Conquer Club

Accused:

Oleg of Novgorod

The accused are suspected of:

Other: Ratings abuse for game 6945537

Every game he loses he complains in game chat about the strategy of the other players. The players did not use cheap tactics and were very polite. This is a violating of what ratings are suppose to be fore. I for one demand the ratings for my game are removed, or at the very least review by an admin and changed. No one likes losing, but lose with some dignity sir.

Game number(s):

Game 6945537
Game 6948185
Game 6936785




Comments: I would also like the rating given by myself to be changed as well to reflect a 0 on this persons attitude.

ratings cant be retracted nor changed by admin.

If you do not like your rating that you left for him then you can withdraw it, and you can respond to his rating that he left for you.

This is pending.

KS

It's clear by the rating he has left he is abusing them. This is abuse. It is an innaccurate rating, and victims of the abuse should have greater ability to prevent or remove ratings given by those who are flagrantly breaking the rules.

i wouldnt say flagrant breaking of rules...no making a multi that is a fragant breaking of the rules..

Lawag wrote:It's clear by the rating he has left he is abusing them. This is abuse. It is an innaccurate rating, and victims of the abuse should have greater ability to prevent or remove ratings given by those who are flagrantly breaking the rules.

ok lawag reading the game chat it is obvious


he was disgruntled with both of your play also for ratings abuse there has gotta be uneven ratings where they are mostly bad 1 stars etc across the board this is not the case with this one i have looked at his ratings page and they are all mixed.

but agreed some of the latest ones are bad might of been having a bad day but he has only left 28 ratings altogether so i dont think the mods will have enough to work with considering half of them are good. i think you will get a famo and noted from ks. unless lv has somthing else lined up.

ill let ks deal with it....i have the assist though

I got a rabbit I'm pulling out of my hat but due to the response this will get I'm quadruple checking this with others...

stand by

I learned from my jefjef mistake.. gotta put the trigger finger away until its absolutely certain

Hmmm...

Game 6936785

2010-05-06 17:51:54 - Oleg of Novgorod: trust me. I
2010-05-06 17:52:06 - Oleg of Novgorod: ve played 2000 plus games here
2010-05-06 17:52:13 - Oleg of Novgorod: he blew it by missing

Yet it looks like this player just joined a few days ago and has opened 32 games. Multi as well perhaps?

As for the ratings, it seems to me like he´s just hard headed, there´s 39 ratings and only 11 with all 1-stars, it´s true he lost those games, and if one player made him lose and the other took the game, giving them both 1 star ratings doesn´t make much sense, he may just need a bit of a warning to let him know leaving 1 star ratings to players that played well may get him a temporary block on giving ratings. If he REALLY is new to the site and only joined recently, that should do. If the comment I found and posted above shows he´s someone´s multi, I guess he should be busted for that.

lol... i found the same comment gundiesalvo.. good eye..

decision will be made soon

aw i missed that one i was looking at ratings

Lol, what a joke.

Lawag wrote:Lol, what a joke.

sorry was getting everyone's opinions on this case.

Oleg of Novgorod Busted with 1 other account.
Lawag Busted with 2 other accounts.

Good Day.

KS

What happens for Ratings abuse anyways? And is this not a persons own opinion and therefore pretty vague?

Prankcall wrote:What happens for Ratings abuse anyways? And is this not a persons own opinion and therefore pretty vague?

A rating is an opinion, but it must have some sort of reasoning behind it or everyone could abuse the system and rate poorly or generously with no care in the world and the system would be an inaccurate assessment.

If someone is suspected over ratings abuse, meaning they have inaccurately rated and tagged players unjustly over a period of time (not just a few games) then you report it here.

We then research the claim. Go in and look at the tags and ratings the offender has left and see if there is any reason at all that could garnish that player for feeling that way. We dont take sides. If there is a dispute in chat and the player leaves a tag or a rating because of that dispute then they very well could have had a just cause for feeling that way and therefor are not in violation given that instance.

Now if it is the opposite, if we find players just leaving untrue tags and unjust ratings because of revenge or what have you then they are found to be violating the rating guidelines and they are punished as per the guidelines. Which is 1st a Warning and then if it continues they start to receive vacations from Ratings until their privileges to Rate are revoked completely.

This account was remotely investigated for Ratings, but it was evident to us that it looked to be a multiple account, and with the additional accounts on multiple accounts getting suspended it made no sense to go down the Ratings Road as this account will be Guested and no longer a member on the site.

KS

lol lv told you that one yesterday lawag was a multi before this thread was started can i have the catch please will bring me up to 4

You've got 2 options. You can restore premium access to one of my accounts. Or you can refund the payments on the three accounts. and I assure you I will be getting my money back if you choose not to do option B.

Lawag wrote:You've got 2 options. You can restore premium access to one of my accounts. Or you can refund the payments on the three accounts. and I assure you I will be getting my money back if you choose not to do option B.

Omission of Guilt right there.

At Conquer Club you are allowed to have 1 account and 1 account only. Violation of this rule will result in the suspension of the account and/or loss of premium status.

Everyone checks a box acknowledging this upon succession of an account on here.

If you wish to take this up further please submit an E-Ticket, which is the correct channel for this.

LOCKED
KS