NotFranklin & Round_earth[noted]

[brianfast]

Accused:

Round_Earth
NotFranklin

The accused are suspected of:

Conducting Secret Diplomacy

Game number(s):

Game 5815426

Comments:

These guys obviously ganged up on me with secret diplomacy, I was winning the game, then they probably decided to not attack each other and only attack me. The whole game, Round_earth had 9's next to NotFranklin's 1's with the possiblility of gaining a big bonus/taking away a big bonus if he attacked his neighbor, but never did. All this while they both only attacked me. I'm not 1005 sure they are colluding but it looks awfully close...

2009-10-26 17:02:34 - NotFranklin received 5 troops for holding Mahgreb
2009-10-26 17:02:34 - NotFranklin received 9 troops for 27 regions
2009-10-26 17:04:02 - NotFranklin deployed 14 troops on Hawaii
2009-10-26 17:04:06 - NotFranklin assaulted Mexico from Hawaii and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:04:16 - NotFranklin assaulted Southern USA from Mexico and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:04:28 - NotFranklin assaulted Cuba from Mexico and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:04:38 - NotFranklin assaulted Guatemala from Mexico and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:04:44 - NotFranklin assaulted Panama from Guatemala and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:04:49 - NotFranklin assaulted Colombia from Panama and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:05:03 - NotFranklin assaulted China from Mongolia and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:05:19 - NotFranklin assaulted Turkmenistan from China and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:05:45 - NotFranklin assaulted Pakistan from Turkmenistan and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:06:40 - NotFranklin reinforced Guineas with 5 troops from Morocco
2009-10-26 17:07:30 - NotFranklin ended the turn
2009-10-26 17:07:51 - Round_Earth received 4 troops for holding Southern Africa
2009-10-26 17:07:51 - Round_Earth received 3 troops for holding The Horn
2009-10-26 17:07:51 - Round_Earth received 10 troops for 30 regions
2009-10-26 17:08:25 - Round_Earth deployed 3 troops on East Australia
2009-10-26 17:10:21 - Round_Earth deployed 10 troops on Somalia
2009-10-26 17:10:58 - Round_Earth deployed 4 troops on Moskva
2009-10-26 17:11:07 - Round_Earth assaulted Turkey from Moskva and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:11:17 - Round_Earth assaulted Iran from Turkey and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:11:28 - Round_Earth assaulted Yemen from Somalia and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:11:33 - Round_Earth assaulted Oman from Yemen and conquered it from neutral player
2009-10-26 17:11:45 - Round_Earth assaulted Saudi from Yemen and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:12:00 - Round_Earth assaulted Iraq from Saudi and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:12:14 - Round_Earth assaulted Levant from Iraq and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:13:04 - Round_Earth reinforced Levant with 3 troops from Sudan
2009-10-26 17:13:25 - Round_Earth reinforced Turkey with 3 troops from Sudan
2009-10-26 17:13:41 - Round_Earth reinforced Iran with 3 troops from Iraq
2009-10-26 17:14:55 - Round_Earth ended the turn
2009-10-26 17:14:55 - Incrementing game to round 5
2009-10-26 17:18:34 - brianfast received 4 troops for holding Canada
2009-10-26 17:18:34 - brianfast received 3 troops for holding La Plata
2009-10-26 17:18:34 - brianfast received 13 troops for 39 regions
2009-10-26 17:21:42 - brianfast deployed 3 troops on New England
2009-10-26 17:22:31 - brianfast deployed 17 troops on Ecuador
2009-10-26 17:22:37 - brianfast assaulted Colombia from Ecuador and conquered it from NotFranklin
2009-10-26 17:22:40 - brianfast assaulted Panama from Colombia and conquered it from NotFranklin
2009-10-26 17:22:44 - brianfast assaulted Guatemala from Panama and conquered it from NotFranklin
2009-10-26 17:22:51 - brianfast assaulted Mexico from Guatemala and conquered it from NotFranklin
2009-10-26 17:23:02 - brianfast assaulted Southern USA from New England and conquered it from NotFranklin
2009-10-26 17:23:14 - brianfast assaulted Cuba from Mexico and conquered it from NotFranklin
2009-10-26 17:23:32 - brianfast assaulted Hawaii from Mexico and conquered it from NotFranklin
2009-10-26 17:23:47 - brianfast assaulted Taiwan from Hawaii and conquered it from NotFranklin
2009-10-26 17:25:21 - brianfast reinforced British Claim with 2 troops from New England
2009-10-26 17:26:16 - brianfast ended the turn
2009-10-26 17:28:48 - NotFranklin received 5 troops for holding Mahgreb
2009-10-26 17:28:48 - NotFranklin received 9 troops for 28 regions
2009-10-26 17:28:54 - NotFranklin deployed 14 troops on Guineas
2009-10-26 17:29:37 - NotFranklin assaulted North East Brazil from Guineas and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:31:17 - NotFranklin assaulted Parana from North East Brazil and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:31:37 - NotFranklin assaulted Uruguay from Parana and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:31:47 - NotFranklin assaulted Argentina from Uruguay and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:31:56 - NotFranklin assaulted Paraguay from Argentina and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:32:11 - NotFranklin assaulted Tierra del Fuego from Argentina and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:32:36 - NotFranklin assaulted Chile from Argentina and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:32:45 - NotFranklin assaulted Bolivia from Chile and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:33:29 - NotFranklin assaulted Amazonas from Bolivia and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:35:29 - NotFranklin ended the turn
2009-10-26 17:35:36 - Round_Earth received 4 troops for holding Southern Africa
2009-10-26 17:35:36 - Round_Earth received 3 troops for holding The Horn
2009-10-26 17:35:36 - Round_Earth received 4 troops for holding Middle East
2009-10-26 17:35:36 - Round_Earth received 12 troops for 37 regions
2009-10-26 17:36:05 - Round_Earth deployed 23 troops on France
2009-10-26 17:36:09 - Round_Earth assaulted British Isles from France and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:36:17 - Round_Earth assaulted Iceland from British Isles and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:36:22 - Round_Earth assaulted Greenland from Iceland and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:36:31 - Round_Earth assaulted Lower Canada from Greenland and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:36:35 - Round_Earth assaulted New England from Lower Canada and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:37:06 - Round_Earth assaulted Southern USA from New England and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:37:11 - Round_Earth assaulted Mexico from Southern USA and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-26 17:37:57 - Round_Earth ended the turn

