Conquer Club

Accused:
alstergren

The accused are suspected of:
Rating Abuse



Game number(s):

6218356
6295633
6266489
6270324
6215381


Comments:
alstergren either rates people 5 stars or 1 star not anything between, and your supposed to rate them honestly and fairly wich he does neither! Im positive everyone he plays get mad at him to because of the responses on his ratings. Im just doing my part to make Conquer Club fair and fun. So somebody do something about this player a warning a vacation anything will make me happy!

c-rod91339 wrote:Accused:
alstergren

The accused are suspected of:
Rating Abuse



Game number(s):

Game 6218356
Game 6295633
Game 6266489
Game 6270324
Game 6215381


Comments:
http://www.conquerclub.com/player.php?mode=ratings2&username=alstergren&page=1
alstergren either rates people 5 stars or 1 star not anything between, and your supposed to rate them honestly and fairly wich he does neither! Im positive everyone he plays get mad at him to because of the responses on his ratings. Im just doing my part to make Conquer Club fair and fun. So somebody do something about this player a warning a vacation anything will make me happy!

Fixed links.

Thanks jefjef i forgot do do that sorry yall

Of the 1st 5 1 star ratings alster lost to 4 of them and even vindictively tagged some of em.

This abuse complaint is absolutely valid.

Thanks for judging this jefjef

Apparently 1's and 5's are abuse, as was determined recently.

http://www.conquerclub.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=239&t=106692

anothe person on my side yay hahaha

c-rod91339 wrote:anothe person on my side yay hahaha

Buuuuuuut, looking through his ratings, he doesn't give all 1's and 5's. He has many other ratings as well, with very few all 1's.

So this seems to me like a spurious vindictive report....


best course of action is to

FAMO!

ummm ok.... I do not no what to say!!!

c-rod91339 wrote:ummm ok.... I do not no what to say!!!

Maybe "Sorry" and retract this report. Mods don't look kindly on random reports with no merit...

i think i will be fine i can handle myself

Snowgun wrote:

c-rod91339 wrote:ummm ok.... I do not no what to say!!!

Maybe "Sorry" and retract this report. Mods don't look kindly on random reports with no merit...

Ah but there actually is merit to this. Vindictive tags are an abuse too snowboy.

And there are so few of anything except for 1's or 5's it is an abuse. But seeing how it's Alster I spose this complaints result will be NOTED.

The last time this was brought up, it wasn't taken very seriously, not only by the mods, but by yourself as well, jefjef:

viewtopic.php?f=239&t=103228&start=0

I get the feeling that last time everyone simply judged the poster instantly and didn't even take the time to consider the complaint was totally valid.

jefjef wrote:

Snowgun wrote:

c-rod91339 wrote:ummm ok.... I do not no what to say!!!

Maybe "Sorry" and retract this report. Mods don't look kindly on random reports with no merit...

Ah but there actually is merit to this. Vindictive tags are an abuse too snowboy.

And there are so few of anything except for 1's or 5's it is an abuse. But seeing how it's Alster I spose this complaints result will be NOTED.

Meh, I dont' know Jeffypoo. There are plenty of combo stars. and it's not like you CANT give someone an all 1's rating....

Definitely not enough here to warrent "abuse" or everyone is suspect. Is this going to be the rise of the "Ratings Nazis"? Everyone and their dog is going to make a report now....

P.S.

Let me show you what ratings abuse really looks like kiddies:

http://www.conquerclub.com/player.php?mode=ratings2&username=policeboy&page=1

LOL. Just saw this, I refer to my previous post, see:
http://www.conquerclub.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=239&t=103228&start=0#p2336118

I usually have around 75-100 games going at all times, I rate far from everyone (in fact, I find it very annoying when people in an anal manner dishes out ratings to the left and right) and I prefer to give out all 5's. When slapping on lower ratings, I assume that there's a (game related or assumed rule violation related) reason or two for that. If any individual feels that any rating is inaccurate, unfair or clearly is a mistake (it could very well happen since I see that I handed out >1,500 ratings), they should drop me a pm. Those I respond to and look into, I don't look into anything so frivolous and general as this report.

An example: 6295633 flirk. 1 star. Tagged Sore loser, clueless, poor strategy. HE WON. 4 of the 1st 5 1 star ratings beat you.

I'm not gonna bother hitting all of em but I sure recall your admitted vindictive rating in re of colton24.

This is not going to look good on your mod application. Though this does not qualify as severe ratings abuse it surely deserves to be noted.

oh and snow dude im not retracting this soo ha

jefjef wrote:An example: 6295633 flirk. 1 star. Tagged Sore loser, clueless, poor strategy. HE WON. 4 of the 1st 5 1 star ratings beat you.

I'm not gonna bother hitting all of em but I sure recall your admitted vindictive rating in re of colton24.

Jez... kid, you're a pain in the ass.

1. Have not bothered to check, but I'm sure there's a reason or two for that particular rating. Ratings are individual and I have yet to see when stand-alone ratings are subject to any C&A-rules. Typically rating abuse involves systematically handing down bad ratings (and I doubt there's any systematic bad ratings on my part for people who beat me, if there would, well, there would be plenty of more bad ratings out there).

2. Don't recall having made any statements re colton24, but please enlighten me with a link to that and a link to this colton24 rating of mine. If it's there, I hope it's a bad one, I recall he went on some stupid deadbeating streak or something.

ur making yourself look bad snow i believe what bout you jef???

c-rod91339 wrote:ur making yourself look bad snow i believe what bout you jef???

What are you trying to do? Bait me into some sort of flame war? Drag Jef into it? You must be new here. My best advice is to pipe down and let this run it's course. The more you post like this the worse you look.

im not flaming just simply suggesting... also im not bribing jefjef in anyway. im not new here... happy?

jez. you sure are arrogant for a pimply faced boy.
by jefjef
on Thu Jan 28, 2010 6:46 pm

Sigh... jefjef... cut the crap wall comments (and consider this a C&A report vis-a-vis jefjef).

I will ask this. Did you PM asltergren prior to posting your abuse post, and ask why he rated you like he did? If so what was the response? If not, if it was a concern to you, i have seen in the past most players on here would try and make the effort to do so if it was such and issue. Granted I understand your issue towards ratings, I also have issues and have made it clear on my wall as well as my main profile on what my issue is, therefore most will know why they got a rate in which i give. I would suggest if an issue comes up on why a player rated yourself a certain way, you Pm them and ask why. Alstergren has stated why he makes certain rates. But I do not see where he posted why he made such a rate on you and I would like to know the reason why? After I recieve all info needed a ruleing will be made at that time.

Eye84free

alstergren wrote:Jez... kid, you're a pain in the ass.

jez... Alster,

Should this be considered a flame and a bait too?

Foe button is on the right.