Page 1 of 1

Team, Friend or Cheater ?[CLOSED]es

PostPosted: Thu Feb 17, 2011 5:41 am
by AslanTheKing
8463521
8463540
In both games i play with Jcm5613,
odd is
at moment he has around 20 games going on with Iceman2010,
all games are fog of war ???
8511407, 8511402, 8511401, 8511400, 8511399, 8511397, 8463540, 8463534, 8463531, 8463529

8463526, 8443351, 8443347, 8443346, 8443345, 8443344, 8443341, 8443340, 8443337, 8419204

I just would like to know if this is okay to play with a friend all games as fog of war,
and playing so many games together is on my mind unfair tactic,
maybe i am wrong,
if thats okay i should look for a friend too ;)
please let me know if that is cheating or fair for everybody to play this style
( i would be bored to play that way)
thx

Re: Team, Friend or Cheater ?

PostPosted: Thu Feb 17, 2011 5:50 am
by eddie2
AslanTheKing wrote:accused
Jcm5613
Iceman2010

charge
secret diplomacy


show: game nos.


comments
I just would like to know if this is okay to play with a friend all games as fog of war,
and playing so many games together is on my mind unfair tactic,
maybe i am wrong,
if thats okay i should look for a friend too ;)
please let me know if that is cheating or fair for everybody to play this style
( i would be bored to play that way)
thx

fixed

Re: Team, Friend or Cheater ?

PostPosted: Thu Feb 17, 2011 6:01 am
by AslanTheKing
do i have to post anything else, or what means fixed?

Re: Team, Friend or Cheater ?

PostPosted: Thu Feb 17, 2011 6:05 am
by JBlombier
It means you don't have to do anything else but wait, because eddie was so kind as to fix your initial post. He fixed it = insert links so the mods will have an easier time checking out your report. So now you can edit your second post to "Thanks eddie!" and just wait and see what the mods will say about your report.

Re: Team, Friend or Cheater ?

PostPosted: Thu Feb 17, 2011 7:52 am
by AslanTheKing
AslanTheKing wrote:do i have to post anything else, or what means fixed?

Thanks Eddie,
since i am new here, i probably have questions which others wouldnt have,
but i am learning, so i dont take anyones time, and as much i learn i will contribute to others in future, thx again.

Re: Team, Friend or Cheater ?

PostPosted: Thu Feb 17, 2011 11:48 am
by Evil Semp
I checked and they are not multi's.

If you want to make a secret diplomacy complaint I will need more than just the game numbers that they have played in. Give information on why you think there is secret diplomacy and give some detail to make it easier for me. After all you are in the game with them so you should be able to explain it.

If you are only asking if they can play that many games together, then the answer is yes. They can play as many games and setting that they want. As long as there isn't any proof of cheating then there are no problems.

Re: Team, Friend or Cheater ?[pending]es

PostPosted: Thu Feb 17, 2011 4:03 pm
by AslanTheKing
Since its Fog of War ;) i cant see anything,
but i am watching closely,
seems like one is taking europe,
the other one defending from asia, na,
thx for the info

Re: Team, Friend or Cheater ?[pending]es

PostPosted: Thu Feb 17, 2011 9:29 pm
by Evil Semp
I am going to mark this CLOSED.

Re: Team, Friend or Cheater ?[CLOSED]es

PostPosted: Fri Feb 18, 2011 5:12 am
by AslanTheKing
perfectly fine with me, i put those guys on the foelist,
the point i am making is very simple,
2 guys again 6,8 or 10, with simple strategy the advantage is big, they win eventually
or suicide in fovour for them selves, ....

just have a look at the scoreboard - i dont believe in coincidences,
No 5 is Kiron,4365- 353 games completed,167 won,
No 9 is xiangwang , games score 4147, games completed 114, 60 games won,

funny is

they played many times together, and in the chat , not in the forum here, there are accusations of foul play
for me case closed 2, sure someone will read in future and post their comments.

Re: Team, Friend or Cheater ?[CLOSED]es

PostPosted: Fri Feb 18, 2011 3:27 pm
by Evil Semp
AslanTheKing wrote:perfectly fine with me, i put those guys on the foelist,
the point i am making is very simple,
2 guys again 6,8 or 10, with simple strategy the advantage is big, they win eventually
or suicide in fovour for them selves, ....


You are making accusations with out providing any proof. Give me game numbers and other information.

AslanTheKing wrote:just have a look at the scoreboard - i dont believe in coincidences,


No body is asking you to believe in coincidences. I repeat myself, but give us something to go on besides the fact that they play games together.

AslanTheKing wrote:No 5 is Kiron,4365- 353 games completed,167 won,
No 9 is xiangwang , games score 4147, games completed 114, 60 games won,

funny is

they played many times together, and in the chat , not in the forum here, there are accusations of foul play
for me case closed 2, sure someone will read in future and post their comment


In my opinion posting in game chat doesn't mean anything when it comes to secret diplomacy. Some people do that to try to influence the others to attack some one else.

When you list the two players you did above with out any proof or evidence pointing to secret diplomacy, is that fair to them? What move in the game did they make that was done through secret diplomacy? FOG games make it even harder for us to see without pointing us in the right direction.