Swisher43 Rating Abuse [BUSTED] KRK
Posted: Fri Jul 20, 2012 10:55 pmAccused:
Swisher43
The accused are suspected of:
Other: Rating Abuse
Game number(s):
Game 11218929
Game 11236191
Game 11238100
Game 11272212
Game 11307958
Game 11286268
Game 11220019
Game 11260475
Game 11260478
Game 11260480
Comments:Ok this guy is still new to the site (only played 12 games in the last month) but of the 24 rating he has given I am seeing quite a few that where given unfairly.
The first example of this is the ratings of Peter321 (Game 11218929), navajo_lunar (Game 11236191), dsl (Game 11307958), 13kidthirteen (Game 11238100), and kimbostan (Game 11272212). These 4 players are all new recruits that missed their first three turns of their respective games. That being said they all received 1 star across the board, with the exception of peter321 who received a 2 star in fair play. None of them said anything in game chat so their or took any turns so they really can’t be judged on their game play, fair play, or attitude as there is nothing to base your judgment on. That being said the main reason I brought these players up is that Dmomurderer(4 stars across the board(Game 11236191)) and Ian Moone (3 stars across the board(Game 11236191)) did the same thing as the players mention above with the exception of Ian Moone saying hello and making a comment/question that makes him sound clueless.
Now onto a more obvious abuse of the rating system. EESHA was rated 1 star across the board with the tags Deadbeat and Cheap Tactics. Swisher43 played three games with EESHA (Game 11307958, Game 11286268, and Game 11220019). EESHA won two and lost the third. He did not miss a single turn in any of the three games. He did not say GL and did not always say GG but since Swisher43 never said ether it is hard to say EESHA had a bad attitude (which is what he was rated). As for game play he won 66% of the 4 player games he played in with Swisher43 which clearly say his game play is not bad (it may not be great but winning two of three 4 player games means you’re doing something right) as for fair play I was not in the game and can’t tell if he used cheap tactics as Swisher43 say but I suspect Swisher43 is just mad that he lost and that is why he rated him a 1 across the board.
Next up is the rating of all. all played one 4 player game with Swisher43 (Game 11307958) and won that game. He did not miss any turns or say anything. Considering it was only his second game on the map I doubt he was using cheap tactics. Swisher43 rated all 1 stars in all categories.
The last example is Swisher43 rating of both NoSurvivors and myself (caymanmew). We were both rated 1 in fair play (we used somewhat cheap tactics so that is a understandable rating) 1 in game play (we won all 3 games we played with Swisher43 in (Game 11260475, Game 11260478, Game 11260480) so clearly our game play is not that bad) and a 3 in attitude (nothing was said so this is a fair rating)
Overall Swisher43 has not yet got a long record of bad ratings but after only 12 games he is most defiantly on his way. I think a warning would be wise and hopefully get Swisher43 to stop poorly rating people who beat him.
Swisher43
The accused are suspected of:
Other: Rating Abuse
Game number(s):
Game 11218929
Game 11236191
Game 11238100
Game 11272212
Game 11307958
Game 11286268
Game 11220019
Game 11260475
Game 11260478
Game 11260480
Comments:Ok this guy is still new to the site (only played 12 games in the last month) but of the 24 rating he has given I am seeing quite a few that where given unfairly.
The first example of this is the ratings of Peter321 (Game 11218929), navajo_lunar (Game 11236191), dsl (Game 11307958), 13kidthirteen (Game 11238100), and kimbostan (Game 11272212). These 4 players are all new recruits that missed their first three turns of their respective games. That being said they all received 1 star across the board, with the exception of peter321 who received a 2 star in fair play. None of them said anything in game chat so their or took any turns so they really can’t be judged on their game play, fair play, or attitude as there is nothing to base your judgment on. That being said the main reason I brought these players up is that Dmomurderer(4 stars across the board(Game 11236191)) and Ian Moone (3 stars across the board(Game 11236191)) did the same thing as the players mention above with the exception of Ian Moone saying hello and making a comment/question that makes him sound clueless.
Now onto a more obvious abuse of the rating system. EESHA was rated 1 star across the board with the tags Deadbeat and Cheap Tactics. Swisher43 played three games with EESHA (Game 11307958, Game 11286268, and Game 11220019). EESHA won two and lost the third. He did not miss a single turn in any of the three games. He did not say GL and did not always say GG but since Swisher43 never said ether it is hard to say EESHA had a bad attitude (which is what he was rated). As for game play he won 66% of the 4 player games he played in with Swisher43 which clearly say his game play is not bad (it may not be great but winning two of three 4 player games means you’re doing something right) as for fair play I was not in the game and can’t tell if he used cheap tactics as Swisher43 say but I suspect Swisher43 is just mad that he lost and that is why he rated him a 1 across the board.
Next up is the rating of all. all played one 4 player game with Swisher43 (Game 11307958) and won that game. He did not miss any turns or say anything. Considering it was only his second game on the map I doubt he was using cheap tactics. Swisher43 rated all 1 stars in all categories.
The last example is Swisher43 rating of both NoSurvivors and myself (caymanmew). We were both rated 1 in fair play (we used somewhat cheap tactics so that is a understandable rating) 1 in game play (we won all 3 games we played with Swisher43 in (Game 11260475, Game 11260478, Game 11260480) so clearly our game play is not that bad) and a 3 in attitude (nothing was said so this is a fair rating)
Overall Swisher43 has not yet got a long record of bad ratings but after only 12 games he is most defiantly on his way. I think a warning would be wise and hopefully get Swisher43 to stop poorly rating people who beat him.
