Conquer Club

1stcatalyst
jdtins



The accused are suspected of:


Conducting Secret Diplomacy
Game number(s):

Game 10412308
And Potentially in:
Game 10412319


Comments:
Ok so going into the last round of Game 10412308 I had a 400-600 troop lead over both green and yellow. Neither player could on his own win the game.
Green did nothing on his turn then after I took my turn he wrote in game chat:
2012-02-29 09:19:14 - 1stCatalyst: Its up to you jdtins... by attacking or not you can decide this game.... its a lot of power for the last placed man and I just wish I could offer you a bribe... lol
2012-02-29 12:39:23 - 1stCatalyst: of course, maybe there is... there is another game going on right now that we are both in... if you should ask a favour in that...

Yellow had no chance of reducing both green and I to less troops than him to achieve the victory on amount of troops once round limit was reached.
So why Yellow mindlessly assualted me handing green the win is beyond any reason.
Green covered himself by posting on yellows wall:
This is written in the gamechat so don't think I'm cheating - I just want to make sure you know...
Game# 10412308
Its the last round and you get to decide the winner if you choose. I just wish I could offer you a bribe... lol

by 1stCatalyst
on Feb 29th, '12, 09:22

In the same tournament another stalemate is developing hence the 'favour' comment Game 10412319

There is not one credible reason why yellow would attack me like he did unless green has offered him something in return.
Someone is bound to say foe and move on but its in a tournament.

first off all, Foe And Move On,

nah, just kidding, there is really something fishy here. To me it is not yet clear whether both players are involved or just jdtins, he might personally know the other player and thinks he is being funny. But something fishy fur sure here.

sniffie

Regardless of whether he posted it in chat or not, you cannot post discussions about diplomacy on someones' wall when they are not your partner.

1stcatalyst is WARNED for Secret Diplomacy

I've had a couple of players in the past post on my wall "read gamechat in game #########"
Is this considered okay?
I realise what I offered was probably a bit over the top and I will avoid games with jdtins for the remainder of this tournament, however, he has made me like his play and were I in a position where I could not win but could decide the game as may well be the case in 10412319 I will be very tempted to knock others out.
Again it may seem unfair but that is the attentive kind of player I am, no good deed would go unnoticed as it were...

1stCatalyst wrote:I've had a couple of players in the past post on my wall "read gamechat in game #########"
Is this considered okay?
I realise what I offered was probably a bit over the top and I will avoid games with jdtins for the remainder of this tournament, however, he has made me like his play and were I in a position where I could not win but could decide the game as may well be the case in 10412319 I will be very tempted to knock others out.
Again it may seem unfair but that is the attentive kind of player I am, no good deed would go unnoticed as it were...

Yes you are allowed to say read game chat for game ####### but that is all.

Maybe you should not have posted the part in blue. That could possibly have repercussions for you in the future.

Evil Semp wrote:

1stCatalyst wrote:I've had a couple of players in the past post on my wall "read gamechat in game #########"
Is this considered okay?
I realise what I offered was probably a bit over the top and I will avoid games with jdtins for the remainder of this tournament, however, he has made me like his play and were I in a position where I could not win but could decide the game as may well be the case in 10412319 I will be very tempted to knock others out.
Again it may seem unfair but that is the attentive kind of player I am, no good deed would go unnoticed as it were...

Yes you are allowed to say read game chat for game ####### but that is all.

Maybe you should not have posted the part in blue. That could possibly have repercussions for you in the future.

No possible about it, kinda proves my original point