Conquer Club

calicus

The accused are suspected of:
Ratings abuse

Game number(s):

Game 12087062 accuses me, wreckead, mrbean721 of secret diplomacy just because he lost.
Game 9785090 gives Craig25 one star even though he has lost both games he played against him.
Game 11255445 gives DoomYoshi, bragsie, crazycolin all one stars and accuses them of Irrational, Secret Diplomacy, Cheap Tactics, Poor Strategy

Comments:
that is a total of 7 ratings that were bad with no excuse but because he was mad because he lost!

It is a total of 7 ratings that were bad with no excuse but because he was mad because he lost?

therev1957 wrote:calicus

The accused are suspected of:
Ratings abuse

Game number(s):

Game 12087062 accuses me, wreckead, mrbean721 of secret diplomacy just because he lost.
Game 9785090 gives Craig25 one star even though he has lost both games he played against him.
Game 11255445 gives DoomYoshi, bragsie, crazycolin all one stars and accuses them of Irrational, Secret Diplomacy, Cheap Tactics, Poor Strategy

Comments:
that is a total of 7 ratings that were bad with no excuse but because he was mad because he lost!

One game is from the year 2011, another is from middle of October this year. Only one is recent (middle of December).
You search through a player's entire history and only find 3 games where he acted with poor sportmanship and rated unrationally? I'd say that guy is an angel

Gillipig wrote:
One game is from the year 2011, another is from middle of October this year. Only one is recent (middle of December).
You search through a player's entire history and only find 3 games where he acted with poor sportmanship and rated unrationally? I'd say that guy is an angel

Well Gillipig did you really look closely at his first page of ratings? It covers 7 months....which means 1. he doesn't play much...or 2. he only rates when he likes someone or gets ticked because he loses!

I'll note this just to see where it goes.