Conquer Club

Accused:

BroncoJordy


The accused are suspected of:

Other: Hello. This player left a bad rating for me when he meant to do it for someone else. No one even talked in this game and I actually played well and the game was peaceful. Can someone remove the rating he left? It's malicious and 100% not meant for me. Please take a look. Thanks for your help.

Game number(s):

Game 8877210

Comments:

Quint wrote:Accused:

BroncoJordy


The accused are suspected of:

Other: Hello. This player left a bad rating for me when he meant to do it for someone else. No one even talked in this game and I actually played well and the game was peaceful. Can someone remove the rating he left? It's malicious and 100% not meant for me. Please take a look. Thanks for your help.

Game number(s):

Game 8877210

Comments:

Ratings don't get removed by mods. you'll have to talk to him about why he left you those tags and that rating.

I just asked him why and he said he did it because I left a bad rating for someone he knew from a previous game! He said it had nothing to do with our game. This is nuts!

It's just one rating. 1 rating really doesn't affect your rating as a whole.

TheForgivenOne wrote:It's just one rating. 1 rating really doesn't affect your rating as a whole.

Seriously? That's how unethical members are handled who leave negative ratings for reasons outside of what they are intended for?

That's crap and as a paying contributor to this game, I'm disappointed and will not be paying again unless this is removed. It's the principle of the matter here, not the rating. If you let people play unethically, you ruin the spirit of the game. Please remove or I will not renew my membership. I assume you don't really care, but with any business, every penny counts.

Quint wrote:

TheForgivenOne wrote:It's just one rating. 1 rating really doesn't affect your rating as a whole.

Seriously? That's how unethical members are handled who leave negative ratings for reasons outside of what they are intended for?

That's crap and as a paying contributor to this game, I'm disappointed and will not be paying again unless this is removed. It's the principle of the matter here, not the rating. If you let people play unethically, you ruin the spirit of the game. Please remove or I will not renew my membership. I assume you don't really care, but with any business, every penny counts.

The ONLY way Multi hunters step in is when it is GROSS abuse, not 1 single case of a bad rating, but a user leaving bad after bad after bad rating of horrible ratings that make no sense. Imagine if EVERY single user, who ever got a bad rating, was to come in here and start creating reports claiming "OMG I DONT DESERVE THIS DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT". The C&A forum would be absolutely overrun with reports like that, which would cause their workload to increase exponentially.

No problem. I'm just not going to renew. No big deal.

Thanks.

Quint, unfortunately there isn't a way for the Moderators/Admins to change/alter/edit/erase what BroncoJordy rated you in your game play. That game was between you and him/her.

The best for you to do is to FOE and move on.

BroncoJordy warned for Ratings Abuse.

I understand and do appreciate the response. However it's not my fault you guys don't have the option to remove negative ratings. I will express my own disappointment in what I consider a disservice by not renewing. No big deal, thanks.

Guys correct me if I am wrong, but since you were able to get into contact with him, if you invite him to another game, play it out, he can give you a new (deserved) rating, overwriting his old rating?

Please look at all the ratings "Quint " has left for people he has played. They are all crap. Maybe Quint should look inward before he points the finger at me. I have left hundreds of ratings of 15 stars. Quint leaves only crap ratings. Care to explain QUINT?

Quint wrote:

TheForgivenOne wrote:It's just one rating. 1 rating really doesn't affect your rating as a whole.

Seriously? That's how unethical members are handled who leave negative ratings for reasons outside of what they are intended for?

That's crap and as a paying contributor to this game, I'm disappointed and will not be paying again unless this is removed. It's the principle of the matter here, not the rating. If you let people play unethically, you ruin the spirit of the game. Please remove or I will not renew my membership. I assume you don't really care, but with any business, every penny counts.

I checked this game 8472829 for the ratings you left. You said Andwyn was a deadbeat when he did not deadbeat out of the game. Maybe BroncoJordy has a case here.

Evil Semp wrote:

Quint wrote:

TheForgivenOne wrote:It's just one rating. 1 rating really doesn't affect your rating as a whole.

Seriously? That's how unethical members are handled who leave negative ratings for reasons outside of what they are intended for?

That's crap and as a paying contributor to this game, I'm disappointed and will not be paying again unless this is removed. It's the principle of the matter here, not the rating. If you let people play unethically, you ruin the spirit of the game. Please remove or I will not renew my membership. I assume you don't really care, but with any business, every penny counts.

I checked this game 8472829 for the ratings you left. You said Andwyn was a deadbeat when he did not deadbeat out of the game. Maybe BroncoJordy has a case here.

Uh, maybe you need to double check your facts. He DID deadbeat, cheated and used unethical tactics in that game. Ask the rest of the players and try following the turns. Not to mention, this thread is not about that, it's about a clear abuse of the system. If you have a problem with me, start a new thread. I consider this case closed. Nothing can be done and I'm not renewing. There you have it. Everyone is happy.

Quint wrote:

Evil Semp wrote:

Quint wrote:

TheForgivenOne wrote:It's just one rating. 1 rating really doesn't affect your rating as a whole.

Seriously? That's how unethical members are handled who leave negative ratings for reasons outside of what they are intended for?

That's crap and as a paying contributor to this game, I'm disappointed and will not be paying again unless this is removed. It's the principle of the matter here, not the rating. If you let people play unethically, you ruin the spirit of the game. Please remove or I will not renew my membership. I assume you don't really care, but with any business, every penny counts.

I checked this game 8472829 for the ratings you left. You said Andwyn was a deadbeat when he did not deadbeat out of the game. Maybe BroncoJordy has a case here.

Uh, maybe you need to double check your facts. He DID deadbeat, cheated and used unethical tactics in that game. Ask the rest of the players and try following the turns. Not to mention, this thread is not about that, it's about a clear abuse of the system. If you have a problem with me, start a new thread. I consider this case closed. Nothing can be done and I'm not renewing. There you have it. Everyone is happy.

Um, check again 2011-02-07 22:24:54 - Quint eliminated Andwyn from the game That means YOU eliminated him from the game. Deadbeating counts as missing 3 turns and being kicked out of the game. And you can't exactly say he missed turns on purpose. How do you know he simply forgot about the game? Getting a turn every 10-20 minutes, so they go to cook dinner or something, return and go "oh my, i have this game going".

I have him foed and can not read the actions between him and I to justify why I left him that rating. I assure you, I don't leave ratings without someone deserving it. Let me know how I can review that game and I will tell you exactly why I left that rating. If I'm wrong, I will remove the rating. However, this has NOTHING to do with this thread and the person in question. All I'm seeing now is mods derailing a thread, but whatever. It's cool guys, I'm done here.

Might I add, he earned that rating for several other actions, and not just the deadbeating. So you're really reaching here. The poor rating would have been given regardless of the deadbeat issue.

it would seem Quint also deserves a warning for ratings abuse.

So answer the question QUINT, why are ALL the ratings you leave CRAP? ALL 3 stars. You never leave a good rating. Why? Cuz u r a punk

BroncoJordy wrote:So answer the question QUINT, why are ALL the ratings you leave CRAP? ALL 3 stars. You never leave a good rating. Why? Cuz u r a punk

It does seem that there is one ratings abuser here, and it isn't BroncoJordy!