KOTARO [closed]

[MrPanzerGeneral]

Accused:

kotaro


The accused are suspected of:

Forum Abuse / Flame Baiting / Trolling

viewtopic.php?f=6&t=97735&p=2230940#p2230940



Comments: as per CC's Forum Guidlines Kotaro's posts rate as Flaming, Trolling. Some consistency in rulings would be excellent.

[Kotaro]

All caps means you're yelling.

Be sure before you accuse someone!
</DELETE ME>

That "delete me" part? You're supposed to delete it.

[Kotaro]

As per community guidelines :

If a player's comments do not violate the rules posted below, then do not ask a moderator or administrator to intervene when a player annoys you. This includes curse words and foul language. They are allowed on this site and would be too difficult to moderate every one.

[BoganGod]

Curse words are allowed, but flaming is not. You clearly called JefJef an arsehole, and suggested that people that play with him are going to get shat on. That does cross the line a bit kottie, I know your probably just upset that you haven't had a recent vacation. You were definately trolling. It was not constructive or on topic about a points neutral option.

[Kotaro]

It doesn't really cross the line, as me saying that he will eventually be site banned is just me prophesying based on current events of King Sam just banned him from the website.

And not constructive or on topic? Mentioning that this has happened before and no fix's were offered is very much so on topic. And as for constructive, warning people away from someone who is going to be getting site banned eventually for being almost EXACTLY like a currently website banned player is quite constructive - I know I won't be losing my points because of him.

Oh and, I love how you would normally not even post, but since he's your clanmate, you defend him. And I love also how you troll about my vacations, which my previous vacations have nothing to do with this topic, nor does the fact that I haven't had one add constructive anything to this topic. A troll knows a troll.

Oh, and I've asked you before not to call me Kottie, and you knew it would warrant a response - I guess common courtesy does not apply when your clanmates had his little feelings hurt, eh?

[BoganGod]

It doesn't really cross the line, as me saying that he will eventually be site banned is just me prophesying based on current events of King Sam just banned him from the website.

And not constructive or on topic? Mentioning that this has happened before and no fix's were offered is very much so on topic. And as for constructive, warning people away from someone who is going to be getting site banned eventually for being almost EXACTLY like a currently website banned player is quite constructive - I know I won't be losing my points because of him.

Oh and, I love how you would normally not even post, but since he's your clanmate, you defend him. And I love also how you troll about my vacations, which my previous vacations have nothing to do with this topic, nor does the fact that I haven't had one add constructive anything to this topic. A troll knows a troll.

Oh, and I've asked you before not to call me Kottie, and you knew it would warrant a response - I guess common courtesy does not apply when your clanmates had his little feelings hurt, eh?

Kotaro you have never asked me not to call you Kottie, please stay on topic. You post was deliberately baiting players. Lets see point by point.
You won't be losing points because of him - no you won't. Trying to suggest other people not play with him is a bit rich, you have been in more strife than he has....
You love how I wouldn't normally post... - I post a lot, though I'm on the site to play not say for the most part. So way off the mark there.
Troll about your vacations - Yes I went off topic there, just as you did, my bad. See point two about you been more of a risk to play with.
A troll knows a troll - Trolls are low ranked sayers rather than players.... Compare and contrast there. I don't need to spell it out.

I have treated you with respect, and joked around with you. At no time did you react in a hurt fashion, you replied in the same fashion. Now crying that you asked not to be called Kottie is just cheap mate. I don't necessarily agree with MrPanzerGeneral starting this thread. I do support his right to start this thread.

[Timminz]

Trolls are low ranked sayers rather than players....

I don't really know anything about any of this, but I don't think redefining words, is going to help your argument.

Rank has nothing to do with trolling. Ironically enough, you're making a good example of that, right now.

[Kotaro]

I love how, in the same thread the OP has posted, that a mod asks for the trolling to stop, and the next post is Bogan trolling me. Priceless really.

[alster]

Accused:

kotaro


The accused are suspected of:

Forum Abuse / Flame Baiting / Trolling

viewtopic.php?f=6&t=97735&p=2230940#p2230940



Comments: as per CC's Forum Guidlines Kotaro's posts rate as Flaming, Trolling. Some consistency in rulings would be excellent.

I skimmed the thread. Not a big deal. Get over it cupcake, you just made this thread 'cause of your love for jefjef. I'm sure you've stralled off-topic in some threads as well. There's a bunch of mods active in the thread, they can handle it. No need to waste peoples' time in the C&A forum.

[chemefreak]

And who said Flame Wars was gone?

btw, i visited the offending thread and was disappointed to see that Kot is being complained about for such a benign post...his posts are usually classics, but this one is not even close to be offensive by his standards

[Captain_Scarlet]

And who said Flame Wars was gone?

btw, i visited the offending thread and was disappointed to see that Kot is being complained about for such a benign post...his posts are usually classics, but this one is not even close to be offensive by his standards

easy to say when you are not frustrated by the situation

Bogan has offered a solution to the jefjef situation - I dont necessarily agree and I am an affected party - if a player is offended he has the right to comment - I dont believe anything was achieved by name calling in an tense situation

[owenshooter]

nothing at all to see here, pretty empty accusation. and isn't this something you two could have resolved within The Book Club forum? Kotaro can be difficult at times, but he generally is on point despite his sometimes harsh delivery. however, i have seen far worse within the forums, and you will probably be told to foe him and move on...-0

[king sam]

this is in the midst of getting 2nd opinions from the C&A Mods.. don't want to pull out my itchy trigger finger again..

pending

King Sam

[Kotaro]

I hope you're avoiding asking the Moderator that has me Foe'd, as that could be considered a Bias'd opinion.

