robindreaux, steezul and steelhorse [cleared]

[shanksdigs]

Accused:

robindreaux
Steezul
Steelhorse

Game 4351306

The accused are suspected of:

Being Multis
Conducting Secret Diplomacy

Other: I cannot be sure that one of them is a multi, and I realize I am calling out a moderator here, but this game smelled like cheating to me.

Steelhorse and robindreaux have played together before. By virtue of robindreaux's move in round 3, robindreaux set the table for Steelhorse to win. I find it difficult to believe that Steelhorse was only lucky to have been the player who followed Steezul and robindreaux. I played a fair game and this game had all the trappings of secret diplomacy.



Game number(s):

[game]xxxxxxx[/game]
[game]xxxxxxx[/game]
[game]xxxxxxx[/game]
[game]xxxxxxx[/game]



Comments:

[shanksdigs]

Neither steezul nor steelhorse was at all concerned that robindreaux didn't take a first turn. Neither posted to robindreaux's wall to inform robindreaux of being up and potentially missing a turn. While this is not necessarily cause for me to call them cheaters, it just was one of many things that didn't make sense in this game. I think it is only fair that this is researched and not tossed aside simply becuase steelhorse is a moderator.

[mpjh]

We all know that Robin cannot follow instructions unless there are pictures.

[owenshooter]

We all know that Robin cannot follow instructions unless there are pictures.

um... wrong robin... and how dare you sully robinettes name in C&A? but nice try... parting gift at the door on your way out...

and as far as the accusation goes, the game chat just shows a poor loser...-0

[gcwca_4_life]

You do realize that one of these is a moderator on this site right? I would have to say your full of shit!

[Optimus Prime]

Just because someone doesn't remind another player that it is their turn, does not mean they are cheating. I have deadbeats in games all the time. I don't go sending them messages and posting on their wall that they are about to miss their turn. If they are missing turns, likely they aren't going to read a PM or see a wall message anyways because they are most likely not logging into the site.

I can't believe you accused Steelhorse of cheating.

[army of nobunaga]

this is ridiculous... seriously...


lol

robin barely handles one ip

[kiddicus maximus]

on steel horse I chide, I'm whining (WHIIINNIIINNNGGGGGG) 'cause I didn't survive!

/Bon Jovi

[happy2seeyou]

The reason Steelhorse's play was a bit off is purely because he doesn't know how to play. Don't blame him for things he cannot control.

[shanksdigs]

As usual, mindless chatter from the pigeons that troll the forum hoping to make the funniest comment possible. NOne of you said anything worth a darn with respect to the game, you didn't check the log, and you're clueless.

[gcwca_4_life]

As usual, mindless chatter from the pigeons that troll the forum hoping to make the funniest comment possible. NOne of you said anything worth a darn with respect to the game, you didn't check the log, and you're clueless.

How are we supposed to go straight to the game if you didn't fill it out right? And I do not think a moderator would cheat. So once again I say, your full of shit.

And some people just make idiot moves. If you can't deal with that, then start foeing people. But have fun trying to foe mods. It's impossible.

[owenshooter]

As usual, mindless chatter from the pigeons that troll the forum hoping to make the funniest comment possible. NOne of you said anything worth a darn with respect to the game, you didn't check the log, and you're clueless.

first of all, you filled out your form incorrectly and very few peope will go find the game themselves. i went and found it, and you are simply whining about a loss. someone else in the thread posted chat from the game. you have no proof of a cheating. you have proof of being a poor loser. to top it off, if someone posted on my wall or pm'd me that it was my turn, i guarantee you i would take my turn down to the last possible moment i could finish my turn in. and did you think that possibly people are making fun of you in this thread, because your accusations are absolutely ridiculous?-0

p.s.-sully just beat me 2 out of 3, should i accuse him of cheating?!!

[Joodoo]

As usual, mindless chatter from the pigeons that troll the forum hoping to make the funniest comment possible. NOne of you said anything worth a darn with respect to the game, you didn't check the log, and you're clueless.

first of all, you filled out your form incorrectly and very few peope will go find the game themselves. i went and found it, and you are simply whining about a loss. someone else in the thread posted chat from the game. you have no proof of a cheating. you have proof of being a poor loser. to top it off, if someone posted on my wall or pm'd me that it was my turn, i guarantee you i would take my turn down to the last possible moment i could finish my turn in. and did you think that possibly people are making fun of you in this thread, because your accusations are absolutely ridiculous?-0

p.s.-sully just beat me 2 out of 3, should i accuse him of cheating?!!

owen has a point here, just because you lost to someone doesn't mean they're a cheater (and the chances of a mod being a cheater is very low... I think)

[happy2seeyou]

As usual, mindless chatter from the pigeons that troll the forum hoping to make the funniest comment possible. NOne of you said anything worth a darn with respect to the game, you didn't check the log, and you're clueless.

