dimonifran [noted]

[cspare]

Accused:

dimonifran


The accused are suspected of:

Other: abusing the rating system



Game number(s):

Game 3134730
For a complete list: http://www.conquerclub.com/player.php?m ... dimonifran



Comments:
I can only speak for the game i played in together with him. The rating he left for all of us is totally unfounded. He left both me and the winner of the game a 1-star rating on all three components, while I was in fact doing very well in the game (and the winner of the game obviously too).

[t-o-m]

He left 8 bad ratings, maybe he just doesnt leave ratings for good, only for bad?

[cspare]

He left 8 bad ratings, maybe he just doesnt leave ratings for good, only for bad?

I don't think thats the case here, atleast not for game 3134730. He is obviously frustrated that he lost the game, and as an act revenge rated us bad. This is especially obvious if you look at the way he rated the winner of the game, babagonosh. He even tagged that rating with 'Sore Loser' (but he won) while he never said anything negative in chat. Which in turn also makes his 1-star rating on attitude questionable.

[Bruceswar]

As the mods will say... Foe him and move on. Ratings are rather worthless...

[king achilles]

As of this late, he has not yet given a 'questionable' rating to anyone. We do not want to second guess a person's judgment on his given ratings but if we see that he is giving ratings without basis from most of his games, we will look into this further.