[Evil Semp]

It is hard to prove secret diplomacy. In 3 player games sometimes like you stated the strongest becomes the target and the attacks can seem to be one sided. AS for the 9's with the 1 borders next to them players decide what is in their own best interest when it comes to attacking.

This report is noted for future reference.

[brianfast]

Ok these guys convinced me to play them again, and what happens? Total obvious collusion:

http://www.conquerclub.com/game.php?game=5844985

2009-10-30 21:01:29 - Round_Earth received 3 troops for 1 regions
2009-10-30 21:01:34 - Round_Earth cashed in a group of Wan Chi, Tai Mo Shan, and Cheung Kang worth 4 troops
2009-10-30 21:01:37 - Round_Earth deployed 7 troops on Shum Cheng
2009-10-30 21:01:41 - Round_Earth assaulted Tsing Yi from Shum Cheng and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-30 21:01:46 - Round_Earth assaulted Sunny Bay from Tsing Yi and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-30 21:01:49 - Round_Earth assaulted Tung Chung from Sunny Bay and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-30 21:01:54 - Round_Earth assaulted Chep Lap Kok from Tung Chung and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-30 21:02:00 - Round_Earth assaulted Shek Pik from Chep Lap Kok and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-30 21:02:04 - Round_Earth ended the turn and got spoils
2009-10-30 21:02:10 - NotFranklin received 4 troops for holding Plover Cove
2009-10-30 21:02:10 - NotFranklin received 9 troops for 27 regions
2009-10-30 21:02:37 - NotFranklin cashed in a group of Tai Po, Po Lam, and Fan Ling worth 6 troops
2009-10-30 21:02:37 - NotFranklin got bonus of 2 troops added to Tai Po
2009-10-30 21:02:37 - NotFranklin got bonus of 2 troops added to Fan Ling
2009-10-30 21:02:58 - NotFranklin deployed 5 troops on Tai Lam Chung
2009-10-30 21:03:03 - NotFranklin deployed 14 troops on Clearwater Bay
2009-10-30 21:03:04 - NotFranklin assaulted Po Lam from Clearwater Bay and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-30 21:03:06 - NotFranklin assaulted Kwun Tong from Po Lam and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-30 21:03:09 - NotFranklin assaulted Chai Wan from Kwun Tong and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-30 21:03:12 - NotFranklin assaulted Chek Chue from Chai Wan and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-30 21:03:18 - NotFranklin assaulted Wan Chi from Chek Chue and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-30 21:03:24 - NotFranklin assaulted Aberdeen from Wan Chi and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-30 21:03:31 - NotFranklin assaulted Victoria from Yau Tsim Mong and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-30 21:03:36 - NotFranklin assaulted Lamma Island from Aberdeen and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-30 21:04:12 - NotFranklin assaulted Tuen Mun from Tai Lam Chung and conquered it from brianfast
2009-10-30 21:04:12 - NotFranklin eliminated brianfast from the game
2009-10-30 21:04:27 - NotFranklin cashed in a group of Shek Pik, Sha Tau Kok, and Sham Shui worth 8 troops
2009-10-30 21:04:27 - NotFranklin got bonus of 2 troops added to Sha Tau Kok
2009-10-30 21:04:27 - NotFranklin got bonus of 2 troops added to Sham Shui
2009-10-30 21:04:37 - NotFranklin deployed 8 troops on Kwai Tsing
2009-10-30 21:04:38 - NotFranklin assaulted Tsing Yi from Kwai Tsing and conquered it from Round_Earth
2009-10-30 21:04:45 - NotFranklin assaulted Sunny Bay from Tsing Yi and conquered it from Round_Earth
2009-10-30 21:04:49 - NotFranklin assaulted Tung Chung from Sunny Bay and conquered it from Round_Earth
2009-10-30 21:04:52 - NotFranklin assaulted Chep Lap Kok from Tung Chung and conquered it from Round_Earth
2009-10-30 21:04:58 - NotFranklin assaulted Shek Pik from Tung Chung and conquered it from Round_Earth
2009-10-30 21:05:00 - NotFranklin assaulted Shum Cheng from Tai Lam Chung and conquered it from Round_Earth
2009-10-30 21:05:00 - NotFranklin eliminated Round_Earth from the game
2009-10-30 21:05:00 - NotFranklin won the game
2009-10-30 21:05:00 - Round_Earth lost 20 points
2009-10-30 21:05:00 - brianfast lost 23 points
2009-10-30 21:05:00 - NotFranklin gained 43 points

This move by Round_earth is completely irrational and completely threw the game to NotFranklin