imacamper wrote:Accused:
mrjinximacamperThe accused are suspected of:
Conducting Secret Diplomacy
Game number(s):
Game 6219382Comments:
This was originally reported in this thread:
viewtopic.php?f=239&t=106533Per the complaint guide, threads will not be locked until after case is closed and no comments are received for 5 days. However in this case, the thread was locked before Jan 26 less than a day after decision and certainly 5 days without comments had not passed. Thus I've been forced to create a new thread in which to post my rebuttal. I have also filed an eticket (
http://www.conquerclub.com/eticket/view ... &id=218416)
I have no relationship with mrjinx beyond the games we have play together here. We haven't even spoken beyond the public game chat and at that, I'm not sure we've ever communicated.
Also in regard to the comment about playing lots of games with mrjinx, I only do that as I prefer to play classic, flat rate, & no fog of war. Almost every time I search for that type of game, mrjinx has one waiting for players. Instead of creating a new game, I just join his. In fact, I think you'll see that I rarely create a game and only do so when there is not one awaiting players.
I would have thought CC would appreciate me joining games as opposed to creating new ones. I would have never thought that it would be used to support a cheating accusation.
I must say I am very offended at this accusation and even more offended at CC's decision. Your own hunter even says there is no proof (
viewtopic.php?f=239&t=106533#p2418758) yet blocks us? Is it CC's policy to convict without proof, especially when one (mrjinx) is a premium member? Now I am even more disappointed. I have been very close to upgrading to premium as I have enjoyed my games on this site. But if this is the way one is treated only because one whiner didn't like the outcome of one game, then I am glad I have not supported this site.
I truly hope this decision is just an error by one hunter and not reflective of CC's policy.
-Very often there is no proof.
-He admitted it was a judgement call, and a tough one...but the record was suspicious.
-You were convicted of nothing.
-You were only blocked from playing with that player, because for whatever reason, favoritism seemed to be happening.
-Blocks are common in this situation, and when two players play a lot of games together, they have to be very careful to actively make the games fair, otherwise this can happen...even in cases when there may be no intended cheating.
-the block however is still justified though, because the record, warrants it..and is just put in place to be safe.
-Everyone acknowledges that it could have been coincidental, but now no one has to worry about an unfair game with you too.
-You are taking it far too personally. You were not busted, you were blocked, and barely blocked....If you just accept that and move on, everyone will forget about it, and no one will ever care. If you need to play with jinx that much...well...thats just odd.
-Move on, seriously...trust me. You and everyone else in CC will forget about this. People have done far worse and no one really cares.
But if jinx keeps breaking the rules, it shows he has no respect for them, and it shows he is quite capable of cheating. Had you too graciously just accepted the simple block and said...well, we understand it looked suspicious, we werent cheating, but respect the mods decision....everyone would have believed you good guys, and probably less capable of cheating. Semp of all people does not act without serious consideration, and in my opinion, may very well be the most fair hunter there ever was....because he resists busting unless he has to. Most of his early days on the forum were spend defending unfairly accused players. Ill assume thats why he is now on Team CC. Read what he wrote carefully... he did block you...but very much gives you the benefit of the doubt. We all read that, and any who know anything understand that you very well may have just been in the wrong place at the wrong time.
You dont have to accept that you were cheating, only that your record was suspicious.
This is all, very good advice.