You haven't even filled out the form correctly. Don't bitch about people not reading the log if you can't even remember to post what game it was.

[clapper011]

as for steel horse..you will find he did not or never has cheated....

[Kotaro]

As usual, mindless chatter from the pigeons that troll the forum hoping to make the funniest comment possible. NOne of you said anything worth a darn with respect to the game, you didn't check the log, and you're clueless.

*Bing bing bing bing bing* We have ourselves a winner!

Other: I cannot be sure that one of them is a multi, and I realize I am calling out a moderator here, but this game smelled like cheating to me.

You do realize that one of these is a moderator on this site right? I would have to say your full of shit!

LOL

How are we supposed to go straight to the game if you didn't fill it out right? And I do not think a moderator would cheat. So once again I say, your full of shit.

LOL again. "Your full of shit". And you're full of terrible grammar. If you didn't look at the game, how do you know he's full of shit? Yes, I know, copying and pasting that number is just soooooo much effort, but since you haven't seen shit, how can you call bullshit?

You haven't even filled out the form correctly. Don't bitch about people not reading the log if you can't even remember to post what game it was.

Accused:

robindreaux
Steezul
Steelhorse

Game 4351306

So hard to find that one. It's crazy even, you'd have to spend hours looking for it!

As for the accusation;

2009-02-26 21:03:47 - shanksdigs: you wouldn't have been able to take her out with her army of 10.

Luck favors... random people? Steelhorse got some lucky rolls, nothing more.

@ Everyone else, nice super-trolling you did, it was LOLable.

[ronsizzle]

As usual, mindless chatter from the pigeons that troll the forum hoping to make the funniest comment possible. NOne of you said anything worth a darn with respect to the game, you didn't check the log, and you're clueless.

first of all, you filled out your form incorrectly and very few peope will go find the game themselves. i went and found it, and you are simply whining about a loss. someone else in the thread posted chat from the game. you have no proof of a cheating. you have proof of being a poor loser. to top it off, if someone posted on my wall or pm'd me that it was my turn, i guarantee you i would take my turn down to the last possible moment i could finish my turn in. and did you think that possibly people are making fun of you in this thread, because your accusations are absolutely ridiculous?-0

p.s.-sully just beat me 2 out of 3, should i accuse him of cheating?!!

owen has a point here, just because you lost to someone doesn't mean they're a cheater (and the chances of a mod being a cheater is very low... I think)

can anyone remember wicked????

[Timminz]

can anyone remember wicked????

Can you speak up a bit? I can't hear you over the rumbling of all these trolls.

[owenshooter]

can anyone remember wicked????

yes, and i also remember laughter... and wicked didn't cheat in games... she just went nuts
from a tick bite and tried to bring CC down to it's proverbial knees...-0

[happy2seeyou]

So hard to find that one. It's crazy even, you'd have to spend hours looking for it!

He/she didn't post the game number until AFTER

[Kotaro]

Really? Because when you edit a post, there's a nice time code, something like...

Last edited by Kotaro on Tue Feb 24, 2009 3:13 pm, edited 10 times in total.

And his has none.

[barterer2002]

Looking at the log it appears that Green had 2 terts and that Red tried to take him out and failed. The chat indicates that it was 12 v 11 or something close like that and that the 2 cards were out there with Blue sitting with a 4 set. With those 4 cards there's a better than 85% chance that he's turning in. Red made the play for Green to keep him from Blue. It may not have been a good move and it clearly backfired on Red as Blue moved in and took her out but just because another player makes a bad move doesn't mean that there is cheating involved. People make bad moves every day. I probably make 5-6 a day at a minimum. Does it suck when someone makes a bad move that costs you the game-of course everyone has been there but that doesn't mean there is cheating going on.

[JOHNNYROCKET24]

The reason Steelhorse's play was a bit off is purely because he doesn't know how to play. Don't blame him for things he cannot control.

so true

[owenshooter]

Really? Because when you edit a post, there's a nice time code, something like...

Last edited by Kotaro on Tue Feb 24, 2009 3:13 pm, edited 10 times in total.

And his has none.

regardless, when you click on the game, it doesn't take you there, because it wasn't done properly... and even then, if you take the time to go to the game, there is nothing there but the OP whining about losing a game...-0

[Kotaro]

regardless, when you click on the game, it doesn't take you there, because it wasn't done properly... and even then, if you take the time to go to the game, there is nothing there but the OP whining about losing a game...-0

The chat log is not necessarily good evidence, but that doesn't mean the game log isn't. Don't mistake me though, I'm not saying there is any evidence there, just Steelhorse getting damn lucky. And I don't remember seeing anywhere in the C&A report where it says "If you don't use the [game] bbcode, your entire form is wrong". Perhaps you could enlighten me as to where it says "use these codes or your form is disregarded".