Conquer Club

Accused:
TheShape
Bam-Bam

The accused are suspected of:

Being Multis
Conducting Secret Diplomacy

Game number(s):

Game 3150016

Comments:

2008-08-29 15:18:48 - Scott-Land: was that coordinated?
2008-08-29 15:18:48 - Phlaim: wow that looks like multi

2008-08-29 15:21:24 - msubryan: why lose 17 armies to get a trade in worth 4?
2008-08-29 15:22:08 - TheShape: that wasn't the plan
2008-08-29 15:22:56 - msubryan: ok? what exactly was the plan...

2008-08-29 15:23:05 - Scott-Land: red goes from nw to greenland, hits iceland all the way to ukraine the turn before
2008-08-29 15:23:43 - Scott-Land: conventiently first to cash at 4 to time it perfectly with a 16 auto in sa from another player?

2008-08-29 15:30:25 - Phlaim: pink, this was wasn't just something that didn't go someones way

They've only played one game together. No chance, Lance.

You'd be thick to be a multi and spend so much on 2 premiums, risking getting caught. And plsu there too big ranks, normally multis have one big rank and one small

2008-08-29 15:18:48 - Scott-Land: was that coordinated?
2008-08-29 15:18:48 - Phlaim: wow that looks like multi

Seems as Phlaim and I thought the same thing at the same time. Being in the game and seeing it, it looked extremely suspicious -coordinated. Bam had a big stack in NW Territory, went through some 1s, 2, and a 3 to park in Ukraine the turn before. There wasn't much aggression in SA betreen teal (msubryan) and pink ( TheShape)- just building stacks there.

You can credit Bam's insight by foreseeing trouble and setting up the kill- only problem it was teal ( private) that was the lower ranked of the two players. TheShape was a major- I certainly wouldn't had expected the higher rank to noob up a stack of 16. If it were the other way around and pink's only other terr was Ural- I wouldn't had questioned the play. Setting up the low rank to noob it up in a bonus is one thing. But for Bam, to think Shape would hit MSU instead of vice versa was the strangest part.

I've played enough to realize when a play is being coordinated- most of the time I just chalk it up to poor play or suicides and even both. It was definitely an odd play but again that was TheShape's first freestyle game let alone escalating. Mostly a flat rate player where those types of plays are seen quite often.

Bam's trek to Ukraine could had been a coincidence or jockeying for position since he only had one large front- perhaps it was insightful and perhaps too good of a play that got everyone questioning it.

Frustrating ReckedR but nothing concrete to drag their names through the mud.

They may have their own strategy and may have took some risk in accomplishing it. Regardless, this is Bam-Bam and TheShape's first game together so far and we would need more games of suspicious plays from the same players pointing to a secret alliance between them to merit a block.