Conquer Club

Accused:

TheDuke5
frodo5660

The accused are suspected of:

Conducting Secret Diplomacy

Game number(s):

Game 20291880
Game 20260311
Game 20291604
Game 20099597

Comments: In game 20291880 they did nothing to prevent each other bonus and they took risks attacking other 2 opponents as if they knew they had no threat from each other. They have played 82 games together, many of them 4 player fog.

All I'll say is that, yes, we play together lots, but I don't think we do a lot of fog- mostly because I don't like it. We're definitely friendly, but in the game we played, we were not originally attacking each other because it didn't make a lot of sense.

Let's have a look at this

PENDING

TheDuke5 wrote:All I'll say is that, yes, we play together lots, but I don't think we do a lot of fog- mostly because I don't like it. We're definitely friendly, but in the game we played, we were not originally attacking each other because it didn't make a lot of sense.

You have between you won 60% of multi player games you play together. Some 34 games, 20 won between you. That's some record!

Your record when not playing together is less than 20%

The 11 wins in 13 games between the two of you when playing 4 player games together is pretty damning when you aren't exactly tearing it up otherwise.

what a coincidence to join 2 min apart from each other back in 2014!

Dude, we know each other outside of CC. We joined at the same time and like to play together. That's not the same as actively colluding in games.

Based on all the evidence presented and going through all the games together, in particular standard 4+ player games.
And also given the fact that both players ignored me when contacted to ask why
I find them Guilty of secret diplomacy
and place a CC BLOCK on them playing games together in future