nicho74 - suiciding on truces [NOTED] KRK

[Killerz999]

Accused:nicho74




The accused are suspected of:

Other: Purposely suiciding so another player will win.


Game 9960387

Comments: This player is under the impresion that in game truces are illegal.
After trying to negotiate one with him in a game we were clearly desitined to lose he took me out. He then referred me to his profile page where he states he will take people out for offering truces.
In chat I pointed out his misunderstanding, but disagress.

Here is his profile comment.

nicho74
Hi everyone, One thing: if you play with me in a single game and try to make a truce with any player; I'll quite this game. If you try to make a truce with me against another player, I'll attack you everyturn till one of us loose. Hope things are clear..... fair play is important! Let's play now by nicho74
on Tue Nov 16, 2010 2:59 pm
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

[gibbyrfc]

What he is being is not a form of cheating,

it is his own opinion that he does not agree with Truces and there are many out there who agree on principal.

if you offer a truce with another play then he may feel threatened so he attacks the offerer of the truce,

this is not against the rules.

FAMO

[Killerz999]

Of course you can attack.. this is fair.
But his stated position is that he will suicide on you.
Purposely suiciding is against another, however, is prohibited.

[jeraado]

I think this is one of those things where the line gets a little bit fuzzy. Gameplay which you don't agree with is not illegal, but deliberately throwing a game is. Assuming there is a pattern of this occuring, IMHO it is difficult to draw a distinction here between a game style (if anyone truces then I'm playing against a two player team, so I'd better take out that player first to protect myself / discourage the truce from continuing) and a deliberate act to ruin the game or dump points. You are definitely entitled to foe / rank / think mean thoughts as a result of this, but I suspect this will be closed or noted

[Killerz999]

Sorry..
Maybe I didn't make myself clear.
He suicides on the person who ask HIM for the truce.
Player three had the clear advantage. Without a truce we would certainly lose the Game. So not only does he not want a truce, which of course is his right, he suicides on the person that ask for the truce with him. Making it a certainty the person who had the advantage wins the game.
Besides breaking the rule on suiciding it defies common sense.
He had eqaul chance if not better by working in concert with the player who had a significant advanatage.
So he also guarautees his own loss.

[Gillipig]

Sorry..
Maybe I didn't make myself clear.
He suicides on the person who ask HIM for the truce.
Player three had the clear advantage. Without a truce we would certainly lose the Game. So not only does he not want a truce, which of course is his right, he suicides on the person that ask for the truce with him. Making it a certainty the person who had the advantage wins the game.
Besides breaking the rule on suiciding it defies common sense.
He had eqaul chance if not better by working in concert with the player who had a significant advanatage.
So he also guarautees his own loss.

What an idiot ! Straight to the foe list for me.

[Symmetry]

Accused:
nicho74

The accused are suspected of:

Other: Purposely suiciding so another player will win.


Game Game 9960387

Comments: This player is under the impresion that in game truces are illegal.
After trying to negotiate one with him in a game we were clearly desitined to lose he took me out. He then referred me to his profile page where he states he will take people out for offering truces.
In chat I pointed out his misunderstanding, but disagress.

Here is his profile comment.

nicho74
Hi everyone, One thing: if you play with me in a single game and try to make a truce with any player; I'll quite this game. If you try to make a truce with me against another player, I'll attack you everyturn till one of us loose. Hope things are clear..... fair play is important! Let's play now by nicho74
on Tue Nov 16, 2010 2:59 pm
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

[Karl_R_Kroenen]

Nicho74 = NOTED

FAMO and rate accordingly