On top of that, choosing the one that I am in a Clan with, would also have the option of being considered bias'd.

[Woodruff]

I hope you're avoiding asking the Moderator that has me Foe'd, as that could be considered a Bias'd opinion.

I wouldn't have thought a Moderator would be allowed to have a user Foe'd...that's disappointing.

[the.killing.44]

I hope you're avoiding asking the Moderator that has me Foe'd, as that could be considered a Bias'd opinion.

I wouldn't have thought a Moderator would be allowed to have a user Foe'd...that's disappointing.

They're allowed to have people foed, they just can't be foed. It's admins who must keep an empty foe list.

[Kotaro]

I hope you're avoiding asking the Moderator that has me Foe'd, as that could be considered a Bias'd opinion.

I wouldn't have thought a Moderator would be allowed to have a user Foe'd...that's disappointing.

They're allowed to have people foed, they just can't be foed. It's admins who must keep an empty foe list.

Which is bullshit, of course, but that's for another thread.

[Kotaro]

I hope you're avoiding asking the Moderator that has me Foe'd, as that could be considered a Bias'd opinion.

On top of that, choosing the one that I am in a Clan with, would also have the option of being considered bias'd.

Which, of course, is in no way saying that Evil Semp would actually base his moderation on his Clan Affiliation, but merely that others might assume as such and use it against me. My apologies to anyone that was offended by the very idea of this.

[lord voldemort]

I have you foe'd because i dont enjoy playing games with you. I still read everyone of your posts

[MrPanzerGeneral]

Accused:

kotaro


The accused are suspected of:

Forum Abuse / Flame Baiting / Trolling

viewtopic.php?f=6&t=97735&p=2230940#p2230940



Comments: as per CC's Forum Guidlines Kotaro's posts rate as Flaming, Trolling. Some consistency in rulings would be excellent.

I skimmed the thread. Not a big deal. Get over it cupcake, you just made this thread 'cause of your love for jefjef. I'm sure you've stralled off-topic in some threads as well. There's a bunch of mods active in the thread, they can handle it. No need to waste peoples' time in the C&A forum.

hey Alster, sticks and stones buddy. I can't help you with your sexuality. but hey, I'm glad I'm wasting your time & bandwidth.

as far as the e ticket goes, Kotaro has also shown a desire in the past for more consistency with forum abuse decisions, well, let him be judged by the same criterion.

[MrPanzerGeneral]

oh, and let me quote Owenshooter here, different thread but really it's all the same...

"it doesn't matter what the intent was, a rule was broken. a rule that was recently ruled upon and made crystal clear. this should be looked at, and not by friends of the accused."

[jefjef]

Flames are posts or parts of posts which, directly or indirectly, insult, belittle, bully, name-call, or otherwise attack another user is not allowed.

# It doesn't matter if another user rubs you the wrong way, that's not an excuse to flame or attack them.

# Attacking a person instead of the user is NOT ok - it's all fun and games until it becomes personal.


Note: kotaro's post will not even have to be twisted and spun and misinterpreted to be found in violation of the RULES and COMMUNITY GUIDELINES.

AND YES being called an asshole is a "personal" attack. AND a flame. AND a trolling post.

A forum ban and a 41 game kick seems to be in order. IMO.

[eye84free]

This post is meant for KOTARO
accused of:

Forum Abuse / Flame Baiting / Trolling

Not for others to rant on about issues that have no baring on this player. If you have no input in reference to this player and what KOTARO is accused of please do not post here. If you feel you have issues with another player who has posted in this topic then please make another post in the forum it belongs.

Eye84free

[Kotaro]

Note: kotaro's post will not even have to be twisted and spun and misinterpreted to be found in violation of the RULES and COMMUNITY GUIDELINES.

AND YES being called an asshole is a "personal" attack. AND a flame. AND a trolling post.

A forum ban and a 41 game kick seems to be in order. IMO.

hey Alster, sticks and stones buddy. I can't help you with your sexuality. but hey, I'm glad I'm wasting your time & bandwidth.

GG though, getting your own friend in trouble in the same post as you grab me should create hilarious talk in your sub-forum.

[jefjef]

This post is meant for KOTARO
accused of:

Forum Abuse / Flame Baiting / Trolling

Not for others to rant on about issues that have no baring on this player. If you have no input in reference to this player and what KOTARO is accused of please do not post here. If you feel you have issues with another player who has posted in this topic then please make another post in the forum it belongs.

Eye84free

This is from the kotaro post on which this complaint is based:

Sucks for his partners, but hell, when you associate yourself with assholes, shit happens.. Think of how piss'd you'll be when you're in a team game with him and
he does get his appropriate website ban.

A flame. A troll. A bait.

41games.

EDIT: 41 games is my new sig. Don't feel like typing jefjef