another. Also, based on the information in the game log (highligted by king sam) it des not appear that there was a secret alliance in this game. If there are more instances of malicious play you can cite them in this thread and it will be looked into.