Conquer Club

Accused: cheesytime/bluebird1964

The accused are suspected of: Conducting Secret Diplomacy
Game number(s): 8726245

Comments: I am new to the game so am not positive this qualifies but appears likely it does unless we are charged with keeping track of postings on opponents walls during games.

Looking at wall chat of players found the following:

Cheesytime to Bluebird1964 at 1:16 pm, Thur Apr 21: "i reckon i wont attack at all in oz....u may wanna start heading up to s.afrika....i want greens out"

bluebird1964 to cheesytime at 8:01pm, Thur Apr 21: im with you cheesy, no probs" followed at 8:03pm with "as custer said to reno, you will be supported by thew whole brigade!"

cheesytime now accuses the two other players of cheating in the game chat.

jimsplace wrote:Accused:
cheesytime
bluebird1964

The accused are suspected of:
Conducting Secret Diplomacy


Game number(s): Game 8726245

Comments: I am new to the game so am not positive this qualifies but appears likely it does unless we are charged with keeping track of postings on opponents walls during games.

Looking at wall chat of players found the following:

Cheesytime to Bluebird1964 at 1:16 pm, Thur Apr 21: "i reckon i wont attack at all in oz....u may wanna start heading up to s.afrika....i want greens out"

bluebird1964 to cheesytime at 8:01pm, Thur Apr 21: im with you cheesy, no probs" followed at 8:03pm with "as custer said to reno, you will be supported by thew whole brigade!"

cheesytime now accuses the two other players of cheating in the game chat.

Fixed links

Sounds like sour grapes to me on Green's part!

bluebird1964 wrote:Sounds like sour grapes to me on Green's part!

You can consider it sour grapes but wall post discussing strategy are against the rules.

cheesytime and bluebird1964 have been WARNED for secret diplomacy.

HA! On what basis would you make such a comment?? Your wall chat is enough to raise suspicion.

I formaly appeal against this decision on the grounds that there was no "secret diplomacy".

Green is nothing more than a "tell-tale" tit

bluebird1964 wrote:I formaly appeal against this decision on the grounds that there was no "secret diplomacy".

Green is nothing more than a "tell-tale" tit

Any discussion OUTSIDE of game chat is secret diplomacy. Cheating.

and calling someone a "tit" is baiting.

Bye.

bluebird1964 wrote:I formaly appeal against this decision on the grounds that there was no "secret diplomacy".

Green is nothing more than a "tell-tale" tit

Try reading the rules once in a while.

The Rules wrote:Rule #2: No secret diplomacy

Any form of diplomatic discussion between opponents must be posted in the game chat in English or in a language that all opponents understand. Diplomacy includes, but is not limited to: proposing truces, negotiating alliances, and coordinating assaults.

Is it illegal to post suggestions for strategy in a game other than the one being talked about ?
In other words, if Bluebird asks me to " read his game chat in game# 12345 " in game 56789 is that illegal ?

If so, he is guilty of that also. If you want specific game#s I will provide them.

Watabastid wrote:Is it illegal to post suggestions for strategy in a game other than the one being talked about ?
In other words, if Bluebird asks me to " read his game chat in game# 12345 " in game 56789 is that illegal ?

If so, he is guilty of that also. If you want specific game#s I will provide them.

If all he is saying is "check the chat in game xxx" that is allowed.