Conquer Club

The Accussed: Conquistadores



Accused of:
Ratings Abuse


Comments:
I was slow / silent / rude in this game Game 7454872 and was given all 1 / 5 stars for beating his quads team. I was NOT slow as this was a freestyle game, i do agree on being silent as NOTHING was said the whole game, not sure about the rude part, if rude is considered as beating his team then i guess... Anyways, i only played him once, and i looked into his ratings and he left ratings like this for 39 people he played against out of 74 people that he rated. That is kind of extreme considering lots of the people he left ratings for like this are decent players, and should never be rated 1 stars

I say CC removes all his ratings he left for those 39 and give him a warning.

-griff

Honestly, nothing will be done because it's a rating report. I think CC should just go back to the rating system it used to have, negative and positive comments about players.

You're not gonna get far with a ratings abuse report. I suggest just PMing Conquistadores to see what his reasoning behind the rating was.

Victor Sullivan wrote:You're not gonna get far with a ratings abuse report. I suggest just PMing Conquistadores to see what his reasoning behind the rating was.

murphy16 wrote:Honestly, nothing will be done because it's a rating report. I think CC should just go back to the rating system it used to have, negative and positive comments about players.

This was his reasoning behind giving me all 1's

by Conquistadores on Mon Oct 25, 2010 2:45 pm - lol dude you can complain, thats when i started, i gave 1's to everyone so (: you can live through it

So why is it fair for someone to give ones to "everyone" when they start and get away with it? this is rating abuse, is there no penalty or punishment for this? the least CC could do is take his ratings he gave to other people away because he rated about 50% of people like this. Anyways he didn't have another excuse besides that and he said my team not talking was "rude" but his team didn't talk either so what the heck? It was a fs quads game, if your gonna rate people like this then don't rate at all! He won't delete the ratings he left for other people even tho i explained to him how easy it was... click "My ratings" on the side panel, click "Ratings left" tab at the top, and click "Withdraw" on the side of that rating... he just had some lame excuse and wouldn't do it.

-griff

Nope really, no punishment just warnings. I think.

grifftron wrote:

Victor Sullivan wrote:You're not gonna get far with a ratings abuse report. I suggest just PMing Conquistadores to see what his reasoning behind the rating was.

murphy16 wrote:Honestly, nothing will be done because it's a rating report. I think CC should just go back to the rating system it used to have, negative and positive comments about players.

This was his reasoning behind giving me all 1's

by Conquistadores on Mon Oct 25, 2010 2:45 pm - lol dude you can complain, thats when i started, i gave 1's to everyone so (: you can live through it

Sounds like maybe he starts everyone off at ones and gives them stars for good conduct? I mean, no one said anything in the game chat, so it seems reasonable. Does Conquistadores know about this thread? He should.

Yes he does. And no that is the stupidest thing i have ever heard in my life

Victor Sullivan wrote:

grifftron wrote:

Victor Sullivan wrote:Sounds like maybe he starts everyone off at ones and gives them stars for good conduct? I mean, no one said anything in the game chat, so it seems reasonable.

If it was reasonable he would have given my whole team 1 stars! he only rated me out of the 4 of us, and none of us said anything, and no one on his team said anything... vic just drop it bro, he gave a bs rating to me and half of the others he rated, there is no good reason for what he did.

dude the first thing is that you didnt talk not even when we said gl, that is rude. Secondly the manners you are talking to me wont change my mind. i agreed to take out the rating, but for being just so annoying and so rude i wont, if you want complain. your manners where harsh, hence i am alloud to give a rating to that

Conquistadores wrote:dude the first thing is that you didnt talk not even when we said gl, that is rude. Secondly the manners you are talking to me wont change my mind. i agreed to take out the rating, but for being just so annoying and so rude i wont, if you want complain. your manners where harsh, hence i am alloud to give a rating to that

Nice try buddy Game 7454872

Firstly! You guys never said gl at all, look at the game chat. Secondly! what manners? what are you talking about? You make no sense at all? You did NOT agree to take out any rating, your excuse is on my wall man, "how do you do it?" "I don't know how to take it away, i can't find it" blah blah blah. You are allowed not "alloud" to give any kind of rating you want to people that FIRST beat you in a game SECOND don't say anything all game (while your team says nothing all game)? Think again buddy, if your rating was like this for only me i wouldn't have posted anything, but i looked at your ratings and seen you have been doing this for tons of people like i said above, i have another player that gave me all 1's but when i looked at his ratings it was only me NOT 50% of the people on his ratings left list, so i left him alone, PLUS we actually did communicate in THAT game, so his rating made sense, yours does not.

I will never play you again. I just hope CC doesn't let you continue to give bs ratings

-griff

griff, I don't think a 4.8 is anything to scoff at... I wouldn't get upset about 1 rating, even if it was unjust (which I don't really think it was, I'm afraid).

Victor Sullivan wrote:griff, I don't think a 4.8 is anything to scoff at... I wouldn't get upset about 1 rating, even if it was unjust (which I don't really think it was, I'm afraid).

So its OK to abuse the rating system is what your trying to say? If this guy gets away with this, then the rating system needs to be changed again. Tell me sully, how can this guy give me ALL 1's even in gameplay after my team beat his team on monsters? how is this justified, because if my gameplay was "horrible" which is what the 1 star is, how did i beat his team? explain please. And how does he justify giving me a 1 star for being rude when he didn't say anything at all in the game, no one did except for 1 gg at the end which was not from him, explain this to me big guy.

-griff

grifftron wrote:

Victor Sullivan wrote:griff, I don't think a 4.8 is anything to scoff at... I wouldn't get upset about 1 rating, even if it was unjust (which I don't really think it was, I'm afraid).

So its OK to abuse the rating system is what your trying to say? If this guy gets away with this, then the rating system needs to be changed again. Tell me sully, how can this guy give me ALL 1's even in gameplay after my team beat his team on monsters? how is this justified, because if my gameplay was "horrible" which is what the 1 star is, how did i beat his team? explain please. And how does he justify giving me a 1 star for being rude when he didn't say anything at all in the game, no one did except for 1 gg at the end which was not from him, explain this to me big guy.

-griff

Conquistadores wrote:dude the first thing is that you didnt talk. Secondly the manners you are talking to me wont change my mind. i agreed to take out the rating, but for being just so annoying and so rude i wont, if you want complain. your manners where harsh, hence i am alloud to give a rating to that

I think those are well enough reasons.

any ruling mods?

Well, the way I see it.. The reason none of your teammates got a bad rating is because two of them are CC staff or volunteers. Not sure why the fourth didn't get a bad rating though. lol

well i think he does do something like that
i dont know if this will help but this is what he sent to me and someone can come onto my account to see if this is true.
this is our converstation



* Quote Conquistadores

Re: sdgfs

Sent: Tue Nov 02, 2010 3:01 pm
by Conquistadores
and?? prob you gave me a bad rating and still you foed me for no reason

* Quote 40kguy

Re: sdgfs

Sent: Tue Nov 02, 2010 3:00 pm
by 40kguy
i unfoed you.

* Quote Conquistadores

Re: sdgfs

Sent: Tue Nov 02, 2010 2:58 pm
by Conquistadores
you foed me first, and for winning so nop

* Quote 40kguy

sdgfs

Sent: Tue Nov 02, 2010 2:57 pm
by 40kguy
Unfoe me

Conquistadores has already been warned.

king achilles wrote:Conquistadores has already been warned.

Thanks ka. thats all i was looking for, that and having my ratings he gave me removed which i know wont happen, but a warning is OK.

-griff