Conquer Club

Accused:

aries4272
jcook343


The accused are suspected of:

Conducting Secret Diplomacy


Game number(s):

10635794


Comments: Toward the end of the game, these players talked of a "deal" they had in place. However they did not mention anything about a deal before hand and the dialogue strongly suggests they have had other deals in place in other games. After a little research, they play MANY games together and one of them seems to win a high percentage of the games they play together. It seems obvious to that when they play games together they will do what they can to help the other.

millertime579 wrote:Accused:

aries4272
jcook343


The accused are suspected of:

Conducting Secret Diplomacy


Game number(s):

Game 10635794


Comments: Toward the end of the game, these players talked of a "deal" they had in place. However they did not mention anything about a deal before hand and the dialogue strongly suggests they have had other deals in place in other games. After a little research, they play MANY games together and one of them seems to win a high percentage of the games they play together. It seems obvious to that when they play games together they will do what they can to help the other.

Fixed links

I can't read the entire game log, nor can I load the full log. For me the log begins with blue saying GG.
(2012-02-23 03:02:41 - aries4272: good game....well played o/)
They are talking about a deal, did the announce any form of truce in the log before that?
If they stated in the log they made a truce or a no attack treaty then they haven't broken the rules. If the agreed a deal through PM or on their wall then it's foul play.

sniffie

they made no mention of any deal or truce prior to the the comment about forgetting they had a deal. Of course i would not be upset if such a deal was posted at the start of the game. They have played too many games together in which one of them wins a high percentage of the time.

millertime579 wrote:they made no mention of any deal or truce prior to the the comment about forgetting they had a deal. Of course i would not be upset if such a deal was posted at the start of the game. They have played too many games together in which one of them wins a high percentage of the time.

I red only posted he forgot about their deal and it was really not stated in the game log they have some serious explaining to do. Their probably multis or good friends playing for one and another.

sniffie

I just went back to the game and tried to copy and paste the chat between the two players in question. It seems as though all statements have been cleared by someone except mine. Even the response to my questioning their tactics. I did not think that comments made in chat could be deleted.

sniffie wrote:

millertime579 wrote:they made no mention of any deal or truce prior to the the comment about forgetting they had a deal. Of course i would not be upset if such a deal was posted at the start of the game. They have played too many games together in which one of them wins a high percentage of the time.

I red only posted he forgot about their deal and it was really not stated in the game log they have some serious explaining to do. Their probably multis or good friends playing for one and another.

sniffie

You are correct. The post stating they forgot about their deal was the 1st comment made about such a deal. I am sure they are friends playing together and making it very hard for Outsiders to win a game against the two.

comments in game chat cannot be deleted, so if there where comments they are still there.

sniffie

millertime579 wrote:I just went back to the game and tried to copy and paste the chat between the two players in question. It seems as though all statements have been cleared by someone except mine. Even the response to my questioning their tactics. I did not think that comments made in chat could be deleted.

Have you foed them, as if you have they will have disappeared

cookie0117 wrote:

millertime579 wrote:I just went back to the game and tried to copy and paste the chat between the two players in question. It seems as though all statements have been cleared by someone except mine. Even the response to my questioning their tactics. I did not think that comments made in chat could be deleted.

Have you foed them, as if you have they will have disappeared

ooh yeah forgot about that

sniffie

aries4272: good game....well played o/
2012-02-22 22:06:06 - jcook343: dude i totally forgot about our deal, i got too excited. i'll make sure you win North America. we can do deals, i just have to remember.. sorry man, you're my bro. was not intentional
2012-02-22 22:22:57 - jcook343: i did not mean to deceive you. i'll place my guys while you rebuild back to even troops, then we'll do what we set out to do...
2012-02-22 22:34:42 - aries4272: its cool man...take the win...i wont play this game anymore
2012-02-22 22:47:17 - jcook343: dude i feel terrible, im watching tv, playing 3 games at once, had a few beers i just fucked up, please don't quit.. unless of course you just don't like the game in general, but its fun playing with you.
2012-02-22 22:59:33 - aries4272: i will still play ofc...no worries....just end the game so we can start another one
2012-02-22 23:01:39 - jcook343: deal

This seems pretty cut and dried. If you are stupid enough to announce you have a truce without actually announcing the truce in the first place, you deserve what you get.

Hit them where it hurts KRK!

I saw the game there is no way they could be cleared on this

redhedge47 wrote:I saw the game there is no way they could be cleared on this

Have you seen our MH's?!? There is always a way.

Evolution299 wrote:

redhedge47 wrote:I saw the game there is no way they could be cleared on this

Have you seen our MH's?!? There is always a way.

But some awkward situations have some really good explanation to do...

sniffie

aries4272= WARNED
jcook343= WARNED

Both are blocked from playing against each other...