Page 1 of 1

mphil and Goofy75 SD?[cleared] KRK

PostPosted: Mon May 23, 2011 1:26 am
by lucbra
Accused:

mphil
Goofy75


The accused are suspected of:

Conducting Secret Diplomacy


Game number(s):

Game 9005710
Game 9005711


Comments:
Both player were from the start on merely attacking each other and picking on the other two. From the moment that I made a comment in one the games, their strategy changed for a couple of rounds.
In one of the games (9005710) it didn't make any sense to attack me. Attacking yellow (the leader of the game) or taking out green was the more logical choise. But in stead, blue (mphil) chose to attack me.
From my point of view it's obvious that there are other ways that mphil and Goofy75 are communicating.

Re: mphil and Goofy75 SD?

PostPosted: Mon May 23, 2011 2:54 am
by TheForgivenOne
lucbra wrote:Accused:

mphil
Goofy75


The accused are suspected of:

Conducting Secret Diplomacy


Game number(s):

Game 9005710
Game 9005711


Comments:
Both player were from the start on merely attacking each other and picking on the other two. From the moment that I made a comment in one the games, their strategy changed for a couple of rounds.
In one of the games (9005710) it didn't make any sense to attack me. Attacking yellow (the leader of the game) or taking out green was the more logical choise. But in stead, blue (mphil) chose to attack me.
From my point of view it's obvious that there are other ways that mphil and Goofy75 are communicating.


Fixed link

Re: mphil and Goofy75 SD?[pending] KRK

PostPosted: Sun May 29, 2011 9:08 am
by lucbra
This report can be closed, but one final remark: As a result of my posting in the C&A forum, I got a bad rating.

Re: mphil and Goofy75 SD?[pending] KRK

PostPosted: Wed Jun 01, 2011 9:26 pm
by Karl_R_Kroenen
lucbra wrote:This report can be closed, but one final remark: As a result of my posting in the C&A forum, I got a bad rating.


Looking at the logs and specifically BEFORE you said something in the game chat of Game 9005710, it looks like everyone was watching bonuses and territory count VERSUS attacking a specific player. There was one round where YELLOW got hammered and it looked GREEN was very dominant but then the other players were actively attacking. I am rather surprised that GREEN didn't win (territory count, bonus, carding), in this game.

Game 9005711, looks like there was active attacking not on one specific player, and right after your comment, YELLOW deadbeats.

CLEARED...